Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Carlton: Stand Your Ground insurance? It is Florida, after all

Florida facts: We have earned being called the Gunshine State. The National Rifle Association uses our lawmakers as sock puppets. And no pro-gun proposal is too absurd for these parts.

So why should we be surprised at this latest insanity about Florida, guns and The American Way?

As the world knows, this is loud-and-proud Stand Your Ground territory. Our law essentially says: Back down, hell — if I'm scared enough, I get to shoot. Retreat? Don't have to.

So naturally, there's got to be a way to make that law even easier on the gun-toting public.

And hey, maybe someone can earn a buck or two in the process.

This is America, right?

As the Times' Sara DiNatale recently reported, groups called the U.S. Concealed Carry Association and the NRA-affiliated Second Call Defense offer what to my mind you could rightly call SYG insurance.

You know, kind of like car insurance, in case some text­ing fool rear-ends you. Or home insurance, for when the neighbor's oak comes crashing through the roof.

Except this particular service is specifically for customers who presumably think they have a pretty good chance of shooting someone in a confrontation at some point. And they're willing to pay for protection from prosecution.

For a monthly fee — don't worry, there's a platinum package available, too — a customer claiming self-defense can get access to a helpful 24-hour hotline, a lawyer at the ready, bail money and even a handy card for his wallet, telling him the magic words to say to police after he has pulled the trigger: I was attacked and was forced to defend myself.

The U.S. Concealed Carry Association's website has this warning: "You need to have these decisions programmed into your brain BEFORE you leave your house with your gun!"

And yes, it says programmed.

The Times reported on the case of Nick Julian IV, who called the hotline last year after he shot Carlos Garcia following a dispute in Carrollwood over loud music. The dead man did not have a gun. "He attacked me and I had to use force," Julian told 911. "I was afraid for my life." Ultimately, prosecutors said there was insufficient evidence to rebut a claim of self-defense, and he wasn't charged.

Stand Your Ground was sold as every good citizen's All-American right to fight back when confronted by a bad guy and in fear of great harm or death. Its impact is more complicated. A 2012 Times study of Stand Your Ground cases showed the law is applied unevenly, that it has exonerated drug dealers and gang members and people who provoked the confrontation in the first place.

Back when the Stand Your Ground was being debated, level-headed people — including police and prosecutors who deal daily with gun violence — worried it could devalue human life, that it would make it easier to shoot first. That it would embolden people instead of encouraging them to retreat.

So how much potential do you figure a service that tells someone what to do and say and guarantees him a defense might have in terms of emboldening?

A handy insurance policy for the shoot-first crowd? Apparently that's who we are.

Carlton: Stand Your Ground insurance? It is Florida, after all 09/23/16 [Last modified: Friday, September 23, 2016 8:25pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Mel and Betty Sembler's Drug Free America Foundation calls for special marijuana session


    An unlikely voice has joined the drug policy activists calling on Florida lawmakers to come back in special session focused on medical marijuana: The Drug Free America Foundation, which opposes medical marijuana and whose founders spent nearly $10 million trying to kill the 2014 and 2016 constitutional amendments to …

    Mel and Betty Sembler, pictured in 2011.
  2. Gov. Rick Scott signs tax cut bill into law


    It's hardly the $618 million tax cut Gov. Rick Scott asked for four months ago.

  3. Florida joins other states in ending 'tampon tax'


    From our friends at the Associated Press:

  4. Rubio, Nelson propose expansion of federal judgeships


    WASHINGTON - Florida Sens. Marco Rubio and Bill Nelson today proposed adding a number of federal judges to the state.

  5. Bar review: The Landing at Jannus in St. Petersburg

    Bars & Spirits

    I've spent many evenings in St. Pete's Jannus Live courtyard, enjoying one of the best open-air venues in the Tampa Bay area. It's where I saw my first concert in Florida: Toadies, on the Rubberneck tour sometime in the mid '90s.

    The drinks at the Landing at Jannus in St. Petersburg are about as cheap as you’ll find at any other regular downtown bar, a nice surprise.