
SWAYING THE VOTER
A fallacy is an error in argument. There are many types of fallacies and oftentimes the different types overlap. You can find a comprehensive list of fallacies at www1.ca.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/. Look for articles, cartoons and advertisements in your local newspaper that focus on the elections. Find examples of at least two different types of fallacies in these items. Write a fully developed paragraph analyzing the fallacies you find. How does understanding the techniques used help people become better voters? Share your paragraph and thoughts on the
NIE Blogging Zone.
Click here to visit the NIE Blogging Zone.
COMPARING NEWS PROVIDERS
Follow an issue that is being reported about in your local newspaper,
on television and online.
Compare and contrast the coverage of these news sources. Which medium provides the most in-depth, accurate information? Do the media report on the same issues or events differently? Do they focus on different slices of an issue or event? What are the differences between the electronic edition articles and the articles on the newspaper’s website? Share your thoughts with other students on the NIE Blogging Zone.
Click here to visit the NIE Blogging Zone.
EDITORIAL CARTOONS
Editorial cartoonists use a variety of tools to make a point. They use symbols, caricatures, stereotypes and analogies. Look in your local newspaper for editorial cartoons about the constitutional amendments or the candidates. With your classmates, decide which of these tools are being used in the various cartoons.
What prior knowledge did you need in order to understand the cartoon?
With a classmate, create your own editorial cartoon about one of the amendments showing that you agree or disagree with adding this change to the Florida Constitution.
RECOMMENDATIONS AND ENDORSEMENTS
Organizations and the media often endorse a candidate to voters who reflects the view of the editorial board or ownership of the organization, which implies more connection or support than a recommendation. Proposed amendments also can be endorsed by the media or organizations. Look for recommendations in your local newspaper and in other media. Write about the impact these recommendations may have on voters’ opinions. After you have done your research and clarified your thoughts, write a persuasive essay regarding one of the amendments. In the essay, discuss whether or not the recommendations support or refute your point of view.
Click here to visit the NIE Blogging Zone.
Check out these links to learn about the three amendments removed from the ballot:
Amendment 3: http://www.collinscenter.org/page/1eFLAmAmend3_MS
Amendment 7: http://www.collinscenter.org/page/1hFLAmAmend7_MS
Amendment 9: http://www.collinscenter.org/page/1jFLAmAmend9_MS
Share your thoughts about these amendments on the NIE Blogging Zone.
Clearly, the initiative process has become an effective way for citizens and organizations to have a direct say about how their government operates. But does the process lead to good government, particularly when citizens believe the Legislature isn’t paying attention to what they want? Or, do initiatives produce a hodgepodge of new policies that can be convoluted, contradictory and even devastating to the state’s economy? What do you think? Share your views on the NIE Blogging Zone.