Tuesday, January 16, 2018
Transportation

Creating one transportation planning agency for all of Tampa Bay won't be easy

CLEARWATER — They gathered around tables and tried to imagine what successful regional transportation planning could look like.

Politicians, citizens, civil servants. Residents of multiple counties. Light rail advocates and opponents. The nearly 200 participants were a microcosm of a diverse population that could, one day, be represented by a regional Metropolitan Planning Organization that represents all of Tampa Bay — and not just each individual county.

But Friday's workshop at St. Petersburg College's Collaborative Labs showed just how complicated it can be to reach consensus, especially on one of the region's most hot-button topics.

The exercise kicked off the process of evaluating whether merging individual MPOs — the groups that oversee transportation planning on a county level — into one regional agency is a good idea for Tampa Bay.

"We can't go through this without turmoil, difficulty and change," said transportation official Ray Chiaramonte.

Business leaders believe that a regional MPO is the next step in the bay area's transportation future. Tampa Bay Partnership president Rick Homans and other economic development leaders successfully lobbied the Legislature to turn the Tampa Bay Area Regional Transportation Authority into the Tampa Bay Regional Transit Authority.

If the governor signs the bill into law, the new TBARTA will focus on transit. But the bay area needs more than an operating agency, Homans said, there's still a void in regional planning.

For some, a regional MPO is the next logical step. Most major metropolitan areas across the country have one MPO, but it's less common in Florida.

For others, it's a loss of sovereignty. A regional MPO would remove local control and could make vying for transportation dollars even harder than it already is.

The group listed the key ingredients for a successful regional planning group: accountability, equity, public engagement, a focus on economic development and improved mobility.

But in the middle of the discussion was tension between a regional vision and local independence.

"It's a balancing act," facilitator Rafael Montalvo told the group. "The point of this is to explore whether there is a balance that will work for most."

Hillsborough Tea Party co-founder Sharon Calvert, for one, opposes a regional MPO. She said there's too much risk of losing local control. The bigger the entity, she said, the more removed it is from the individuals it serves.

"It makes it a bigger food fight into a smaller amount of money," Calvert said. "Who is responsible to me in this regional group?"

But others see it as a way to focus regional priorities without casting aside local needs.

"The overall sense I got was that we need a strong regional entity still with strong local input that goes into that," said Chiaramonte, executive director of TBARTA.

Friday's input will be used by the group studying the idea. That group is also supposed to search the nation for best practices for a regional MPO structure. There will be more other opportunities to gather local input, Montalvo said, and more workshops. The study should be completed by December, complete with a recommendation.

The group could come back, Pinellas MPO executive director Whit Blanton said, and declare that a unified, regional MPO will not work in Tampa Bay.

"The local, regional tension will never go away," he said. "There's this respect you always have to have for local community and local needs, but at a certain point you can't let it paralyze what you need to do to move a region forward.

Contact Caitlin Johnston at [email protected] or (727) 893-8779. Follow @cljohnst.

Comments

Brooksville intersection re-opens

BROOKSVILLE — Jasmine Drive is expected to reopen to traffic this weekend at the Cortez Boulevard intersection. The traffic change followed a resurfacing project by the Florida Department of Transportation that required lane closures. Work wil...
Published: 01/12/18
Tampa Bay Transit: How rapid buses left light rail in the dust

Tampa Bay Transit: How rapid buses left light rail in the dust

Transit leaders have spent years trying to build a transportation system that would span the Tampa Bay region and allow residents to travel from one end of the bay to the other without having to drive across it. Now they’re closer than ever to...
Published: 01/12/18
Road planners to study underpass at central Pasco bottleneck

Road planners to study underpass at central Pasco bottleneck

DADE CITY Ė Pasco Countyís transportation board wants to find out if a big dig will work at the congested intersection of U.S. 41 and State Road 54.County commissioners and elected officials from Pascoís cities, sitting as the Metropolitan Planning ...
Published: 01/12/18

Part of King Street in Safety Harbor closed next week

SAFETY HARBOR ó Dr. Martin Luther King Jr Street N will be closed from Elm Street to Ninth Avenue N (local traffic only from 7 p.m.-7 a.m.) Monday through Wednesday. Sanitary sewer cleaning and videotaping will be performed by Florida Jetclean.
Published: 01/11/18
St. Petersburg picks finalists for 40th Avenue NE bridge project

St. Petersburg picks finalists for 40th Avenue NE bridge project

ST. PETERSBURG ó Four firms have been selected as finalists to take on project management of the 40th Avenue NE bridge repair project. The bridge, which was shut down for emergency repairs last year but was soon re-opened for outer lane traffic, is e...
Published: 01/11/18
Tampa Bayís transit future: Light railís out. Rapid buses are in.

Tampa Bayís transit future: Light railís out. Rapid buses are in.

Watch out, Tampa Bay: light rail is out, and buses are in. For now, anyway.Transit leaders appear ready to scrap their dream of building a light rail line connecting Pasco, Hillsborough and Pinellas counties in favor of a bus rapid transit system tha...
Published: 01/11/18
HARTís driverless shuttle on hold for downtown Tampa

HARTís driverless shuttle on hold for downtown Tampa

TAMPA ó A highly touted autonomous shuttle project along the Marion Street Transitway wonít be ready by the NHL All-Star weekend at the end of the month, as previously planned.Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority, the countyís bus agency, ove...
Published: 01/08/18
HART board considers $2.3 million of bus projects today

HART board considers $2.3 million of bus projects today

TAMPA ó New bus services could be coming next month if transit board members today approve a list of $2.3 million worth of bus projects.The Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority will discuss the project list during its monthly board meeting st...
Published: 01/08/18
After 88 days, complaints in for HARTís reduced bus routes, service

After 88 days, complaints in for HARTís reduced bus routes, service

TAMPA ó Three months after the Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority pared down its bus network to save money, riders are still concerned about safety, missed connections and losing routes that once took them to work and doctorsí appointments....
Published: 01/06/18
Updated: 01/08/18
Traffic solution in the sky, or just pie-in-the-sky?

Traffic solution in the sky, or just pie-in-the-sky?

CLEARWATER ó By the end of this year, a never-before-been-built, Jetsons-like pod car system will be ready to transport visitors through the sky between downtown and Clearwater Beach.At least thatís what businessman Tom Nocera has been pledging to lo...
Published: 01/03/18
Updated: 01/06/18