Wednesday, November 22, 2017
Opinion

Florida death penalty reform is overdue

RECOMMENDED READING


The Florida Bar's Criminal Law Update for lawyers is taking place in Tampa today.

Challenging the status quo to promote fairness and impartiality in our justice system can be a daunting task even for legal practitioners. When Florida's death penalty process is at issue, the task can be further complicated because such efforts are often equated with being soft on crime or insensitive to victims' issues. Moreover, the Florida Bar Foundation, which had played an instrumental role in advancing death penalty process reform efforts, is less inclined to support such projects today given depleted discretionary funding.

The alarming backdrop is that the Death Penalty Information Center, an independent Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit organization, reports that since 1973, Florida has reversed more death sentences than any other state.

Frank Lee Smith was exonerated posthumously after the actual perpetrator was identified. He died of cancer after languishing on death row for 14 years.

Juan Melendez was exonerated after almost 18 years on death row when a taped confession by the actual perpetrator was discovered.

Reasonable people may disagree about capital punishment, but all should agree that the process must be as fair and impartial as possible.

More than five years ago, the American Bar Association released a comprehensive report developed by a team of eight Florida-based experts that raised serious concerns about Florida's death penalty process. (It did not take a position on the merit or efficacy of capital punishment.)

Few of its recommendations have been implemented.

One key recommendation was that state officials should conduct a comprehensive review of Florida's death penalty process, suggesting that the report's findings and recommendations would be a logical place to start. For perspective, no such review has been attempted in more than 10 years; even then it was limited in scope. Any of the state's three branches of government could initiate working in cooperation with the others.

One of the report's key findings notes that Florida is an outlier in allowing capital-case juries to find aggravating circumstances and recommend a death sentence by a simple majority, for example, 7-5. Now that Connecticut repealed its death penalty statute for future crimes last month, apart from Florida the 32 other remaining death penalty states require a form of unanimity.

Some counter that if unanimity had been required, convicted serial killers such as Ted Bundy and Aileen Wuornos wouldn't have received death sentences because both penalty-phase jury deliberations resulted in 10-2 votes.

Not necessarily. Had those juries been instructed that unanimity was required, the nature of the deliberations would have changed, including conceivably the vote, and while the judge is expected to place great weight on a jury's recommendation, it is the judge who imposes death sentences in Florida.

We may be reaching a turning point.

Sen. Thad Altman, R-Melbourne, filed a bill in anticipation of the 2012 regular state legislative session that would require unanimity in future penalty phase jury deliberations for both advisory recommendations of death and findings regarding the presence of aggravators, the basis for any death sentence.

He expanded the scope of a unanimous-jury bill that he previously filed to address issues raised in Evans vs. McNeil, a recent case out of the Southern District in which U.S. District Judge Jose Martinez declared related aspects of Florida's capital case sentencing scheme unconstitutional. The state has appealed.

Before Evans, the Florida Supreme Court, in a 2005 opinion known as State vs. Steele, had called upon the Legislature to revisit Florida's death penalty statute to require unanimity for jury recommendations of death. Then-Gov. Jeb Bush observed that the issue was "definitely worth consideration" and cautioned legislators not to ignore the court.

The Legislature ignored the court.

Simply put, Altman's bill would have helped to ensure that the death penalty is reserved for the most heinous crimes. The bill died in committee without a hearing.

Legislative leadership seems to be falling prey to the notion that any change in Florida's death penalty statute might result in unintended consequences and therefore should be resisted at virtually all costs, essentially gambling that Evans will be reversed on appeal.

Maintaining the status quo and thereby Florida's outlier status in this regard among all other death penalty states does not serve the cause of justice. States like Texas and Georgia, known for their pro-death-penalty stance, require unanimous juries. So should we.

Raoul Cantero is a former Florida Supreme Court justice appointed by Gov. Jeb Bush. Mark Schlakman, senior program director for the Center for the Advancement of Human Rights at Florida State University, is board chairman for theInnocence Project of Florida and was a memberof the ABA's Florida Death Penalty Assessment Team.

Comments

Another voice: Time for Republicans to denounce this tax nonsense

Mick Mulvaney, the phony deficit hawk President Donald Trump tapped to oversee the nationís budget, all but admitted on Sunday that the GOP tax plan currently before the Senate is built on fiction. Senators from whom the public should expect more ó s...
Updated: 11 hours ago
Editorial: Florida should restore online access to nursing home inspections

Editorial: Florida should restore online access to nursing home inspections

In a state with the nationís highest portion of residents over 65 years old and more than 80,000 nursing home beds, public records about those facilities should be as accessible as possible. Yet once again, Florida is turning back the clock to the da...
Published: 11/20/17

Another voice: A time of reckoning on sexual misconduct

Stories about powerful men engaging in sexual misconduct are becoming so common that, as with mass shootings, the country is in danger of growing inured to them. But unlike the tragic news about that latest deranged, murderous gunman, the massive out...
Published: 11/20/17
Editorial: Fighting the opioid crisis on many fronts

Editorial: Fighting the opioid crisis on many fronts

From birth to death, opioid addiction is ravaging the lives of thousands of Floridians. Drugmakers, doctors, state lawmakers and insurance companies all have a role to play in slowing the epidemic. Lately some more responsible answers, including mill...
Updated: 7 hours ago

Editorial: Good for Tampa council member Frank Reddick to appeal for community help to solve Seminole Heights killings

As the sole black member of the Tampa City Council, Frank Reddick was moved Thursday to make a special appeal for help in solving four recent murders in the racially mixed neighborhood of Southeast Seminole Heights. "Iím pleading to my brothers. You ...
Published: 11/17/17
Editorial: Itís time to renew communityís commitment to Tampa Theatre

Editorial: Itís time to renew communityís commitment to Tampa Theatre

New attention to downtown Tampa as a place to live, work and play is transforming the area at a dizzying pace. Credit goes to recent projects, both public and private, such as the Tampa River Walk, new residential towers, a University of South Florid...
Published: 11/17/17
Editorial: Rays opening offer on stadium sounds too low

Editorial: Rays opening offer on stadium sounds too low

The Rays definitely like Ybor City, and Ybor City seems to like the Rays. So what could possibly come between this match made in baseball stadium heaven? Hundreds (and hundreds and hundreds) of millions of dollars. Rays owner Stu Sternberg told Times...
Published: 11/16/17
Updated: 11/17/17
Editorial: Wage hike for contractorsí labor misguided

Editorial: Wage hike for contractorsí labor misguided

St. Petersburg City Council members are poised to raise the minimum wage for contractors who do business with the city, a well-intended but misguided ordinance that should be reconsidered. The hourly minimum wage undoubtedly needs to rise ó for every...
Published: 11/16/17

Editorial: Make workplaces welcoming, not just free of harassment

A federal trial began last week in the sex discrimination case that a former firefighter lodged against the city of Tampa. Tanja Vidovic describes a locker-room culture at Tampa Fire Rescue that created a two-tier system ó one for men, another for wo...
Published: 11/15/17
Updated: 11/17/17
Editorial: Firing a critic of his handling of the sewer crisis is a bad early step in Krisemanís new term

Editorial: Firing a critic of his handling of the sewer crisis is a bad early step in Krisemanís new term

Barely a week after St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman promised to unite the city following a bitter and divisive campaign, his administration has fired an employee who dared to criticize him. It seems Krisemanís own mantra of "moving St. Pete forwar...
Published: 11/15/17
Updated: 11/16/17