Wednesday, November 22, 2017
Opinion

Political purity pitfalls

RECOMMENDED READING


Barry Goldwater vs. Nelson Rockefeller. Ronald Reagan vs. Gerald Ford. Ted Kennedy vs. Jimmy Carter. The two parties' presidential nomination fights have often pitted ideologues against pragmatists, and this year's Republican primary is yet another example.

One contender after another — Rick Perry, Michele Bachmann, Newt Gingrich, Herman Cain and now Rick Santorum — has claimed to be the "true" conservative alternative to Mitt Romney, the purported Massachusetts moderate.

Each has argued that staying true to party doctrine on taxes, government spending and abortion is not only morally right but also politically expedient. The only way to beat President Barack Obama in November, they argue, is to present the voters with a clear ideological alternative. "You win by giving people a choice," Santorum said during a recent visit to Texas.

These Republicans need to read Flagrant Conduct, a superb new book by University of Minnesota law professor Dale Carpenter. It tells the story of the dramatic 2003 victory for gay rights at the Supreme Court, in which the justices struck down a Texas ban on homosexual sodomy.

Justice Anthony M. Kennedy's opinion for the majority in that case, Lawrence vs. Texas, relied on — and expanded — doctrine that the court had previously invoked to guarantee constitutional rights to contraception and abortion, much to conservatives' consternation.

And while Lawrence had no direct bearing on the question of gay marriage, the reasoning and the rhetoric of Kennedy's opinion encouraged subsequent lawsuits seeking a constitutional right to same-sex nuptials.

In short, Lawrence was a huge setback for social-issues conservatives. But, as Carpenter shows, it was a defeat for which the ultra-right had only itself to blame.

Enacted in 1973 as part of a backlash against the fledgling gay rights movement, the Homosexual Conduct Law made Texas one of the few states that banned private, consensual sex between people of the same gender.

The statute registered Texas' moral condemnation of gay sex and, indeed, its condemnation of just being gay. But it was rarely enforced — until 1998, when two Harris County men, John Lawrence and Tyron Garner, were arrested and duly convicted of engaging in sex.

With the help of lawyers from Lambda Legal Defense, Lawrence and Garner asked a three-judge panel of a state court of appeals, all of whose members were Republican, to overturn their convictions.

In June 2000, the Texas court did so, ruling in a split decision that the Homosexual Conduct Law violated the state constitution's equal rights amendment because it treated people unequally based on the gender of their sexual partners.

The case could well have ended there, with a ruling that applied only to 14 counties in southeastern Texas. And it would have ended, if the Harris County district attorney, a Republican, had decided to accept the defeat of a law that served no practical purpose and that two pretty conservative Republican judges considered an affront to basic notions of fairness.

But by that point the ideological purists of the Texas Republican Party would not let that happen. It was an election year, and the ruling came out just days before the state Republican convention in Houston. The party faithful adopted a resolution calling for the electoral defeat of the insufficiently conservative "activist" appeals-court judges who had struck down the sodomy law. The party platform denounced homosexual behavior as "contrary to the fundamental, unchanging truths that have been ordained by God."

Taking the hint, the Harris County district attorney appealed the panel's ruling to the full nine-judge appeals court. In March 2001, the full court voted 7-2 to uphold the Texas law, without even bothering to hear oral argument.

The state's highest court, also dominated by Republicans, refused to hear Lawrence and Garner's appeal, and so the case went to the U.S. Supreme Court, which not only struck down Texas' idiotic and unjust law but also prohibited any state from ever again making or enforcing such a law — while laying the legal basis for more possible gay rights victories in the future.

There's a lesson here for those who would lead today's Republican Party down the path of ideological purity. In fact, there's a lesson here for everyone.

Charles Lane is a member of the editorial page staff of the Washington Post.

© 2012 Washington Post

Comments

Another voice: Time for Republicans to denounce this tax nonsense

Mick Mulvaney, the phony deficit hawk President Donald Trump tapped to oversee the nationís budget, all but admitted on Sunday that the GOP tax plan currently before the Senate is built on fiction. Senators from whom the public should expect more ó s...
Published: 11/20/17
Updated: 11/21/17
Editorial: Florida should restore online access to nursing home inspections

Editorial: Florida should restore online access to nursing home inspections

In a state with the nationís highest portion of residents over 65 years old and more than 80,000 nursing home beds, public records about those facilities should be as accessible as possible. Yet once again, Florida is turning back the clock to the da...
Published: 11/20/17

Another voice: A time of reckoning on sexual misconduct

Stories about powerful men engaging in sexual misconduct are becoming so common that, as with mass shootings, the country is in danger of growing inured to them. But unlike the tragic news about that latest deranged, murderous gunman, the massive out...
Published: 11/20/17
Editorial: Fighting the opioid crisis on many fronts

Editorial: Fighting the opioid crisis on many fronts

From birth to death, opioid addiction is ravaging the lives of thousands of Floridians. Drugmakers, doctors, state lawmakers and insurance companies all have a role to play in slowing the epidemic. Lately some more responsible answers, including mill...
Published: 11/17/17
Updated: 11/21/17

Editorial: Good for Tampa council member Frank Reddick to appeal for community help to solve Seminole Heights killings

As the sole black member of the Tampa City Council, Frank Reddick was moved Thursday to make a special appeal for help in solving four recent murders in the racially mixed neighborhood of Southeast Seminole Heights. "Iím pleading to my brothers. You ...
Published: 11/17/17
Editorial: Itís time to renew communityís commitment to Tampa Theatre

Editorial: Itís time to renew communityís commitment to Tampa Theatre

New attention to downtown Tampa as a place to live, work and play is transforming the area at a dizzying pace. Credit goes to recent projects, both public and private, such as the Tampa River Walk, new residential towers, a University of South Florid...
Published: 11/17/17
Editorial: Rays opening offer on stadium sounds too low

Editorial: Rays opening offer on stadium sounds too low

The Rays definitely like Ybor City, and Ybor City seems to like the Rays. So what could possibly come between this match made in baseball stadium heaven? Hundreds (and hundreds and hundreds) of millions of dollars. Rays owner Stu Sternberg told Times...
Published: 11/16/17
Updated: 11/17/17
Editorial: Wage hike for contractorsí labor misguided

Editorial: Wage hike for contractorsí labor misguided

St. Petersburg City Council members are poised to raise the minimum wage for contractors who do business with the city, a well-intended but misguided ordinance that should be reconsidered. The hourly minimum wage undoubtedly needs to rise ó for every...
Published: 11/16/17

Editorial: Make workplaces welcoming, not just free of harassment

A federal trial began last week in the sex discrimination case that a former firefighter lodged against the city of Tampa. Tanja Vidovic describes a locker-room culture at Tampa Fire Rescue that created a two-tier system ó one for men, another for wo...
Published: 11/15/17
Updated: 11/17/17
Editorial: Firing a critic of his handling of the sewer crisis is a bad early step in Krisemanís new term

Editorial: Firing a critic of his handling of the sewer crisis is a bad early step in Krisemanís new term

Barely a week after St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman promised to unite the city following a bitter and divisive campaign, his administration has fired an employee who dared to criticize him. It seems Krisemanís own mantra of "moving St. Pete forwar...
Published: 11/15/17
Updated: 11/16/17