Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Clearwater City Council unconcerned about learning of Scientology's detailed plan from newspaper

CLEARWATER — One afternoon in late October, City Manager Bill Horne was invited to the Fort Harrison Hotel where Church of Scientology leader David Miscavige shared details about the church's long-rumored retail strategy.

Until that meeting, elected officials and downtown followers knew Scientology was working on some kind of general business plan, but the church had kept the specifics and overall concept secret.

Miscavige showed Horne and Community Redevelopment Agency director Seth Taylor renderings of a facade overhaul for Cleveland Street and they later learned the church's plan to manage its own retail district through controlling the downtown core, whether by buying property outright or having its parishioners or other willing players as landlords.

Horne said he discussed with City Council members the fact Scientology was working on a general retail plan but didn't report specific details of his October meeting because it was "conceptual."

"It wasn't anything very definitive other than conceptual," Horne said. "I shared with the council that he was going to go after putting together some kind of retail recruitment plan, so I couldn't give them much more specifics than that. There weren't takeaways I could show them."

Since that meeting in October, the church has begun implementation by buying more than $26 million of prime downtown real estate. Although they learned the extent of the church's plan from a Tampa Bay Times article Monday, four of the five City Council members said they are unconcerned about not getting a formal report from the city manager.

"People try to amass property for redevelopment and they don't like the details to be let out," Mayor George Cretekos said. "If this weren't the Church of Scientology, or if this weren't Mr. Miscavige, it may not be a story. … I don't know that it's a lack of transparency that some people are suggesting or thinking. I think it's just a matter of trying to put a plan together that would work, and the details are vague at the present time."

Scientology's plan does not require approval from elected officials or voters, and the church has already hired consultants to help recruit businesses and architects to design a facade renovation of Cleveland Street for when they control all the property.

Only City Council member Doreen Caudell said she is concerned she didn't get a formal briefing of Scientology's retail plan from Horne before learning about it through the Times.

Caudell said she urges Scientology to make a public presentation at the March 16 City Council meeting, but said she will not ask Miscavige herself because "that role belongs to the city manager, especially since he has been apprised of Scientolgy's retail plan since October."

Scientology spokesman Ben Shaw did not respond to an email or phone call for comment on the plan or a request by the Times to interview Miscavige.

City Council member Hoyt Hamilton said despite Scientology's aggressive acquisition of property, he is still skeptical of the concept's future because Miscavige did not provide Horne or Taylor with copies of the renderings.

"Sometimes when you're not willing to let it out of the room, it may not even be true," Hamilton said. "(Horne) was probably like 'well, if I can't show them something, I don't want to describe something that's not true.' That doesn't really concern me."

Vice Mayor Bill Jonson said although he didn't know the extent of Scientology's intentions until the Times story, he still doesn't know the full scope of it and did not expect a report from Horne.

City Council member Bob Cundiff agreed, saying "plans are plans," and it would not have made a difference if Horne shared what he knew or not.

"You can't stop them from buying land," Cundiff said. "Like anybody else they have the freedom to buy what they want to buy. Their interest right now seems to be developing businesses in downtown. …You have to see if they actually do that."

Contact Tracey McManus at or (727) 445-4151. Follow @TroMcManus.

Clearwater City Council unconcerned about learning of Scientology's detailed plan from newspaper 03/09/17 [Last modified: Thursday, March 9, 2017 2:25pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Authors R.L. Stine, Neil DeGrasse Tyson coming to Tampa Bay this week


    AUTHORS: Neil deGrasse Tyson, R. L. Stine, Finn Murphy

    NEW YORK, NY - OCTOBER 12:  Author R.L. Stine attends “Goosebumps” New York premiere at AMC Empire 25 theater on October 12, 2015 in New York City.  (Photo by Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images)
  2. Brothers' fatal shootout at Plant City ranch draws lawsuit from survivor


    TAMPA — George "Terry" Long escaped with his life last spring when his wife's ex-husband tried to gun him down at Plant City's Rocking V Ranch.

    This Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office photo shows part of the scene at the Rocking V ranch in Plant City where two brothers were shot dead April 15 during a family confrontation. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  3. Florida Gators' Jordan Sherit out for the year after hip surgery


    Florida Gators defensive lineman Jordan Sherit will miss the rest of the season after undergoing hip surgery earlier this week, coach Jim McElwain said Wednesday morning.

    "It's a bad deal, man," McElwain said.

  4. 5 things to do under $5: Wiener dog racing, Streetcar Festival, Clearwater chalk art, Dia De Los Muertos


    1Wienerfest: They had us at wiener dog racing. This day devoted to dachshunds features racing, a dog costume contest, food trucks, photo booth and raffles at the Florida State Fairgrounds on Saturday. Leashed dogs of all breeds welcome. 10 a.m.-4 p.m. Saturday. 4802 U.S. 301 N, Tampa. Free admission. (407) …

    An entry in the costume contest from 2015's annual Dia de los Muertos Fiesta, or Day of the Dead Festival, hosted by Casa Tina's Mexican Restaurant.
photo courtesy Mikell Herrick
  5. Locale Market changes yet again, rebranding the restaurant as FarmTable Cucina

    Food & Dining

    When Locale Market opened in Sundial St. Pete in Dec. 2014, it was the most-hyped, most-anticipated gourmet market/food hall/culinary playground Tampa Bay had ever seen. Since then, celebrity chef-owner Michael Mina has done what every entrepreneur does in the face of challenges: tinker.

    Chef Michael Mina and chef Jeffrey Hileman work in the kitchen at Farmtable Kitchen in 2016. EVE EDELHEIT   |   Times