Make us your home page
David Ignatius

Could Mumbai happen in U.S.?

WASHINGTON — Like the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in America, the Mumbai terrorist assault last week began with a hijacking. Islamic militants seized a private fishing boat at sea rather than commercial jetliners, according to U.S. counterterrorism officials. But the attackers displayed the same deadly ability to coordinate a complex operation against multiple targets as did their predecessors on 9/11.

The terrorists were from a Pakistani group called Lashkar-i-Taiba, which has loose links with al-Qaida. The attackers began by boarding the boat in the Arabian Sea and killing the captain. They then piloted the boat toward Mumbai Harbor. As they neared the coast on Nov. 26, they launched several rubber lifeboats for the final amphibious assault.

The attack was meticulously planned: The raiders dispersed to several targets across the crowded city that had been studied by advance reconnaissance teams. Most important, they carried with them enough guns, ammunition and supplies for a long battle.

Then the mayhem began: The terrorists stormed their targets — three luxury hotels, a Jewish cultural center, a railway station — turning the nearby streets into a free-fire zone. It took about 10 hours for Indian antiterrorist commandos to arrive at the besieged hotels, and it was almost three days before the attackers had been captured or killed.

The Mumbai attacks were a ghastly reminder of the threat still posed by al-Qaida and related terrorist groups. The militants read their enemies' tactical vulnerabilities well — understanding in this case that urban police forces have trouble combating moving bands of shooters. And they appeared to have had a divisive strategic goal — of reanimating tension between India and Pakistan just as the two were beginning to make common cause against terrorism.

For Americans, the obvious question was: Could it happen here? U.S. officials say the answer, unfortunately, is yes. And then comes a second question: If America is hit with another 9/11-style terrorist assault, how should the country react?

The Department of Homeland Security has been worried for more than a year about the danger of seaborne attacks. With an estimated 17-million small vessels plying the thousands of miles of U.S. coastline, the vulnerability is obvious. DHS announced a "small-vessel security strategy" last April to focus on ports and coastal waterways, and it has held four regional small-vessel "security summits" this year.

Technology is improving for detecting radiological devices that might arrive at seaports. But defense is thin against bioterrorism, and almost nonexistent against seaborne gunmen of the sort who terrorized Mumbai.

What would happen if roving gunmen infiltrated U.S. cities and started shooting? Most U.S. police departments aren't well prepared to deal with such "active shooters," as they're called. Police are trained to cordon off an area that's under attack and then call in a paramilitary SWAT team to root out the gunmen. But what if the attackers keep moving and shooting? The response can be haphazard, as was clear in the 2002 Beltway sniper attacks and the 2007 massacre at Virginia Tech.

"Mumbai is a worst-case 'active shooter' problem," says a former CIA officer who helped organize a DHS pilot program on the subject last summer for police chiefs. "It had multiple shooters, multiple locations, mobile threats, willingness to fight the first responders and follow-on SWAT/commando units, well-equipped and well-trained operatives, and a willingness to die. Police department commanders in America should be scratching their heads and praying."

Forewarned is forearmed, and the Mumbai attacks are a powerful demonstration of the danger for cities around the world. The reason to discuss such threats isn't to feed antiterrorism hysteria. There was far too much of that fear-mongering and spasmodic reaction after 9/11. The challenge is to understand the adversary so that, if an attack comes, the authorities will respond with cool heads and steady aim.

David Ignatius' e-mail address is

© Washington Post Writers Group

Could Mumbai happen in U.S.? 12/02/08 [Last modified: Monday, December 8, 2008 11:25am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Washington Post Columnist.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours