Monday, April 23, 2018
Public safety

What would be justice for 'stand your ground'?

So he is charged, and everyone can take a breath.

After weeks of intense debate on guns and race and what justice should look like, the most infamous neighborhood watch volunteer in America faces a second-degree murder charge in the shooting of an unarmed teenager.

Now those who criticized the weeks that passed before George Zimmerman was arrested in the death of Trayvon Martin can mark this moment as progress.

But even as lawyers get ready for the serious pretrial wrangling to come and the court case slowly unfolds and we learn about the evidence against him, we shouldn't lose sight of what got us here in the first place:

The overreaching, unnecessary and potentially dangerous law that could still ultimately exonerate him.

By now Florida's "stand your ground" law is pretty infamous, too, steroid-strengthened in 2005 to say you have no obligation to look for alternatives to killing someone if you feel seriously threatened. Even now, no one has come up with any real justification for changing the law as it then existed, beyond making the National Rifle Association happy yet again.

Law enforcement types were understandably worried about emboldening people to provoke confrontations instead of calling police or stepping back to cool down before someone died. Critics talked about the potential for cheapening human life.

We know the law has been interpreted differently depending on where it's used, that a case that results in criminal charges in one part of the state might not in another. This does not exactly inspire confidence about justice evenly applied.

Maybe most alarming, though, is we now know "stand your ground" has protected people from criminal charges even when they were the ones who did the pursuing or started the confrontation.

At this point, everything written about this case should include the caveat that we don't know all the evidence about who said what or what physical evidence shows. We do know Zimmerman told a 911 dispatcher he was following a suspicious teenager in a hoodie. We know he says it was Martin who ultimately attacked him and he had to shoot to protect himself — to stand his ground — even if he initially went after Martin and supporters of the law insist pursuers weren't meant to be protected.

If you think this case is an anomaly, consider one closer to home. Trevor Dooley was 69 when he shot 41-year-old David James in a dispute over a kid skateboarding at a neighborhood basketball court. (And could there be a more senseless reason for someone to die?)

Dooley brought the gun into the situation but says he feared for his life when James came after him. Because authorities say he illegally displayed that gun, and "stand your ground" says the shooter must otherwise be obeying the law at the time, Dooley is charged with manslaughter. Whether the case goes forward is now a question in the hands of a judge.

When everyone up to President Barack Obama was weighing in on the shooting in Sanford, politicians vowed a thorough review of "stand your ground." We'll have to wait to see what justice finally looks like here. But a piece of it would be holding those politicians to their word for serious reconsideration of all this law has wrought.

Comments
Deputies find parents who fled with newborn; 1-month-old is safe

Deputies find parents who fled with newborn; 1-month-old is safe

TAMPA — The 1-month-old infant reported missing Monday was found hours later about 300 miles north in Quincy, according to the Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office.Sage Cooper was reported to be unharmed, officials said, and Gadsden County sheriff’s ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
In search for stolen car, the baby inside was the calmest one

In search for stolen car, the baby inside was the calmest one

ST. PETERSBURG — Photojournalist Michael Egger pulled into the apartment complex off 71st Avenue N on Monday afternoon, waiting for reporter Mark Douglas. The two WFLA-Ch. 8 journalists were looking for someone — they wouldn’t say who — when they fou...
Updated: 2 hours ago
‘Tase me, and you’ll see what happens,’ an American Airlines flier said. Police did - 10 times.

‘Tase me, and you’ll see what happens,’ an American Airlines flier said. Police did - 10 times.

Washington PostWhat began as a simple boarding dispute at Miami International Airport escalated into a tour de force of plane drama on Sunday as a belligerent passenger was repeatedly stunned by police, forcibly carried out of his seat, then driven t...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Deputies: Port Richey man admits molesting, attempting to rape 8-year-old girl

Deputies: Port Richey man admits molesting, attempting to rape 8-year-old girl

NEW PORT RICHEY — A 26-year-old man was arrested Friday on charges that he molested and attempted to rape an 8-year-old girl, according to the Pasco County Sheriff’s Office.Kaleb Harrah, 26, of Port Richey, faces charges of attempted sexual battery o...
Updated: 4 hours ago
FHP: Man struck, killed by SUV while walking in center of road

FHP: Man struck, killed by SUV while walking in center of road

TRINITY — A 49-year-old man was struck and killed early Monday morning by a sport-utility vehicle as he walked in the center of westbound Trinity Boulevard, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.Phillip Meadows, of New Port Richey, was wearing dark...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Did you see who hit panhandler near Selmon and drove away?

Did you see who hit panhandler near Selmon and drove away?

TAMPA — A man with a history of arrests for roadside soliciting has been found dead at the side of a road. Jess Paez, 51, was identified by Tampa police Monday as the victim of an apparent hit-and-run crash over the weekend. His body was found about ...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Police arrest suspect in Waffle House shooting

Police arrest suspect in Waffle House shooting

NASHVILLE, Tenn. — The suspect in a quadruple homicide at a Nashville Waffle House was taken into custody Monday, police said. Authorities had mounted a massive manhunt for 29-year-old Travis Reinking, after the Sunday morning attacks. Authorities an...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Waffle House customer on why he rushed shooter: ‘He was going to have to work to kill me’

Waffle House customer on why he rushed shooter: ‘He was going to have to work to kill me’

Moments before the first shot, James Shaw Jr. was watching a Waffle House employee wash dishes, stacking them higher and higher. When the first shot was fired, Shaw thought the tower of plates had come crashing down, he would later recount at a news ...
Published: 04/23/18
Teen killed in Hernando crash was ‘always smiling and laughing’

Teen killed in Hernando crash was ‘always smiling and laughing’

WEEKI WACHEE — Seth Leathers was on his way to play basketball at his church when he was killed Wednesday in a car crash on U.S. 19 in Spring Hill, according to family friend Laurie Pike.Leathers, 16, was the passenger in a car driven by his friend G...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Deputies: St. Petersburg man on LSD knocks out teen girl at RaceTrac while her parent pumps gas

Deputies: St. Petersburg man on LSD knocks out teen girl at RaceTrac while her parent pumps gas

ST. PETERSBURG — A man punched a 13-year-old girl inside a RaceTrac convenience store Saturday, knocking her unconscious as her parent pumped gas outside, Pinellas deputies reported. Kolbe Wayne Smith, 27, of St. Petersburg now faces charges o...
Published: 04/22/18
Updated: 04/23/18