Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Teachers sue to block voters from lifting ban on public funding of religious groups

TALLAHASSEE — A constitutional amendment to lift the ban on public funding of religious groups should be ripped from the 2012 ballot because it's "misleading and insufficiently specific," according to a lawsuit filed by Florida's largest teachers union Wednesday in Leon County Circuit Court.

"This is designed to open the state treasury to voucher schools, but this is not what the ballot summary says," said Andy Ford, president of the Florida Education Association.

Advocates for private school vouchers, however, say the constitutional amendment would simply let the state deliver education, health care and social services irrespective of a provider's religious affiliation.

"Unions are more interested in protecting political monopolies than ensuring every Floridian has access to the high-quality services that best fit their needs," said Jaryn Emhof, a spokeswoman for Foundation for Florida's Future, former Gov. Jeb Bush's education think tank.

By attacking the ballot summary as "misleading," the teachers union takes aim at a sensitive issue for the Republican lawmakers, who have watched in recent years as the Florida Supreme Court used that very reason to block a series of constitutional changes from the ballot.

In response to the legal challenges, the GOP-controlled Legislature passed a law this year requiring the attorney general to fix any ballot titles or summaries that a court deems problematic and return it to the ballot within 10 days.

The teachers union is also trying to reverse that law in its suit, saying it violates the separation powers provision in the state Constitution.

But, even if the teachers are successful on both counts, lawmakers would get another shot at the 2012 ballot when they return for their annual lawmaking session in January.

Sen. Thad Altman, a Melbourne-area Republican who introduced the measure in the Senate two years ago, has argued that school vouchers were not the primary reason he pushed for the change.

"Ultimately," Altman said, "we will prevail."

In 2006, the state Supreme Court halted the so-called Opportunity Scholarship voucher program, which paid private school tuition for students in failing public schools, because it violated a constitutional requirement for a uniform system of public schools.

But the ban on public funding of religious institutions, known as the Blaine Amendment, was cited by the 1st District Court of Appeal in an earlier ruling against the program.

Altman said his change would align the Florida and U.S. constitutions.

"This is about religious organizations not being discriminated against," Altman said. "I don't think this, in any way, shape or form, changes the court's decision on vouchers."

But attorneys for the teachers union said the change goes beyond squaring the two constitutions.

Instead of giving religious institutions the right to public funding in the U.S. Constitution, plaintiffs argue the Florida change would mandate it.

Union attorneys, led by Ron Meyer, also argue the ballot summary falsely implies the change is required by U.S. Constitution.

Meyer also said the ballot title of "religious freedom" is deceptive.

The term is copy-and-pasted from the section of the state Constitution that contains the ban.

But the nine plaintiffs, including St. Petersburg Revs. Harold Brockus and Bobby Musengwa, say the phrase commonly refers to the right to practice religion without government interference.

"The amendment does not promote such freedom," according to the lawsuit.

Michael C. Bender can be reached at [email protected] or (850) 228-2048. Follow him on Twitter @MichaelCBender.

>>Fast facts

Change proposed for state constitution

Amendment 7 would delete this sentence from the Florida Constitution: "No revenue of the state or any political subdivision or agency thereof shall ever be taken from the public treasury directly or indirectly in aid of any church, sect, or religious denomination or in aid of any sectarian institution."

And replace it with this: “Except to the extent required by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, neither the government nor any agent of the government may deny to any individual or entity the benefits of any program, funding, or other support on the basis of religious identity or belief."

Here is the ballot title and summary:

RELIGIOUS FREEDOM — Proposing an amendment to the State Constitution to provide, consistent with the United States Constitution, that no individual or entity may be denied, on the basis of religious identity or belief, governmental benefits, funding, or other support and to delete the prohibition against using revenues from the public treasury directly or indirectly in aid of any church, sect, or religious denomination or in aid of any sectarian institution.

Teachers sue to block voters from lifting ban on public funding of religious groups 07/20/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, July 20, 2011 9:03pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. FBI: Florida man sympathized with IS, wanted to bomb mall


    MIAMI (AP) — A Florida man who described himself as a sympathizer of the Islamic State extremist group faces terrorism-related charges stemming from a purported plot to bomb a Miami-area shopping mall, according to court documents filed Monday.

    An undated file image posted on an extremist website on Jan. 14, 2014, shows fighters from the Islamic State group marching in Raqqa, Syria. The group champions a hyper-religious lifestyle grounded in a self-proclaimed caliphate, but most recruits have a superficial understanding of religion and are largely ignorant in the laws of Islam. [Militant photo, via Associated Press]
  2. Frog Pond restaurant opens new location in downtown St. Petersburg


    There's a new option for breakfast and lunch in downtown St. Petersburg.

    Frog Pond's original location, seen here in 2006, has been open in North Redington Beach for 35 years. A new Frog Pond restaurant opened in St. Petersburg this week.
  3. Estuary wins pier design contest for the Lee Roy Selmon Expressway extension

    Real Estate

    TAMPA — And the winner is… Estuary.

    Voters overwhelmingly supported a pier design called Estuary for the $200-million extension of the Lee Roy Selmon Expressway in Tampa.
[Courtesy of AECOM]
  4. What to watch and listen to this week: Halloween offerings, best spooky podcasts


    Halloween is all about scary stories. The holiday itself is based on a compilation of creepy tales from history going back thousands of years.

    The Halloween kids classic The Nightmare Before Christmas airs this week on Freeform.
  5. Fennelly: Would you take Jameis Winston over Cam Newton?


    Factoring out futures, it wouldn't be a short list if I picked NFL quarterbacks I'd take right now over Bucs quarterback Jameis Winston.

    Bucs quarterback Jameis Winston (3) calls a play during the first half of Sunday's game. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]