Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Supreme Court questions limits on gun rights

WASHINGTON — Thousands of former gun owners who have a misdemeanor conviction for assaulting or threatening a spouse or girlfriend could have their gun rights restored because of a flaw in the federal law.

That prospect grew more likely Monday after the Supreme Court gave a skeptical hearing to a government lawyer who argued that a crime of domestic violence should result in a loss of gun rights.

Neither families nor police officers should face "the powder keg situation of a domestic offender with a gun," said Nicole Saharsky, a Justice Department lawyer.

But she ran into sharp questioning from justices who said the law was badly written.

Congress sought in 1996 to strengthen the laws against domestic violence. Before, only people convicted of violent felonies in such situations lost their rights to own a gun. Going a step further, lawmakers adopted an amendment to take gun rights from those who had a "misdemeanor crime of domestic violence" on their records.

Sen. Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., its sponsor, said he was closing a loophole. In domestic violence cases, local prosecutors often agree to have defendants plead guilty to a misdemeanor assault or battery, which usually calls for less than a year in jail, he said.

"There is no reason for someone who beats their wives or abuses their children to own a gun. When you combine wife-beaters and guns, the end result is more death," Lautenberg said on the Senate floor.

Last year, a U.S. appeals court in Virginia cast doubt on the reach of the law. Its judges decided the federal gun ban did not cover misdemeanor convictions involving assault at home. Instead, it said the federal ban applied to persons who were convicted under a state's domestic violence law.

That would make the federal gun law "a dead letter in two-thirds of the states," the government's lawyer said. She said most states do not have misdemeanor laws on domestic violence.

Justice Antonin Scalia was unswayed by that argument. "People are governed by the law that is passed, not by the law that Congress intended to pass," he said. He and Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. said the law as written appeared to apply only to domestic violence measures, not the more common assault-and-battery laws.

The case of U.S. vs. Hayes heard Monday does not turn on the Second Amendment but instead on how the justices read the words of the 1996 law.

"This statute is a mess," Justice Anthony M. Kennedy commented at one point.

>>Fast facts

Next on agenda

In a closely watched case, justices will consider on Wednesday when cities and states can be compelled to display donated monuments that may contain religious messages. The resulting decision could shape what public parks look like nationwide.

Supreme Court questions limits on gun rights 11/10/08 [Last modified: Thursday, November 4, 2010 9:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Good news: Tampa Bay no longer a major foreclosure capital of the country

    Real Estate

    Once in the top five nationally for foreclosure filings, the Tampa Bay area no longer ranks even in the top 25.

    A few short years ago, Tampa Bay was a national hub for foreclosures. Not any more. [Getty Images/iStockphoto]
  2. Largo promotes Joseph Pennino to deputy fire chief

    Public Safety

    LARGO — The city has a new deputy fire chief after Dave Mixson left the post to take a job as chief and director of public safety of the South Pasadena Fire Department.

    Largo Deputy Fire Chief Joseph Pennino
  3. State Attorney announces expansion of Hillsborough juvenile civil citation program

    Courts

    TAMPA — Kids who, for the first time, commit certain minor crimes in Hillsborough County may now avoid a criminal conviction by completing a civil citation program.

    Thursday's announcement of civil citations for first-time juvenile offenders in Hillsborough County marked the fulfillment of a campaign promise by State Attorney Andrew Warren.
  4. Pinellas County approves settlement with Suncoast fire district

    Public Safety

    SEMINOLE — County commissioners on Tuesday approved a settlement with the Pinellas Suncoast Fire and Rescue District, closing out a lawsuit filed last year by the district over millions of dollars of emergency medical services funding.

  5. Attorney general has no plans to resign despite Trump rebuke

    Nation

    WASHINGTON — Attorney General Jeff Sessions said he has no immediate plans to resign a day after President Donald Trump excoriated the nation's top prosecutor for recusing himself from the probe of suspected Russian meddling in the 2016 campaign.

    In this July 12 file photo, Attorney General Jeff Sessions speaks in Las Vegas. President Donald Trump says he never would have appointed Sessions as attorney general had he known Sessions would recuse himself from overseeing the Russia investigation. Trump makes the extraordinary statement about Sessions in an interview with the New York Times Wednesday. [AP Photo/John Locher, File]