Monday, October 22, 2018
News Roundup

Federal judge to rule on validity of Scientology's refund process

TAMPA — A federal judge on Thursday urged both sides in a lawsuit over the Church of Scientology's fundraising tactics to settle matters on their own before he is forced to make "a difficult decision" after two days of hearings.

If they don't come to an agreement — and there was no indication they would — U.S. District Judge James D. Whittemore said he will focus on whether the church has a valid procedure in place to arbitrate money disputes with former parishioners.

The plaintiffs, Luis and Rocio Garcia, spent $1.3 million on services and causes over 28 years, and are seeking a refund.

The church contends the couple must go through a "Committee of Evidence" to be considered for a refund. But the couple argues there are no such procedures in place.

According to testimony this week, church policy governing Committees of Evidence never mentions arbitration, and there has never been an arbitration in the history of the church. Whittemore said there is no basis for what one would look like.

Much of Thursday's testimony related to whether someone who leaves or is expelled from the church would be treated fairly by a panel made up of Scientologists in good standing, as required for a Committee of Evidence.

Former Scientologists Hayden James and Christie Collbran told stories about how the church's "disconnection" policies forced family members still in the church to disown relatives who left.

But Whittemore said the First Amendment prevents him from putting any weight on such testimony, no matter how persuasive.

"I have no authority to delve into the beliefs, doctrines, tenets of this organization that calls itself a church," he said.

He also expressed frustration with former church members using their time on the witness stand to air grievances instead of focusing on the arbitration issue.

"This is not a forum to fight with the church," Whittemore said. "I am not going to be dragged into these disputes."

Church attorney F. Wallace Pope Jr. said a Committee of Evidence can conduct an arbitration because it is in charge of all matters of justice. But Whittemore asked for more information to explain the connection between a Committee of Evidence and the arbitration clause in the enrollment agreement parishioners must sign whenever they take a church course or use a service. The Garcias say they signed many such agreements.

Their attorney, Theodore Babbitt, countered that the arbitration clause and the Committee of Evidence policies are inconsistent and polar opposites, and the church would be making up the process as it went.

Contact Caitlin Johnston at [email protected] or (813) 661-2443. Follow @cljohnst

Comments
Buccaneers AfterMath: Dirk Koetter chooses his inconsistent kicker over his inconsistent quarterback

Buccaneers AfterMath: Dirk Koetter chooses his inconsistent kicker over his inconsistent quarterback

TAMPA — By beating the Browns 26-23 in overtime Sunday, the Buccaneers snapped a three-game losing streak and Tampa Bay breathed a collective sigh of relief.It wasn’t pretty, the kind of game the NFL should move to 4 a.m. to hide it from ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Cool! Fall has finally arrived in Tampa Bay

Cool! Fall has finally arrived in Tampa Bay

Folks waiting for fall can finally rejoice. A brisk morning will lead to a pleasant day in Tampa Bay, and highs this week will remain in the mid to upper 80s -- with an even cooler weekend forecast.
Updated: 1 hour ago
Numbers to know from the Lightning’s record-setting night

Numbers to know from the Lightning’s record-setting night

CHICAGO — The Lightning always strives to put up a high volume of shots in every game.But there is a high volume of shots, and then there's what the Lightning put together Sunday against the Blackhawks in the second period.Lightning players pep...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Florida Gators preparing for top-10 showdown with Georgia

Florida Gators preparing for top-10 showdown with Georgia

GAINESVILLE — As No. 9 Florida prepares for to play No. 7 Georgia on Saturday, the Gators aren't putting any extra attention on a top-10 matchup, the appearance of ESPN's College GameDay or any of the other hoopla surrounding the rivalry's...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Hooper: Stand up for the arts, vote no on Amendment 1

Hooper: Stand up for the arts, vote no on Amendment 1

The Tampa Bay Businesses for Culture and the Arts put everything I love about the arts on display at its annual gala on Oct. 18.I only wish legislative leaders had joined the group in saluting the grace of artist Mernet Larsen, the innovation of the ...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Veteran blames fight over football on TV in shooting deaths of girlfriend and her son, 10

Veteran blames fight over football on TV in shooting deaths of girlfriend and her son, 10

TAMPA — A man accused of shooting his live-in girlfriend and her 10-year-old son told deputies they attacked him after an argument over changing the channel to watch a football game, an arrest report says.But evidence at the scene contradicts that st...
Updated: 2 hours ago
News at noon: Argument over TV blamed for double homicide; greyhound racing amendment is getting ugly; and more

News at noon: Argument over TV blamed for double homicide; greyhound racing amendment is getting ugly; and more

Here are the top five latest headlines and updates on tampabay.com.
Updated: 2 hours ago
Cops should get body cameras before cell phones get them

Cops should get body cameras before cell phones get them

It’s happened again. Another snippet of video. Another Florida cop being questioned. This time, it’s in Coral Springs, and the cop is punching the midsection of a 14-year-old girl who is pinned on the ground with two cops above her, and ...
Updated: 3 hours ago
When you gotta go, you gotta go, right? Deputies arrest man after he enters Spring Hill home, uses the bathroom

When you gotta go, you gotta go, right? Deputies arrest man after he enters Spring Hill home, uses the bathroom

SPRING HILL — A Palm Harbor man was arrested Saturday after Hernando deputies said he drunkenly pulled his convertible into a driveway, went inside a home and used the toilet.Daniel Alfred Jenk, 40, faces charges of burglary, driving under the influe...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Pasco to promote itself as Florida's Sports Coast

Pasco to promote itself as Florida's Sports Coast

Pasco County's tourism effort will rebrand itself as Florida's Sports Coast to capitalize on facilities for team and individual sports and outdoor adventure activities.
Updated: 3 hours ago