Saturday, June 23, 2018
Transportation

Questions continue on bouncy Bayside Bridge

Questions about the bouncing Bayside Bridge have been pouring into the Doc's inbox since we covered the issue in this column in May. Many readers insist that there are foundational issues with the construction of the bridge and have questioned the county's explanation that the rhythmic bouncing effect is due simply to cambers in the design of the bridge. Cambering allows individual concrete slabs to flex downward to a level position under heavy loads. The reasoning from the county was that bouncing is a common byproduct of bridge spans constructed with concrete slab spans.

This didn't hold water with readers, including several who identified themselves as engineers. The common theme of the emails and calls the Doc received is the perception that something went wrong with the construction of the bridge, which began in 1991 and was completed in 1993.

The Doc asked the county's engineering team to respond to four follow-up questions. We heard back from engineer Jorge M. Quintas, director of Pinellas County's division of engineering and technical support. Here is his response to our questions:

Was an error made in the construction process of the cement slab?

We are not aware of any errors in the construction process that can be directly attributed to the overcambering of some flat slab concrete segments at the south end. Cambering is a typical practice in bridge construction in which the superstructure is built with an upward deflection so that when the beam or slab is set in place it will deflect downward and assume a smooth riding surface in conjunction with the remaining spans. Overcambering took place on a portion of this bridge, and that is what drivers are feeling. Though this can result in an uncomfortable ride to a driver, it does not affect the structural integrity of the bridge.

Have corrective measures been taken to address the bounce? If so, what measures and when?

No corrective measures have been taken for the following reasons: This condition is extremely costly to correct, as the deck has to be milled, joints have to be replaced, and a deck overlay has to be poured. In most cases, a considerable improvement to the riding surface is not achieved after completing such costly corrective measures. Consequently, the cost-to-benefit ratio does not justify remediation. This condition is not wholly uncommon in bridges. As previously stated, the condition is primarily one of rider discomfort, and not one that generates structural concerns.

Was more than one contractor used in the construction of the bridge (hence the different feels)?

There are many subcontractors that work on large projects as these. However, they are all guided by the same contract plans and specifications. The contractor was Traylor Brothers Inc.

Why is the bridge so wavy/bouncy along one-quarter of the structure (south section of the northbound lanes) and not wavy/bouncy for the other three-fourths of the bridge?

We can only assume that, along the approximate bridge length of 2.65 miles, there was a nonuniform reaction to prestressed forces. A prestressed member will continue to deflect upward, or camber, for a considerable time after the prestressing strands are released at the casting yard. Not all prestressed members will react exactly the same, since their reaction can be affected by a multitude of factors. It would difficult, if at all possible, to ascertain what specific factor in 1991-1993 may have led to the uneven reaction of the prestressed members.

Email Dr. Delay at [email protected] to share your traffic concerns, comments and questions or follow Dr. Delay on Twitter @AskDrDelay.

Comments
SunPass charges will soon be showing up again on customer accounts — without late fees

SunPass charges will soon be showing up again on customer accounts — without late fees

It has been more than two weeks since SunPass customers have been able to access their accounts after the Florida toll service took down its website for system maintenance.While SunPass continues to accumulate toll charges since the maintenance perio...
Published: 06/22/18
Petition language reveals details of Hillsborough sales tax transportation initiative

Petition language reveals details of Hillsborough sales tax transportation initiative

TAMPA — The Hillsborough County Supervisor of Elections on Friday approved petition language that will let a new group of transportation advocates begin gathering the 48,000 signatures they need to get a sales tax initiative on the Nov. 6 ballot.All ...
Published: 06/15/18
Carlton: A trolley instead of a boondoggle? About time, Tampa

Carlton: A trolley instead of a boondoggle? About time, Tampa

You could rightly call the vintage streetcars that trundle between downtown Tampa and Ybor City big, beautiful boondoggles.Charming?Yes. An integral part of this city’s unique history?Absolutely.And in their current incarnation, overpriced, inefficie...
Published: 06/15/18
Federal judge halts work on Suncoast 2 toll road

Federal judge halts work on Suncoast 2 toll road

U.S. District Judge James S. Moody, Jr. granted a temporary restraining order on Thursday to halt the work that has already begun on the extension of the Suncoast Parkway — aka the controversial "Suncoast 2."The toll road now ends at U.S. 98 at the n...
Published: 06/14/18
Updated: 06/15/18
Hillsborough group pushing new referendum on raising sales tax for transportation

Hillsborough group pushing new referendum on raising sales tax for transportation

TAMPA — In 2010, Hillsborough voters soundly rejected a 1 cent sales tax hike backed by their elected leaders to raise billions of dollars for roads, bus expansion and light rail. In 2016, county commissioners helped develop a new transportation plan...
Published: 06/14/18
SunPass apologizes to customers who couldn’t access accounts after website maintenance

SunPass apologizes to customers who couldn’t access accounts after website maintenance

Users were unable to access their SunPass accounts on Monday after the release of a system redesign that took the system’s web site, app and hotlines down for a week.From June 5-11, the SunPass website, hotlines and mobile app were taken down for sys...
Published: 06/14/18
Elon Musk to build 125 mph underground transit line serving Chicago O’Hare

Elon Musk to build 125 mph underground transit line serving Chicago O’Hare

Elon Musk has taken on a task perhaps more challenging than launching rockets into space: getting passengers from Chicago’s O’Hare airport to the Loop in 12 minutes, roughly three to four times as fast as the current taxi journey.The plan for the "Ch...
Published: 06/14/18
This trooper pulled over a driver - then realized the man had delivered him nearly 27 years ago

This trooper pulled over a driver - then realized the man had delivered him nearly 27 years ago

New Jersey state trooper Michael Patterson was on patrol recently when he pulled over a white BMW for a routine traffic stop.He asked the driver for his license and registration, and the two started making small talk. It turned out that the driver, M...
Published: 06/13/18
Fares eliminated on downtown Tampa trolley following FDOT grant

Fares eliminated on downtown Tampa trolley following FDOT grant

TAMPA — Fares on the TECO Line Streetcar in downtown Tampa will be eliminated for three years following a grant funded by the Florida Department of Transportation.The grant provide $2.67 million to Hillsborough Area Regional Transit, allowing it to t...
Published: 06/12/18
Tampa road work forces office workers to wait up to an hour to get out of their parking garage every day

Tampa road work forces office workers to wait up to an hour to get out of their parking garage every day

TAMPA — At 42 floors tall, the largest office building on Florida’s Gulf Coast offers some spectacular views.But good luck getting out of it.Since the start of a $5.7 million street resurfacing project late last year on Kennedy Boulevard and Jackson ...
Published: 06/11/18
Updated: 06/12/18