Make us your home page
David Broder

Crisis clobbers cities, states

WASHINGTON — When Barack Obama meets Tuesday in Philadelphia with governors of both parties, an added dimension of the credit crisis and financial meltdown will come into focus. We have heard a lot about the collapse of housing prices, the threatened or actual bankruptcy of many banks and the rise in unemployment. Individuals, families and firms of all sizes have been clobbered by these events.

What the governors will point out to the president-elect is that most of their budgets are in such trouble that they may not be able to meet their responsibilities to their citizens. When Obama puts his economic rescue plan together, he will have to build in significant aid to state and local governments, lest they add to the public woes by slashing their own spending in order to meet the constitutional requirements for balanced budgets in most states.

When I spoke with Gov. Joe Manchin of West Virginia, the head of the Democratic Governors Association, the other day, he was effusive in his praise of Obama for reaching out to the governors of both parties. Manchin's state voted for Hillary Clinton in last spring's Democratic primary and for John McCain in November. But he insisted that Obama had gone more than halfway in involving governors during the campaign, and now in the transition.

Manchin said he had advised other governors to be prepared when they meet Obama to talk in specifics about the biggest challenges facing their states. "I don't want to see us going there with our hands out," he said. "I want us ready to roll up our sleeves and go to work with Washington."

That is brave talk, but the reality is that state and local governments are hurting badly. On Monday, the National Governors Association and the National Conference of State Legislatures are holding a bipartisan phone-in news conference to "outline the current fiscal situation and urge Congress and the next administration to provide a recovery package that will spur job growth, support infrastructure projects and ease the burden of Medicaid costs."

The House passed such a measure recently but it died under threat of a Bush veto. It is almost a certainty that Obama will support and sign such a bill.

In Philadelphia, where Obama and the governors will meet, Mayor Michael Nutter announced recently that he was closing 11 libraries, laying off 220 workers, eliminating another 600 unfilled positions, postponing a promised tax cut and slicing his own salary by 10 percent.

In Obama's Chicago, Mayor Richard Daley, looking at a budget shortfall of almost half a billion dollars, has called for hundreds of layoffs. In Atlanta, the fire department is losing people. In Seattle, it's housing for the homeless that is taking a hit. New York measures its shortfall in the billions and is whacking education, police and almost every other service.

The forced cutbacks hit the most vulnerable of our fellow citizens. And they damage the prospects for a strong and swift economic recovery.

The federal government is following the Keynesian blueprint by rapidly increasing its spending — letting deficits explode past the trillion-dollar mark in hopes of stimulating the private economy. But if declining tax revenues and increasing Medicaid and welfare payments force state and local governments to cut back, that will work against the stimulus.

Obama and the governors are in this together. It is good that they are meeting now, and important that their dialogue continues when he takes office.

David Broder's e-mail address is

© Washington Post Writers Group

Crisis clobbers cities, states 11/29/08 [Last modified: Monday, December 1, 2008 1:26pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Washington Post Columnist.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours