Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy) | Tampa Bay Times

Trump not accurate on Clinton, fracking

During a rally in Roanoke, Va., on Saturday, Donald Trump said Hillary Clinton wants to “shut down” shale and natural gas.

Getty Images

During a rally in Roanoke, Va., on Saturday, Donald Trump said Hillary Clinton wants to “shut down” shale and natural gas.

The weekend before the first presidential debate, Donald Trump went to Roanoke, Va., to talk about energy.

"Here, in Virginia, we are going to end the war on American energy and on our miners. Hillary Clinton says she wants to put the miners out of work," Trump said. "Clinton and Kaine also want to shut down shale, and shut down natural gas."

Does Trump have his facts right on energy policy? PolitiFact decided to look into what Trump said about shale natural gas. We'll also provide context about what Clinton said about putting miners out of work.

Shale has become a dominant source of fossil fuels in the United States, thanks to a controversial process known as fracking. It wrings natural gas out of bedrock in a process that was once not considered profitable for extracting oil or natural gas. The process is efficient enough that the country's dependence on petroleum imports has declined precipitously.

Supporters note that burning natural gas produces far less pollution than other types of fossil fuel. Critics say the process can cause earthquakes, water contamination and the unwanted release of methane, a gas renowned for trapping heat, which makes it a big player in climate change.

Does the Clinton team want to shut down fracking and natural gas? No, but Clinton wants to regulate it more. So Trump's claim rates Half True.

Regulating fracking

When we contacted the Trump campaign, spokesman Jeff Wood sent us to a transcript of the Democratic presidential debate in Flint, Mich., where Clinton and her primary opponent, Bernie Sanders, were asked whether they supported fracking.

"I don't support it when any locality or any state is against it, number one," Clinton said. "I don't support it when the release of methane or contamination of water is present. I don't support it — number three — unless we can require that anybody who fracks has to tell us exactly what chemicals they are using.

"So by the time we get through all of my conditions, I do not think there will be many places in America where fracking will continue to take place," she continued. (Sanders opposes fracking.)

Clinton supported fracking as secretary of state, promoting it for Latin America, China, India and the European Union. She characterized natural gas as a "bridge" between dirty fuels, and said it was a way to get countries away from Russian oil.

In the United States, only a minority of states have banned fracking. Vermont was the first in 2012, and New York followed in 2014. Maryland has a moratorium on the practice through next year. Some municipalities have banned it as well.

When it comes to disclosing the chemicals used in the process, most of the states where fracking is done require some level of disclosure. According to the American Chemical Society, 26 of the 28 states have disclosure rules, though some have exceptions for company trade secrets.

Mining jobs in context

Trump said that Clinton said she wants to put miners out of work. Clinton has acknowledged that she said something to that effect, but she also apologized.

"I don't know how to explain it other than what I said was totally out of context for what I meant because I have been talking about helping coal country for a very long time," Clinton said on May 2. "It was a misstatement because what I was saying is the way things are going now, they will continue to lose jobs. It didn't mean that we were going to do it. What I said is that is going to happen unless we take action to help and prevent it."

Clinton made the comment during a March 13 CNN town hall. Journalist Roland Martin asked, in effect, why should poor white people vote for her.

In her response, Clinton did say that she would be putting coal companies out of business, as a result of moving toward renewable energy sources. But she followed that by saying she wanted to create new economic opportunities for current coal workers, possibly spurred by clean energy development.

"I'm the only candidate which has a policy about how to bring economic opportunity using clean renewable energy as the key into coal country. Because we're going to put a lot of coal miners and coal companies out of business," Clinton said. "And we're going to make it clear that we don't want to forget those people. Those people labored in those mines for generations, losing their health, often losing their lives to turn on our lights and power our factories.

"Now we've got to move away from coal and all the other fossil fuels, but I don't want to move away from the people who did the best they could to produce the energy that we relied on."

This report has been edited for print.

The statement

Says Hillary Clinton and Tim Kaine "want to shut down shale, and shut down natural gas."

Donald Trump at a rally in Roanoke, Va., Sept. 24

The ruling

Clinton has said the fracking process to extract natural gas from shale should be heavily regulated, but she does not support banning it outright. We rated Trump's statement Half True.

Trump not accurate on Clinton, fracking 09/25/16 [Last modified: Sunday, September 25, 2016 11:58pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Florida man sits in jail 90 days when drywall power is mistaken for cocaine (w/video)


    OVIEDO — A Florida man spent 90 days in jail after police officers who stopped him for driving without headlights said white powder found in his car was cocaine.

    Karlos Cashe spent 90 days in jail after Oviedo police officers who stopped him for driving without headlights said white powder found in his car was cocaine. But he walked out of jail last week after lab results determined the powder in the handyman's car was actually drywall. [Photo from video] 

  2. Coming to Netflix in July: 'Rogue One,' 'E.T.,' 'Castlevania' and more


    Just when I think Netflix has outdone itself with new releases and originals, it surprises me with another month of superb offerings coming to the streaming site.

    Felicity Jones in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
  3. Jones: Serena Williams, and all women, deserved better from John McEnroe


    John McEnroe might be the best sports analyst in broadcasting.

    Serena Williams makes a backhand return to her sister Venus during the women's singles final at the Australian Open tennis championships in January in  Melbourne, Australia. [AP photo]
  4. Watch: Provocateur targets CNN producer with hidden camera video


    NEW YORK —A conservative provocateur posted a video Tuesday of a man identified as a CNN producer commenting on his network's coverage of President Donald Trump and connections to Russia.

    Anthony Scaramucci, a senior adviser to President-elect Donald Trump, talks to reporters in the lobby of Trump Tower in New York. [Associated Press]
  5. Protesters demand Confederate statue be moved from old Hillsborough courthouse


    TAMPA – Politicians, clergy and community leaders demanded Tuesday that the Hillsborough County commission reverse course and remove a Confederate monument from the old county courthouse.

    (From left) Mike Reed, Kristen Perry and Dayna Lazarus hold protest signs Tuesday in front of a Confederate monument on the grounds of Hillsborough County's old courthouse. Protesters want the statue removed. ALESSANDRA DA PRA   Times]