Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Uneven slicing of Pinellas pie for 19 fire departments has foes, defenders

Six weeks before next year's budget goes into effect, many local fire departments are questioning the fairness of the county's distribution of EMS money.

Faced with dwindling revenues and escalating costs, county officials decided to look at EMS funding in a new way this year.

They established standards for determining how much of the countywide EMS tax revenue that each of Pinellas' 19 fire departments should receive. The goal was to reduce costs and to make funding decisions fair and consistent across the county.

"I understand the logic behind it," St. Pete Beach City Manager Mike Bonfield said. "Everybody understands the issue of funding and budget cuts, (but) some stations are treated differently than others."

Bonfield points to a chart he made comparing the amount of money collected from the 19 fire districts with the amount each receives from the aggregate pot of EMS money. The tax-rich beach communities are "definite losers," he said.

Properties in St. Pete Beach, for example, have an overall taxable value of about $2.3 billion. The city's property owners pay about $1.3 million into the EMS pot, given a countywide EMS rate of about 58 cents per $1,000 of assessed, taxable value. But they only receive about $783,700 from the EMS pot — about a 61 percent difference.

The Lealman Fire District, on the other hand, one of the poorest areas of the county, has an overall taxable value of about $1.1 billion, which translates into a contribution to the county EMS budget of about $616,400. Yet Lealman receives about $1.9 million for EMS services — 306 percent more than its taxpayers contribute.

It's not just Lealman. St. Petersburg contributes about $8.6 million to the EMS aggregate but gets about $11.9 million, or 139 percent, more than its contribution. Pinellas Park's taxpayers get 130 percent back. Safety Harbor gets 121 percent back; Largo, 105 percent.

A rebuttal

St. Petersburg division Chief William Ward and Seminole City Manager Frank Edmunds agree that funding inconsistencies exist, but they say Bonfield's analysis is not a good way to look at EMS funding.

The system is countywide and the money needs to go where there's the most demand, they say. Some of the highest demand is in the areas covered by Lealman, St. Petersburg, Pinellas Park and Largo. That's the midsection of the county with high traffic and a dense population, so the call volume is higher. And those departments — like all in Pinellas — run calls into other areas when needed. Plus, beach residents who travel or work elsewhere may end up using the services of the paramedics in Lealman, St. Petersburg, Pinellas Park or Largo.

Those inequities, Edmunds said, are something people have to accept in order to have a unified countywide service funded by a countywide tax.

Pinellas Park fire Chief Doug Lewis has his own way of looking at the situation. He divided the money provided to each department by the number of paramedic positions funded. Using his analysis, St. Petersburg was the big winner — 22 positions (each consisting of three shifts), each funded at about $541,000. Pinellas Park was at the bottom with seven positions, each funded at about $370,000. Those figures include everything that was funded, not just salaries, but Lewis said it does say something about inequities in pay and benefits among departments and the wisdom of making taxpayers from one place pay for high salaries and benefits elsewhere.

Less tax revenue

Dunedin fire Chief Bud Meyer said the inequities have existed since the county first unified EMS services. And, for a long time, he said, the county paid a fixed amount to each department with an annual cost-of-living increase. The departments chose how to spend that money.

That worked as long as property values kept going up. But with the advent of Amendment 1 and the tanking economy, things changed radically.

And will continue to. The county is conducting a study of EMS and hopes the results of that will help iron out future inequities.

But St. Petersburg's Ward said the answer may lie in breaking the mold, doing things differently. One example, he said, could be to let the fire departments provide transportation to hospitals.

But, even so, he said, inequities will always exist as long as there are 19 departments with different pay and benefit structures.

"I don't know how to get completely around that other than bring everything under one umbrella, which would be a daunting task," Ward said.

Anne Lindberg can be reached at or (727) 893-8450.

Uneven slicing of Pinellas pie for 19 fire departments has foes, defenders 08/25/09 [Last modified: Wednesday, August 26, 2009 11:41am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Inside the Rays continuing historically bad slump


    The numbers tell the story of the Rays inexplicable ongoing offensive slump, and the words detail how tough it has been to deal with.

  2. How Rays' Chris Archer is branching out on Twitter

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Rays RHP Chris Archer has made a name for himself on the mound. And at a time when some athletes work to steer clear of any issue with a tint of controversy for fear it could damage their brand, Archer has used that platform to weigh in on some topical social, political and news events.

    Tampa Bay Rays pitcher Chris Archer (22) leans on the railing of the dugout during the All-Star game at Marlins Park in Miami, Fla. on Tuesday, July 11, 2017. WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times

  3. Candidates for governor get emotional talking about their gay siblings


    Occasionally in today's hyper-rehearsed and contrived world of political campaigns one witnesses moments that are so honest and real, we can't help but understand we're not just listening to another politician give his or her stump speech; We're listening to a human being who understands personal pain at least as well …

    Chris King talking to reporters in Tallahassee
  4. Southern heritage groups sue to keep Confederate monument at old Tampa courthouse

    Local Government

    TAMPA — Groups that say they support Southern heritage filed a lawsuit late Friday trying to halt the removal of a Confederate statue from downtown Tampa.

    Workers place boards around a Confederate monument on Hillsborough County property in Tampa on Thursday, August 17, 2017. It took 24 hours to raise private funds in order to move the statue from its current location.
  5. Bucs mull options at right tackle as Dotson awaits MRI


    Right tackle Demar Dotson, the Bucs' most experienced offensive lineman, will undergo an MRI on his injured groin Saturday, three weeks before the season opener.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneer Demar Dotson, offensive tackle, brought his coffee and breakfast to One Buc Place, 7/31/15, as he reported to training camp.