Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Sue Carlton: Lives ruined for a gun in a park on a quiet Sunday

In all the testimony about what happened in a quiet neighborhood park on a Sunday afternoon, one small detail stood out.

The 69-year-old man came out of his house because he saw a kid skateboarding on the newly resurfaced basketball court and wanted it stopped.

A man in the park with his little girl disagreed.

This should have been the kind of get-off-my-lawn scene that plays out in suburban neighborhoods across America. It should have ended, at worst, in a spat between neighbors and maybe a hot topic for the next homeowners association meeting, right after residents who don't pick up after their dogs.

Except when Trevor Dooley confronted the boy, he was packing a gun. I keep remembering this detail from his testimony this week: He didn't bother putting on his shoes that day, but he did bring his gun.

Twin Lakes is the kind of Valrico community where parents feel safe letting kids ride bikes on winding streets. It has a nice community pool, a huge oak-shaded playground and a guard to keep out potential unpleasantness at night. Dooley carried his .32 in his pocket into a park where a little girl was shooting baskets with her dad, a couple was smacking around a tennis ball and a skinny blond kid was trying to perfect the art of jumping one skateboard over another.

David James, the dad there with his daughter, had already told the kid that skateboarding was okay. He and Dooley argued, then scuffled. James, 41, was shot and killed right there in front of his daughter, who was 8. Two years later, the senselessness is no less stunning.

The manslaughter arrest of Dooley, a school bus driver with a concealed weapons permit and no record, made big news in light of Florida's dubious stand your ground law. His defense: The bigger, younger man attacked, and he had a right to defend himself. He denied witness testimony that he flashed his gun, a weapon his lawyer indicated he carried out of "habit."

Really, though, does the controversy over stand your ground — and the mounting evidence of how it's been unevenly applied across the state — even matter here?

The human cost of the gun that day was everywhere in that courtroom. It was in the testimony of the skinny skateboarder, older and a head taller but still a boy who hung his mop of blond hair on the stand when they played back the 911 call. "It was my fault," he wept then. It was in a daughter without a father for the rest of her life. And it was Dooley's own wife of more than four decades, sitting in a courtroom pew bracketed by family but utterly alone, her face buried in her hands while he testified.

Before NRA types start soapboxing and bossing the Legislature around again, this was not about responsible, legal gun ownership. This was a deadly weapon improperly used, as the jury ultimately found. This was a gun where it never should have been.

It was disturbing that Dooley showed no remorse for the death of a man over something so absurd, even if in his heart he believes he was right. It was also sad to hear him say the guilty verdicts, handed down by a multiracial jury, were because he is black and the man who died was white.

No. It was about a gun in a neighborhood park on Sunday afternoon, and everything that single decision cost.

Sue Carlton: Lives ruined for a gun in a park on a quiet Sunday 11/20/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, November 21, 2012 2:08am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Blake Snell struggles in return as Rays fall to Pirates

    The Heater

    PITTSBURGH — Blake Snell talked a good game ahead of his return to the Rays rotation Wednesday night, but he didn't pitch one.

    ON THE BALL: Rays third baseman Evan Longoria makes the play and the throw during the first inning against the Pirates.
  2. College World Series title puts Florida Gators in elite company


    The Florida Gators put themselves in rare company with Tuesday night's College World Series national championship victory.

    Florida ace and Tampa native Alex Faedo (21) lets loose with his teammates after they win the Gators’ first baseball national title.
  3. Lightning prospects mantra: You never know when NHL chance will appear

    Lightning Strikes

    BRANDON — Brett Howden said he watched closely last season as former junior teammate Brayden Point made an remarkable rise to a Lightning regular in his first year pro.

    Lightning prospect Mikhail Sergachev skates during the Lightning Development Camp Wednesday at the Ice Sports Forum in Brandon. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD   |   Times]
  4. McConnell trying to revise the Senate health care bill by Friday


    WASHINGTON — Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is aiming to send a revised version of his health care bill to the Congressional Budget Office as soon as Friday as he continues to push for a vote before Congress' August recess.

    Protesters rally against the Senate Republican health care bill Wednesday on the east front of the Capitol building.
  5. Police raise likely death toll in London high-rise blaze


    LONDON — The number of people killed or presumed dead in the London high-rise fire has inched up to 80, but the final death toll may not be known for months, British police said at a grim briefing Wednesday.