Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

St. Pete Beach couple in court again over private beach

An aerial image from Google Maps shows Chet and Katherine Chmielewski's home, indicated with a blue marker, just south of the Loews Don CeSar Hotel in St. Pete Beach.


An aerial image from Google Maps shows Chet and Katherine Chmielewski's home, indicated with a blue marker, just south of the Loews Don CeSar Hotel in St. Pete Beach.

ST. PETE BEACH — The First Amendment Foundation has entered an appeals case alleging that the City Commission violated the state's Sunshine Law.

The court action involves an ongoing and sometimes bitter dispute over the public use of beach property in front of a Pass-a-Grille home south of the Loews Don CeSar Hotel.

Chet and Katherine Chmielewski began their battle with the city in 2006 because of city-sponsored events they say encourage the public to use their private beach.

The couple purchased their home in the 1970s at about the same time the city acquired several adjacent lots from the federal government. Now the site of the Don Vista Community Center, the property includes a federal restriction against public beach access from the center.

The Chmielewskis won the 2006 case in federal court. The city agreed in a formal settlement that the couple owns the beach-front property all the way to the mean high water line on the Gulf of Mexico.

The settlement also stipulated that the Chmielewskis' beach property was "dedicated to the use of the property owners … for beach and bathing purposes, and no tents, vehicles nor structures of any kind shall be permitted."

In 2009, the Chmielewskis took the city to court again, alleging that the city was still using their land, a practice they said amounted to illegal taking without compensation.

They contended that their property was being "consistently invaded by the public traversing across their property, peering into their windows, sitting and leaning on their back patio, (and) walking dogs along their property walkway."

The case is before the U.S. District Court in Tampa. As part of that case, the Chmielewskis' lawyers asked for copies of a private meeting between the City Commission and its attorneys that occurred in a 2008 before the 2006 case was settled.

When the Circuit Court, which has jurisdiction over the Sunshine Law, denied that request, saying the underlying cases were essentially the same, the Chmielewskis took the matter to the 2nd District Court of Appeal.

In its amicus brief filed last week, the foundation supports that appeal.

According to the foundation, if the lower court ruling were allowed to stand it would "substantially expand the limited exemption to Florida's Sunshine Law" that applies to government entities and their attorneys.

The group also argues that because of the year's time between the two cases, the 2008 shade meeting transcript was effectively made public and could not revert to protected status under the Sunshine Law.

The foundation also stresses that a 1993 amendment to the Sunshine Law allows government entities to meet privately with their attorneys "only to discuss settlement negotiations or strategy related to litigation expenditures."

"The stated basis for the trial court's ruling is contrary to Florida law … If the trial court order is allowed to stand, government entities will be allowed to keep shade meeting transcripts out of the public eye long after litigation is concluded — perhaps in perpetuity," the foundation brief states.

The Chmielewskis are seeking the shade meeting transcripts because they think the commission and its attorneys may have discussed how to circumvent the federal court to allow public use of the beach in front of their home, their attorney Stephen Turner said Tuesday.

"It is an interesting case. The question is, do the Chmielewskis have rights and are those rights being trampled on," Turner said.

Susan Churuti, one of the city's attorneys, maintains that the two cases are still active and connected and therefore the closed meeting is protected by the Sunshine Law.

St. Pete Beach couple in court again over private beach 01/28/14 [Last modified: Wednesday, January 29, 2014 10:23am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Joe Maddon: What my time in Tampa Bay meant — and still means — to me

    The Heater

    Editor's note: The Rays next week in Chicago will meet up for the first time with former manager Joe Maddon, who is in his third year leading the Cubs after nine with the Rays. In advance of the Tuesday-Wednesday series, we asked Maddon to share his thoughts in a column on what his time in Tampa Bay meant to …

    Joe Maddon waits to greet B.J. Upton after Upton's home run in Game 2 of the ALCS in 2008 at Tropicana Field. [Times files (2008)]
  2. First WannaCry, now cyberattack Petya spreads from Russia to Britain


    Computer systems from Russia to Britain were victims of an international cyberattack Tuesday in a hack that bore similarities to a recent one that crippled tens of thousands of machines worldwide.

    A computer screen cyberattack warning notice reportedly holding computer files to ransom, as part of a massive international cyberattack, at an office in Kiev, Ukraine, on Tuesday.  A new and highly virulent outbreak of malicious data-scrambling software appears to be causing mass disruption across Europe.
[Oleg Reshetnyak via AP]
  3. Pinellas sheriff's corporal had racist, sexist, pornographic content on his cell phone

    Public Safety

    LARGO — A Pinellas County sheriff's corporal resigned recently after an investigation into an alleged extramarital affair revealed a trove of racist, sexist and pornographic images on his personal cell phone.

    Shawn Pappas, 46, resigned as a training division corporal from the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office after an investigation revealed a trove of offensive images and videos on his phone. This photo was taken as a screenshot from one of the videos released by the Sheriff's Office that Pappas filmed while on duty. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
  4. Sen. Angus King, I-Maine reflects on the news from the Congressional Budget Office analysis that could imperil GOP leaders' hopes of pushing their health care the plan through the chamber this week, Tuesday, on Capitol Hill in Washington. [AP photo]
  5. Review: Dan Auerbach, Benjamin Booker plumb the past for inspiration on new albums

    Music & Concerts

    It didn't take Benjamin Booker long to get lumped in with the greats. The Tampa-raised singer-songwriter's 2014 self-titled blues-punk debut brought widespread acclaim, not to mention an appearance on The Late Show with David Letterman, a tour with Jack White and sessions with Mavis Staples.

    The cover of Benjamin Booker's new album "Witness." Credit: ATO Records