Tuesday, June 19, 2018
News Roundup

St. Petersburg property appraiser calls for reform of oversight system

ST. PETERSBURG — Frank Gregoire is proud to be the "slowest property appraiser in Florida."

He always takes extra time to evaluate market data and conduct a thorough evaluation before he determines the value of a house.

Thanks to new regulations, which require a third party — usually an appraisal management company — to act as a go-between for appraisers and mortgage lenders, he is one of the few appraisers that do.

The appraisal management companies control about 80 percent of the business, Gregoire said, and they hire appraisers based on cost and turnaround time rather than qualifications. Those appraisers are then pressured to sway their evaluations and finish their reports as quickly as possible.

A former chairman of the Florida Real Estate Appraisal Board and the appraisal committee for the National Association of Realtors, Gregoire, 59, testified before a congressional committee on Thursday about the impact of the new appraisal oversight rules.

He told the Tampa Bay Times in an interview Friday that the system has threatened appraisers' ability to conduct thorough and objective appraisals.

Why is it so important for appraisers to be independent and objective?

The appraiser is the only one, whether during a sale or a refinance, that is not an advocate for any party. The appraiser is paid strictly for their appraisal report. The appraiser's job is to call things the way they see it. When any party to the transaction attempts to influence the appraiser to be conservative or optimistic about value, the appraiser's obligation is to ignore it. The sad fact is that under the current scheme it's very difficult to do that.

How so?

(The appraisal management companies) control the bulk of the business because they handle accounts for the big banks, the ones that are making the loans these days. If an appraiser is getting the bulk of his business from a handful of appraisal management companies, and he fails to respond to the pressure that's imposed on him or just decides he doesn't want to work for them, he may be giving up a huge percentage of his business.

What kind of pressure is being put on those appraisers?

I don't work for AMCs, so I don't have firsthand knowledge of it. The whole rub now is that appraisers are not recognizing that we have some positive signs in the market. With my belief that an appraiser should be calling it the way he sees it — good, bad or indifferent — he also has an obligation to use the market data to figure out what the property is worth today.

For my testimony (at the congressional hearing), I asked appraisers if they (adjusted their appraisals for a recent increase in home values). Some said yes, they had. But both of them said when they submitted the report to either the lender or the AMC, they were told to "rethink" it. They don't say change the adjustment, they say rethink it. I call that interference with an appraiser's independence.

What effect does that have on home buyers?

In my experience, people that buy houses are not stupid. It's a big decision and they don't make a decision in a day or two. They spend time examining the market, they negotiate. That negotiation is a pretty good indication of what the property is worth. The appraiser's job is not to validate that, but part of the information that he should be considering is that agreement. That is a piece of market information. There's plenty of evidence that appraisal management companies and lenders are not allowing the appraisers to do that job.

You also testified that these companies are hiring appraisers based on low fees and quick turnaround time, which means they are working with less-experienced appraisers. How does that affect the home buyer?

If you're buying a house, and you're worried about the market, making a big decision and obligating yourself to 20 or 30 years worth of payments, you don't want somebody going through just filling out blanks on a form or rubber-stamping it.

What do you think is the solution?

We need to find an alternative to the appraisal management company model, or make sure the appraiser is given the necessary independence. We encouraged the lender to pay the appraisal management company, rather than the borrower paying an appraisal fee. The National Association of Realtors recommended that appraisers be selected based on license level, their knowledge, experience and geographic competency, not based on their fee and turnaround time.

Obviously, that's a tough thing to do because everyone shops for time and price, but this is too important to borrowers and too important to lenders. Lenders may not be making the loans that they could be making.

There also needs to be transparency in the fees. Some of these appraisal management companies are owned by the banks, and I believe that if a borrower is paying for a service, he deserves to know if a piece of that fee is going to the bank and is pure profit.

Comments
Rays’ Kevin Kiermaier returns, with energy to spare

Rays’ Kevin Kiermaier returns, with energy to spare

HOUSTON — Energy.That's what Kevin Kiermaier said he felt he'd provide most in rejoining the Rays Tuesday against the Astros after missing two-plus months recovering from thumb surgery."I like to think I bring energy on both sides of the ball, ...
Updated: 10 minutes ago
Rays journal: Blake Snell outlasts Justin Verlander in 2-1 win

Rays journal: Blake Snell outlasts Justin Verlander in 2-1 win

HOUSTON — The starting pitcher walked seven over seven otherwise solid innings Tuesday. That seemed weird enough for the Rays. Then the next pitcher they brought in was the one who started Monday's game. Even more bizarre.And then there was thi...
Updated: 20 minutes ago
As Tesla races to meet Model 3 deadline, factory pressures and suspicions grow

As Tesla races to meet Model 3 deadline, factory pressures and suspicions grow

Tesla chief Elon Musk said last week that the company’s layoffs of 9 percent of its workforce wouldn’t affect production as the all-electric automaker races to build thousands of new Model 3 sedans a week.But documents the company filed days later wi...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Norris Trophy could be good consolation for Lightning’s Victor Hedman

Norris Trophy could be good consolation for Lightning’s Victor Hedman

Victor Hedman is talking from a hotel room in Las Vegas and admits he's a little jet-lagged."Actually, very jet-lagged," Hedman says.That's what happens when you take a flight from Sweden to the party capital of the world.But he knows exactly what he...
Updated: 5 hours ago

Hillsborough school district will pursue two kinds of local taxes

TAMPA — Hillsborough County School District officials took an important step Tuesday toward asking the voters to pay higher taxes for schools that, they say, are not getting enough money from the state.The board voted 5-0 to submit a tax referendum r...
Updated: 5 hours ago
New Port Richey man faces sexual battery charge

New Port Richey man faces sexual battery charge

NEW PORT RICHEY — A 33-year-old man was arrested Monday on a charge of sexual battery, accused of assaulting a 10-year-old girl.Jonathan Wells was booked into the Pasco County jail, where he was being held Tuesday without bail.The assault took place ...
Updated: 6 hours ago

House bill would detain families — togetherThe Republican House compromise bill on immigration would end the family separation issue at the border — but Democrats won’t support it. The bill mandates that the Department of Homeland Security hold any a...
Updated: 7 hours ago

WashingtonSenate approves $716B for 2019 military budgetThe U.S. Senate on Monday voted to give the military $716 billion for 2019, approving one of the biggest defense budgets in modern American history despite concerns from some economists and lawm...
Updated: 7 hours ago
For starters: Rays at Astros, with Kiermaier back and an ace-high matchup

For starters: Rays at Astros, with Kiermaier back and an ace-high matchup

UPDATE, 6:45: Cash said Smith will continue to play a lot, getting time in LF and RF, meaning something of a rotation system for rookie Johnny Field and veteran Carlos Gomez.UPDATE, 4:49: Kiermaier is batting leadoff and playing center as expected, w...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Romano: A Tampa Bay ‘superstar’ caught in the crosshairs of Trump’s border policy

Romano: A Tampa Bay ‘superstar’ caught in the crosshairs of Trump’s border policy

At this moment, she is Tampa Bay’s most influential export. A smart, accomplished and powerful attorney making life-altering decisions on an international stage.But what of tomorrow? And the day after?When the story of President Donald Trump’s border...
Updated: 7 hours ago