Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Minister who did gay wedding is in hot water

The Rev. James Yearsley of Village Presbyterian says the Rev. Janet Edwards, who performed a same-sex marriage, violated the Presbyterian Church constitution and “damaged the body of Christ.”

KEN HELLE | Times (2006)

The Rev. James Yearsley of Village Presbyterian says the Rev. Janet Edwards, who performed a same-sex marriage, violated the Presbyterian Church constitution and “damaged the body of Christ.”

CARROLLWOOD — What began three years ago as a complaint about the marriage of a lesbian couple has put a Carrollwood Presbyterian pastor into the national spotlight.

It was 2005 when the Rev. Janet Edwards, a Presbyterian minister, married Nancy McConn and Brenda Cole in Pittsburgh. James C. Yearsley, who then served in Pittsburgh as well, learned of the ceremony in a newspaper interview Edwards had given.

"I was offended," said Yearsley, now the pastor of Village Presbyterian Church in Carrollwood Village. "What she did in marrying two people of the same sex was a complete violation of the constitution of the Presbyterian Church of the United States of America, and she knew that, but she intentionally violated the constitution."

Yearsley filed an accusation with the Pittsburgh Presbytery, and a one-year investigation ensued to determine if Edwards violated church doctrine and if she should be brought to a trial. The ramifications were dramatic, with many in the denomination around the country taking sides. A trial was ordered, then put off because of the Presbytery had mistakenly missed a deadline.

For those unfamiliar with the trial process: Charges are brought against the accused, who stands before an ecclesiastical court that determines guilt or innocence. The court is called a Permanent Judicial Commission and is composed of ministers and elders elected from within the judicatory having jurisdiction (in this case, the Pittsburgh Presbytery). The panel sits in place of a judge, and there is counsel for the accused.

Yearsley said he could have walked away, but his orthodox convictions led him to re-file the charges, this time with 13 other ministers. Once again there was a yearlong review, which culminated in March with a decision to bring Edwards to trial. All parties are now waiting to hear when the Presbytery will set a trial date.

Yearsley acknowledges that the Presbyterian Church has changed and evolved over hundreds of years. The organization now ordains women, for example. But he insists that the ruling enforcing marriage between only one man and one woman must always remain intact.

"There's a difference between ordaining women and the idea of God's plan for all of humanity," he said. "It's become a cultural issue. But for us, this about the authoritative word of God, which you can't change to make your desire appropriate."

Since the announcement last month, Edwards has entered into reflective prayer and would not speak directly with the media. She did release a statement through her spokeswomen, Ashley Harness, saying, "The Presbyterian Book of Order instructs the church to 'give full expression to the rich diversity within its membership,' and I believe marriage between two women or two men is consistent with this call to inclusiveness, diversity and openness within the church. It is also clear to me that marriage between two men or two women can have all of the characteristics of marriage envisioned in Scripture: fidelity, love, progeny, family, community, companionship and mutual support."

Edwards could be dismissed from the ministry. Whatever the result, Yearsley said he will be satisfied that the church pursued the allegations. He said he harbors no ill feelings toward Edwards.

"Janet has a wonderful gift for mediation, and a very compassionate pastoral heart," Yearsley said. "I just believe theologically what she did was wrong as she damaged the body of Christ."

Contact reporter Sheryl Kay with any religion news at, or call (813) 230-8788.

Minister who did gay wedding is in hot water 04/03/08 [Last modified: Tuesday, April 8, 2008 8:45am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Fennelly: Is Charlie Strong the anti-Freeze?


    The Hugh Sleaze era at Ole Mess is over.

    Hugh Freeze resigned as head football coach Thursday to avoid being fired by Mississippi school officials. For those of you who had NCAA violations and investigations in the pool, you were wrong. Nor was it the defamation lawsuit filed against the school by former Rebels …

    FILE - In this Sept. 5, 2016, file photo, Mississippi coach Hugh Freeze pauses during a timeout in the team's NCAA college football game against Florida State in Orlando, Fla. Freeze has resigned after five seasons, bringing a stunning end to a once-promising tenure. The school confirmed Freeze's resignation in a release Thursday night. Assistant Matt Luke has been named the interim coach. (AP Photo/John Raoux, File) NY176
  2. Editorial: Just another crazy week for Florida government


    This is your state government at work this week:

  3. What to watch this weekend: 'Ozark,' 'Insecure,' 'Midnight, Texas'


    This side of Hell: Midnight, Texas

    Yvonne Orji and Issa Rae in Insecure.
  4. On the Camino de Santiago, Day 17: Think 11 miles of nothing but straight trail and open, flat fields sounds easy? Think again.


    Day 17: Villarmentero de Campos to Lédigos: 33.5 km, 10.25 hours. Total for Days 1-17 = 394 km (245 miles)

  5. Uhuru activist Eritha Cainion speaks up in St. Pete City Council race

    Local Government

    ST. PETERSBURG — Eritha "Akile" Cainion has been one of the most vocal candidates among the crowded field running for the District 6 seat on the St. Petersburg City Council.

    Eritha "Akile" Cainion. [LARA CERRI   |   Times]