Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Irma forecast wasn't as far off as you may think, experts say

This forecast graphic from the National Hurricane Center on Sept. 7 shows Irma's final path well within the cone of uncertainty. NATIONAL HURRICANE CENTER

This forecast graphic from the National Hurricane Center on Sept. 7 shows Irma's final path well within the cone of uncertainty. NATIONAL HURRICANE CENTER

As the monster storm Irma approached, some people in South Florida fled to the Gulf Coast, hoping to be safe there. Instead, after clobbering the Keys, Irma followed them, wobbling to the east and taking a course that came right up the state's western edge with a landfall at Marco Island.

Did the National Hurricane Center get the forecast wrong?

"An analysis of the track forecast and intensity error of the storm won't be done for a few weeks, at the earliest," Hurricane Center spokesman Dennis Feltgen said Monday.

But a trio of weather and climate experts say the forecasters did pretty well, given the size of the sprawling storm and the 120-mile width of the Florida peninsula.

"South Florida isn't that wide," pointed out Phil Klotzbach, a research scientist with Colorado State University. "The typical forecast margin of error is going to be within 100 miles."

In order to give people plenty of time to evacuate, Klotzbach said, forecasts often have to be made several days before anyone is certain where the storm will go. That's bound to lead to some evacuations that turn out to be unnecessary, he said.

For everyone who believes he or she didn't really need to evacuate, Klotzbach quoted former National Hurricane Center director Neil Frank: "You have to evacuate three times for every time you really need to evacuate."

Sharanya Majumdar, a professor of atmospheric science at the University of Miami, pointed out that Irma's final track was within the hurricane center's "forecast cone," more commonly known as "the cone of uncertainty."

Even before the storm crossed Cuba, some models showed the storm taking the path it eventually took and losing steam as the hurricane left the warm water that fuels its power. That would mean the powerful Category 5 storm everyone feared would be a tiger would be a far tamer pussycat, a 2 or even a 1, by the time it reached Tampa Bay.

People who paid attention to the line instead of the cone were the ones who were fooled, Majumdar said.

"There's too much focus on the line of the storm, and not enough on the uncertainty of the storm," he said. "There needs to be more emphasis on the size of a storm like Irma," he added, noting that it covered the whole peninsula.

Also, he said, Floridians should learn that there's danger from more than just the winds in a storm's eyewall. He pointed to the flooding in Jacksonville.

If he had been in charge, he would have told people on the Gulf Coast to evacuate at the same time as the people on the east coast, he said. But he found no fault in the forecasting prowess of the hurricane center.

"I think it was handled very well," he said.

The Hurricane Center's ability to see into the future has been questioned before, most strongly after Hurricane Charley became the first of four hurricanes to clobber Florida in 2004.

Originally, the hurricane was predicted to hit Tampa Bay head-on, the first such hurricane to slam into the region since 1921. Instead, at the last minute, it made an abrupt turn and slammed into Punta Gorda, then cut a swath of destruction across Central Florida.

Charley's abrupt change in direction wasn't the only surprise. The storm also intensified very rapidly from a weak Category 1 hurricane to a strong Category 4 within a few hours.

In reviewing what happened, the National Weather Service in a 2006 report found that the Punta Gorda landfall had been within the cone of uncertainty.

"Many people focused on the specific forecast track which indicated the projected path of the center of Hurricane Charley making landfall near Tampa Bay instead of the cone of uncertainty," the report noted.

The report said that a social scientist from Florida International University interviewed 100 people where the storm made landfall and found that more than 90 percent thought Charley was supposed to hit Tampa.

The report suggested the agency spend more time trying to educate people about what the cone means. But the changing demographics of a growing state make that difficult.

The report did note that the change in Charley's intensity was something that would have been hard to foresee.

"It is unusual for hurricanes to intensify rapidly just before making landfall — they usually weaken — and it is rare for hurricanes to make landfall as a category 4 or 5," it said.

As Florida's official state climatologist, Florida State professor David Zierden isn't an expert on day-to-day forecasting, but he does consider himself "a weather nerd" who knows a few things about how it works.

What Irma did "was well within the forecast cone put out by the National Hurricane Center," Zierden said. "As storms like this are making landfall, these kinds of developments can happen."

When a storm is headed for land at an oblique angle, "even a slight deviation can make a big difference," and can be hard to foresee three or four days in advance, he said.

The bottom line is that the amount of notice required to move millions of people conflicts with the forecasters' ability to gauge what a bunch of swirling wind might do next.

"The science is good and it's getting better," Klotzbach said. "But it's not perfect."

Contact Craig Pittman at Follow @craigtimes.

Irma forecast wasn't as far off as you may think, experts say 09/11/17 [Last modified: Tuesday, September 12, 2017 11:38am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 5 things to do under $5: Wiener dog racing, Streetcar Festival, Clearwater chalk art, Dia De Los Muertos


    1Wienerfest: They had us at wiener dog racing. This day devoted to dachshunds features racing, a dog costume contest, food trucks, photo booth and raffles at the Florida State Fairgrounds on Saturday. Leashed dogs of all breeds welcome. 10 a.m.-4 p.m. Saturday. 4802 U.S. 301 N, Tampa. Free admission. (407) …

    An entry in the costume contest from 2015's annual Dia de los Muertos Fiesta, or Day of the Dead Festival, hosted by Casa Tina's Mexican Restaurant.
photo courtesy Mikell Herrick
  2. Locale Market changes yet again, rebranding the restaurant as FarmTable Cucina

    Food & Dining

    When Locale Market opened in Sundial St. Pete in Dec. 2014, it was the most-hyped, most-anticipated gourmet market/food hall/culinary playground Tampa Bay had ever seen. Since then, celebrity chef-owner Michael Mina has done what every entrepreneur does in the face of challenges: tinker.

    Chef Michael Mina and chef Jeffrey Hileman work in the kitchen at Farmtable Kitchen in 2016. EVE EDELHEIT   |   Times
  3. Look for Tampa Bay filmmaker Joe Davison on 'Stranger Things'

    Human Interest

    For a year, Joe Davison kept a secret he wanted to tell so badly he feared it would burst from his mouth like an alien baby from John Hurt's chest.

    Joe Davison, at home in his dining room in Seminole, decked out for Halloween with “Stranger Things” decor, will appear in Season 2 of “Stranger Things.”
  4. Brooksville council begins study of law enforcement options

    Local Government

    BROOKSVILLE — The City Council has jumped headlong into a discussion about the future of the Brooksville Police Department — specifically whether to maintain it as is or change the way law enforcement service is provided in an effort to relieve the city's budget woes.

    Brooksville Mayor Robert Battista suggested that the City Council agree to promise residents that neither the city police nor fire departments would be disbanded without a voter referendum.
  5. U.S. home construction tumbles 4.7 percent in September

    Working Life

    WASHINGTON — Construction of new homes fell 4.7 percent in September, the biggest decline in six months, reflecting weakness in both single-family activity and apartment building.

    Construction of new homes fell 4.7 percent in September, the biggest decline in six months, reflecting weakness in both single-family activity and apartment building.  [Associated Press file photo]