Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Christmas displays are a public forum, so more should get involved

On the lawn of the old courthouse in downtown Brooksville last week, a wooden sign quotes Scripture celebrating Christ’s birth.


On the lawn of the old courthouse in downtown Brooksville last week, a wooden sign quotes Scripture celebrating Christ’s birth.

I have a clear least favorite among the Christmas cards that show up on the lawn of the old courthouse in downtown Brooksville this time of year.

I'm talking not about standard cards, but the 4- by 8-foot plywood variety, and the one I have in mind carries not a greeting but a brief lecture from Christ, the last part of which is underlined in red for the benefit of us slow learners:

"Keep in mind, no matter how you celebrate Christmas, It's still my birthday."

Christ is also identified as the "Savior of all people" — whether you like it or not, basically. And, as pictured on this card, he looks as stern as Uncle Sam on a military recruiting poster.

That's actually not a bad comparison because the assumption seems to be that there's a war on Christmas and that the folks at Holy Trinity Lutheran Church had no choice but to fire off this defensive salvo.

But the evidence to the contrary is right here in this very display: There is no war on Christmas. Nobody is stopping anybody from expressing their thoughts about the season, even overtly religious thoughts, on highly visible public ground. Hernando County has allowed these cards to be erected here for at least the last 20 years.

It's true that in the past there has been saber rattling of the kind that tends to get conservative Christians fired up. In the late 1990s, a self-described atheist wrote a couple of angry letters to the county, claiming the displays violated the constitutional guarantee of the separation of church and state.

I appreciate that he was on the lookout for this sort of thing; generally, we need more of that around here.

But in this case he was wrong. These cards are protected under the "public forum doctrine," said deputy county attorney Jon Jouben.

Governments can allow religious speech as long as they allow all religious speech. In fact, they get in trouble if they don't allow it, which shows bias against religious rather than secular expression.

Legal principles become firmer every time they are heard in court, Jouben said, and "this has been litigated about 8 billion times."

Which means that if you fear a war on Christmas — don't.

So the only remaining question about the display on the courthouse lawn is this: Is everyone truly welcome?

Absolutely, said Christie Williams, the events coordinator for the county, who has been involved with the courthouse displays since 2000 and remembers one card that carried the message: "Smile, Buddha loves you."

Back in 1997, former Times columnist Jan Glidewell wrote — approvingly, of course — that a local chapter of Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays, P-FLAG, had been allowed to put up a Christmas greeting.

So, it was a little disappointing this year not to see much of this sort of thing.

We might still, because more billboards are on the way, Williams said. But when I checked last week, there was nothing from either the Islamic Center of Hernando County or the county's only synagogue, Temple Beth David.

I'm not talking about defiant, in-your-face displays such as the ones atheists have insisted on erecting in Tallahassee and Chicago this year, and which are at least as divisive as the finger-wagging note from the folks at Holy Trinity Lutheran.

I'm talking about something that might help us get in the true Christmas spirit even as sweat rolls down our foreheads.

Maybe next year, said Temple Beth David's rabbi, Lenny Sarko.

"Peace on earth is a good thing; good will toward men is a good thing, regardless of your religion," Sarko said.


Christmas displays are a public forum, so more should get involved 12/10/13 [Last modified: Tuesday, December 10, 2013 1:25pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Mexicans dig through collapsed buildings as quake kills 225 (w/video)


    MEXICO CITY — Rescuers found a surviving child on Wednesday in the ruins of a school that collapsed in Mexico's magnitude 7.1 earthquake, one of many efforts across the city to try to save people trapped in debris under schools, homes and businesses toppled by the quake that killed at least 225 people.

    A man is rescued from a collapsed building in the Condesa neighborhood after an earthquake struck Mexico City, Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017. The 7.1 earthquake stunned central Mexico, killing more than 100 people. [Associated Press]
  2. Construction starts on USF medical school, the first piece of Tampa's Water Street project


    TAMPA — Dozens of workers in hard hats and boots were busy at work at the corner of South Meridian Avenue and Channelside Drive Wednesday morning, signaling the start of construction on the University of South Florida's new Morsani College of Medicine and Heart Institute.

    A rendering shows what the USF Health Morsani College of Medicine and Heart Institute will look like when completed in 2019. Local officials gathered Wednesday to celebrate as construction begins on the facility, the first piece of the Water Street redevelopment area in downtown Tampa. [Rendering courtesy of the USF Health]
  3. Flooded Withlacoochee River nears crest


    The flooded Withlacoochee River neared its projected crest Wednesday, with expectations that the floodwaters will begin to recede by the weekend.

    LUIS SANTANA   |   Times This aerial drone view shows flooding in the Talisman Estates neighborhood along the Withlacoochee River.
  4. Tampa Electric rules, Duke Energy drools, Hillsborough commissioners declare


    TAMPA — The pile on of Duke Energy continued Wednesday in Hillsborough County, where commissioners boasted how quickly most of their constituents had power after Hurricane Irma.

    Duke Energy workers cut tree limbs off a power line on Sept. 11 following Hurricane Irma.
  5. Whatever USF has to say about Temple waits till Thursday


    "The holes were wide open. Anyone could have run through them."

    South Florida Bulls cornerback Mazzi Wilkins (23) intercepts a pass during the second half of the home opener for the South Florida Bulls against the Stony Brook Seawolves at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Fla., on Saturday, Sept. 2, 2017. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times