Saturday, August 18, 2018
Transportation

Romano: Are buses really our last gasp?

To the members of the Tampa Bay Transportation Management Area Leadership group:

Listen carefully when a new plan for a rapid bus system is unveiled to you on Friday. All the benefits the supporters will tout will undoubtedly be true.

A rapid bus system will be cheaper than rail.

It will be more flexible.

It could be up and running much quicker.

In fact, when all is said and done, the only possible drawback is this:

Everything else.

Pardon me if that sounds too negative. Honestly, itís not intended to be. At this point, I think the concept of bus rapid transit (or BRT, as it is commonly known) has greater potential than rail around here.

But it has to be nearly flawless. It has to be approached as the best solution, and not a consolation prize. In other words, do not simply accept the recommendation because youíre tired of waiting for rail.

Rapid bus systems have seen success in other countries and in some American cities, but they also have revealed some flaws in the system. So, while it may be more appealing to spend millions on buses instead of billions on rail, it will still be a waste of money if it isnít done right.

For instance Ö

It must operate like a train. That means riders pay at the station, or on their phones, so when the bus stops, every door opens and riders have 10-12 seconds to hop on or off. No standing by the driver looking for coins or a bus pass while everyone else waits. This has been a problem in San Diego where some stations did not have a prepay option.

For instance Ö

Existing local routes cannot be robbed to pay for rapid routes catering to wealthier riders. Pittsburgh is currently dealing with this issue. The cost of providing a rapid line from the suburbs to downtown could mean eliminating routes for working-class people who depend on bus service.

For instance Ö

You canít really call it a BRT line if doesnít have its own exclusive lane. If itís travelling behind cars, itís not really rapid. Itís just another bus. A Minneapolis line that had to exit the highway for a portion of its route was far less successful than a second line that more accurately mimicked light rail.

For instance Ö

There must be a commitment to build new lanes, as opposed to repurposing existing traffic lanes. If reducing rush-hour congestion is a major consideration, then youíre probably defeating your purpose by eliminating one lane of traffic. Itís like a mathematical equation. If you have 10 cars per minute per lane, then a bus that uses a dedicated lane once every 10 minutes would theoretically have to carry more than 100 passengers to make up for a lost lane.

As you can see, the philosophy of a cheaper, more fluid bus system can be appealing, but that doesnít mean it is either simple or guaranteed for success.

Transportation leaders seem confident that they will be able to draw down money from both state and federal governments to get the project off the ground, but it will still have costs at the local level to build and operate. That means convincing residents/voters that this will work.

And that means a plan with plenty of details and answers. That means convincing residents that they want to leave their cars behind for a slick-looking bus with comfortable seats, free Wi-Fi and a faster commute. That means providing many of the advantages of a subway without the construction cost.

So, yes, itís worth giving Fridayís pitch plenty of time and attention.

After all, it looks like weíve already missed the train.

Comments
Have you made up your mind on a transportation sales tax? Many candidates havenít

Have you made up your mind on a transportation sales tax? Many candidates havenít

TAMPA ó Some 77,000 people signed a petition to place a sales-tax hike for transportation on the Nov. 6 ballot, but many of the 17 people seeking seats on the Hillsborough County Commission say theyíre still making up their minds.Some candidates aren...
Published: 08/17/18
Transportation activists hope to pave over past referendum defeats

Transportation activists hope to pave over past referendum defeats

TAMPA ó The group behind a sales tax transportation initiative used hundreds of volunteers and spent at least $550,000 on a petition-gathering firm in a frantic six-week dash to qualify for the Nov. 6 General Election ballot.That may have been the ea...
Published: 08/11/18
Troubled SunPass vendor could have to pay $1.7 million, but Florida isnít asking for it

Troubled SunPass vendor could have to pay $1.7 million, but Florida isnít asking for it

The vendor responsible for recent problems with the SunPass tolling system could be on the hook to pay the state at least $1.7 million based on a review of documents obtained by the Tampa Bay Times.But the Florida Department of Transportation hasnít ...
Published: 08/08/18
Updated: 08/09/18
Petition succeeds, Hillsborough voters set to decide on sales tax hike for transportation

Petition succeeds, Hillsborough voters set to decide on sales tax hike for transportation

TAMPA ó As if there wasnít enough riding on the mid-term elections, a plan to raise the sales tax to pay for transportation projects is now set to go before Hillsborough voters.The Hillsborough County Supervisor of Elections confirmed Wednesday that ...
Published: 08/08/18

Flooding closes WPA Road in Brooksville; Rackley, other roads still closed

BROOKSVILLE ó Flooding on Wednesday led the Hernando County Department of Public Works to close WPA Road just south of its intersection with Mondon Hill Road.More than a foot of water is covering part of the road, east of downtown Brooksville, accord...
Published: 08/08/18
Ferry project waves goodbye to $4.7 million federal grant

Ferry project waves goodbye to $4.7 million federal grant

TAMPA — If the long-awaited commuter ferry service between south Hillsborough County and MacDill Air Force Base ever happens, it will likely be without federal money. Leaders of the Hillsborough Area Regional Transit authority acknowledged Mon...
Published: 08/06/18
Updated: 08/07/18
High-speed rail firm scouting land for station and development around proposed Rays ballpark site

High-speed rail firm scouting land for station and development around proposed Rays ballpark site

TAMPA ó Brightline, the firm behind the passenger rail system between Miami and West Palm Beach, doesnít yet know if it will win a state bid to build a high-speed rail link between Tampa and Orlando.But the company is already scouting sites for a ter...
Updated one month ago
Southbound I-275 ramp to northbound 75 in Manatee County to close for 10 months

Southbound I-275 ramp to northbound 75 in Manatee County to close for 10 months

People who travel from Pinellas County to southern Hillsborough using the interstates may want to build in some extra time.The Florida Department of Transportation has shut down the ramp that shuttles motorists from southbound Interstate 275 in Manat...
Updated one month ago
Waterborne transportation a fact of life in other cities; why not Tampa Bay?

Waterborne transportation a fact of life in other cities; why not Tampa Bay?

Mark Hubbard, the owner of Hubbard’s Marina on John’s Pass, has watched two decades of uncertainty over the future of waterborne transportation play out in Tampa Bay. Just when it seems that Tampa and St. Petersburg have figured out how ...
Updated one month ago
One Florida agency rejected the troubled SunPass vendor three years ago. Hereís why.

One Florida agency rejected the troubled SunPass vendor three years ago. Hereís why.

When Florida wanted to consolidate its tolling systems into what drivers now know as SunPass, regional expressway agencies in Tampa, Orlando, and Miami were ready to work together. But when Xerox spinoff Conduent State & Local Solutions was chosen as...
Updated one month ago