Sunday, July 15, 2018
Opinion

Column: We expect perfection from self-driving cars, but not from human drivers

Joshua Brown died letting his Tesla do the driving for him in Williston. Just a few days earlier I was test-driving the same self-driving system in another Tesla for a column.

Both of us were playing a game of chicken with technology, maybe not fully appreciating the gamble we were taking.

A lot of people are unnerved by the idea of vehicles on autopilot, but we are destined for a future in which most of our cars drive themselves. But since we aren't there yet, I tried something closer to what I'd call half-driving. I turned my life over to the Autopilot setting on a $100,000 Tesla Model S, which let the electric car drive itself, sort of.

It doesn't respond to stop signs or red lights. It doesn't drive a route, turning down one street and then on to another on its own. What it does do, at least on a highway, still seems incredible.

Picture going 70 mph on the highway when the road curves, the cars ahead speeding up and slowing down, vehicles on either side of you and — this is the crucial part — you are admonished to avoid braking, accelerating or steering the Tesla, because the car does all of that for you.

"You don't want to override anything," the Tesla PR person told me.

What worried me was that she also cautioned me to keep my hands on the wheel, if only lightly, and to remain vigilant. I inferred this was because, well, it would be crazy to trust a car to drive itself.

How do I know when I should and shouldn't take control? I asked. "I don't have that answer," she replied. Very comforting.

The first 20 minutes of driving in Autopilot is an exercise in trust and willpower.

My body tensed. I definitely winced. I may have grunted. Or yelped. My foot had a mind of its own and hovered just above the brake pedal. Twice my instincts kicked in and I took control.

Other drivers had no idea there wasn't a person driving the fancy car beside them. The Tesla stays in its lane by using cameras, radar and sensors to watch lane lines or, if they are faded, the vehicle in front of it. The car slows itself or stops as needed, then speeds up again. It steers through curves.

Flip on a turn signal, and the Tesla will look for the right time to change lanes, then cross over when it sees fit.

Which is where the car and I had a disagreement.

I'm not good about delegating to a machine. The Tesla drives like it wants to drive, which odds are isn't exactly the way you would. I became a bit of a front-seat driver. Once or twice the Tesla was a wimp, slowing down when it saw something minor ahead that I knew was nothing meaningful.

The real test was when I purposely hit the turn signal when there wasn't much of a gap between cars in the next lane over.

The car waited a beat, then moved like it was going to get over. To me it felt like it was going to cut off another driver. My nerves turned from steel to cooked spaghetti. I tapped the brake and stopped it from switching lanes.

"That's what you don't want to do," Tesla's backseat PR person told me. The Tesla would have sped up and gotten over safely, she said.

Driving is a complex, messy exercise. It takes mountains of trust — or self-delusion — to believe a machine will get it right and not kill us. The same could have been said back in the early days of planes or regular cars.

We have fresh soul-searching and cold analysis to do now. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which recently announced Brown's accident, is investigating Tesla's Autopilot system. Tesla said the death is the first in more than 130 million miles of driving with the activated Autopilot.

In Brown's case, his Tesla didn't automatically brake for an 18-wheeler because it didn't pick up the trailer's white side against a brightly lit sky, according to Tesla and the government.

Of course, there are lots of white trucks on highways and lots of days when the sun lights the sky.

We have less tolerance for machines that kill us than we do when our fellow, foolish human drivers do the same. To err is human. To be perfect is what we demand of machines designed to act like humans.

I have to believe that technology can solve a white-truck/sunlight problem. I hope it also can handle the host of other variables and nuances involved in driving. Still, when it comes to testing the bounds of technology's surging role in our lives, we are perennially the guinea pigs.

Matt Kempner writes for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution. © 2016 Cox Newspapers

Comments
Romano: The best politician in Tampa Bay is not a politician

Romano: The best politician in Tampa Bay is not a politician

Some politicians bark, and some like to preen. It’s all part of an elaborate act to attract attention and create an image.But the very best politicians?They don’t act like politicians at all.I was reminded of that last week while watching Pinellas Co...
Published: 07/13/18
Updated: 07/14/18
Editorial: A vote for preserving waterfront parks by St. Petersburg City Council

Editorial: A vote for preserving waterfront parks by St. Petersburg City Council

The St. Petersburg City Council made the appropriate but difficult decision to reject a contract with renowned artist Janet Echelman for one of her aerial sculptures. It would be wonderful for the city to have one of her signature works, but Spa Beac...
Published: 07/13/18

‘Everybody needed to know what happened’

The brutal murder of Emmett Till, a black Chicago youth, in Mississippi nearly 63 years ago went unpunished, but not forgotten. A decision by his mother, Mamie Till-Mobley, to allow an open casket at Emmett’s Chicago funeral represented an act of def...
Published: 07/13/18
Brink: Extending the Suncoast Parkway has gone from boondoggle to folly

Brink: Extending the Suncoast Parkway has gone from boondoggle to folly

In a few short weeks, the Suncoast 2 toll road project has gone from boondoggle to folly.State officials pitched the 13-mile extension of the Suncoast Parkway as a step toward eventually linking the road to Interstate 75 near Ocala via a project dubb...
Published: 07/13/18
Daniel Ruth: Rays stadium dream masks the sticker shock

Daniel Ruth: Rays stadium dream masks the sticker shock

Close your eyes and dream. It is October 2023 or so and the Tampa Bay Rays are up 3-0 in the World Series against the Chicago Cubs. The game is being played in the Rays new stadium, Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, Credit Suisse, George Soros, Vinny’s...
Published: 07/13/18

Brooks: The quiet death of racial progress

Over the past few months, I’ve been trying to write a comforting column. The thesis was going to be that even though Donald Trump is doing his best to inflame racial division, we are still making gradual progress against racism and racial disparities...
Published: 07/12/18
Updated: 07/13/18
Pam Bondi: The Senate should confirm Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh

Pam Bondi: The Senate should confirm Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh

I personally know appeals court Judge Brett Kavanaugh, who has been nominated by President Donald Trump to succeed retiring Justice Anthony Kennedy on the U.S. Supreme Court. To call him qualified for the role is a massive understatement.A graduate o...
Published: 07/12/18
Column: The test for Judge Kavanaugh

Column: The test for Judge Kavanaugh

So it’s Judge Brett Kavanaugh. There will be time enough to explore the nominee’s views and record. Let’s step back a bit and get some perspective on the national debate that we are about to have.Those on the left fear, and those on the right hope, t...
Published: 07/12/18
Column: A liberal’s case for Brett Kavanaugh

Column: A liberal’s case for Brett Kavanaugh

The nomination of Judge Brett Kavanaugh to be the next Supreme Court justice is President Donald Trump’s finest hour, his classiest move. A few days ago, the president promised to select "someone with impeccable credentials, great intellect, unbiased...
Published: 07/12/18
Editorial: Personal bias taints Florida’s clemency system

Editorial: Personal bias taints Florida’s clemency system

A recent exchange between the governor and Cabinet and a felon seeking to have his civil rights restored underscores the arbitrary unfairness of Florida’s clemency system. A long waiting period, a ridiculous backlog of cases and elected officials who...
Published: 07/11/18
Updated: 07/13/18