Make us your home page

Powerful women are not like the rest of us

It's one of our current ironies that the same liberal people complaining that there are not enough women CEOs seem to harbor a special contempt for the women CEOs we do have.

We like to say there aren't enough women in the higher echelons of spectacularly successful business people, but when women do rise to those echelons, we attack them for that spectacular success.

USA Today ran a column arguing that Marissa Mayer and Sheryl Sandberg leave "a bad taste in the mouths of many working mothers who don't have the income or family luxuries of these uber-women." They are constantly attacked for the unremarkable fact that they have staff to support their careers and sustain their families. In other words, the shameful or distasteful truth about these very rich, successful business women is that they are very rich.

The main critiques of Sandberg and Mayer boil down to the fact that they are "not like us." And yet, it is precisely because they are not like us that we should admire them, or at least be pleased, abstractly, about their existence on Earth.

It also seems like a feminist mistake to expect women entrepreneurs to create little utopias instead of running extremely successful businesses. Mayer was attacked recently for her decision not to allow employees to work at home.

She is a woman, this line of thinking goes, how could she think women should have to work away outside of their houses, away from their children? But why should Marissa Mayer have some special responsibility to nurture her employees with a cozy, consummately flexible work environment just because she is a woman?

Isn't her responsibility to run a company according to her individual vision? If we want powerful female entrepreneurs shouldn't we allow them to pursue entrepreneurial power?

The strange idea that women who are successful must represent all women, or somehow be like all women, is both totally absurd and completely prevalent. How could someone in the position of Sandberg or Mayer live exactly like most women in America?

One has to wonder if there is a broader distrust of successful women at work (and the confusing thing is that it is a distrust of successful women among successful women). Think of Lena Dunham and the outsized rage she has attracted for her large book advance, for attracting huge amounts of attention with her show.

These could be greeted as welcome signs of success for a woman in the largely male world of comedy, but instead she too is attacked for "not being like us." She too is expected to create a mini utopia on the set of her show. She is attacked for not hiring minorities, or not representing people without college educations.

In one cranky piece in Slate, Amanda Hess complains: "So far Dunham hasn't appeared to use her position to give a leg up to less-privileged voices." To which one can only wonder, "Is she supposed to run a home for starving comedy writers of other races?"

But why should Lena Dunham or Sheryl Sandberg or Marissa Mayer have a special obligation to "represent" the experiences of the whole chaotic spectrum of American female experience?

Surely, as a country, we should have moved beyond the idea that successful women should be less ambitious, less ruthless, less self-involved, less inspired or single-minded in their pursuit of power or creative expression than their male counterparts.

If we are interested in female power, then we should let our powerful women pursue power, without harassing them with our distaste for that pursuit. We should not expect them to be warmer, fuzzier, more nurturing than their male counterparts because to do so is to impose sexist expectations.

We should not expect extraordinary women to be ordinary; we should not be constantly demanding that they live like us, or be like us or feel like us. If you want to see someone who is just like you, look in the mirror.

Katie Roiphe, professor at the Arthur L. Carter Journalism Institute at New York University, is the author most recently of "Uncommon Arrangements: Seven Marriages," and the forthcoming "In Praise of Messy Lives."

© 2013 Slate

Powerful women are not like the rest of us 03/07/13 [Last modified: Thursday, March 7, 2013 3:23pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours