Saturday, February 24, 2018
Opinion

Public sector costs, benefits

Ever have a bad day at the Department of Motor Vehicles? Or had a math teacher flunk your brilliant child? Then you have a feel for why public employees are such easy targets for budget cuts.

With private sector jobs hard to come by and state budgets under strain, public employees are often viewed as overly job-protected and, in many instances, as lazy, uncaring and overpaid.

The idea of reducing their compensation resonates well with many voters. In several states, public employees have taken salary cuts or been made to increase their contributions toward health and pension benefits. Florida lawmakers are considering a proposal that will reduce the number of deferred vacation and sick days that can be accrued each year.

Public versus private compensation. In Florida, New Jersey and Wisconsin respectively, Govs. Rick Scott, Chris Christie and Scott Walker assert that public employees are paid 30 percent more than private sector employees. Of course, they want good public employees, and they realize that compensation must meet the market. But if they are correct and public employees are overpaid, then compensation packages can be reduced without too many workers finding better jobs.

Unfortunately, their analysis simply consists of comparing average salaries in the public sector to those in the private sector with no allowance for differences in job requirements and qualifications. The percentage of public employees with advanced degrees is higher than in the private sector because they are our teachers, professors, lawyers, health care workers, and others charged with highly professional responsibilities.

Salary comparisons are quite complex as total compensation includes a mix of current items (wages, salaries, health coverage) and deferred items (pensions, future health benefits). More sophisticated studies have shown that when the entire compensation packages are compared, there is no premium for working in the public sector.

Of course, in our current economic climate, employees have fewer alternatives and so employers can cut compensation more freely. But if they are to avoid a large exodus of the best public employees when better times return, states that implement these cost-saving cuts must be prepared to respond to the market. For instance in Wisconsin, the current budget calls for a reduction in current salaries as well as for limits on the growth of future compensation, which can grow no faster than the consumer price index. Since the wage index rises more rapidly than the CPI during economic recoveries, Wisconsin may have to alter this limit on wage growth when the recovery comes and the need for more nurses, snow-plow operators and teachers grows.

The trade-off between salary and benefits. Historically, the nonsalary items in public payrolls constitute a greater fraction of total compensation than in private sector payrolls. This is understandable since larger employers have a cost advantage when providing nonsalary benefits. Compared to smaller employers, large organizations — whether public or private — find it less expensive per employee to offer a range of benefits, such as health insurance, sick days, holiday pay and pensions. In addition, tax breaks further incentivize this option.

Because of these cost savings and tax advantages, it is simply cheaper for large state employers to offer more benefit-laden compensation packages and for their employees to accept them. Taxpayers also benefit from this arrangement as public payrolls are less costly than they otherwise would be. Even though this greater benefit-to-salary ratio provides lower cost to both public employers and the taxpayers, public employees are often charged with receiving excessive benefits. Such criticism is focusing on just one component of a compensation package when it is the entire package that must be competitive.

One final note: Compensation packages can be designed to fight a brain drain. States that lose experienced professionals at the point of their maximum career productivity suffer many negative consequences. As examples, the loss of engineers and scientists stymie economic development efforts; the exodus of health care workers reduces the quality of life; and the departure of teachers has tragic implications for our ability to successfully compete in the global marketplace. The trick is to design a golden handcuff that will encourage valuable employees to remain after their skills and productivity are maximized around mid career. One option would be to make their unused sick leave redeemable for health insurance premiums in retirement, but forfeited by workers who resign prior to age 65.

William L. Holahan, far left, is emeritus professor of economics at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. Charles O. Kroncke, near left, retired dean of the College of Business at UW-M, also recently retired from USF. They are co-authors of "Economics for Voters." They wrote this exclusively for the Tampa Bay Times.

Comments
Editorial: Improve school security plans with gun controls

Editorial: Improve school security plans with gun controls

Gov. Rick Scott and key members of the Florida Legislature offered ambitious proposals Friday that would plug some holes in the stateís safety net, strengthen school security and spend up to a half-billion dollars in response to last weekís massacre ...
Published: 02/23/18
Editorial: Six proposals for reasonable gun control

Editorial: Six proposals for reasonable gun control

Enough is enough. The mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School has renewed conversations about gun control in Washington and Tallahassee. Young people are demanding action, and there are cracks in the National Rifle Associationís solid w...
Published: 02/23/18
Editorial: The time to act on guns is now

Editorial: The time to act on guns is now

The nationís conversation on guns took an encouraging step this week in three essential places ó South Florida, Tallahassee and Washington ó as survivors, victimsí families and elected leaders searched painfully and sincerely for common ground after ...
Published: 02/22/18

Editorial: FDLE probe of state fair fiasco falls short

It should go without saying that Florida law frowns upon public officials who take freebies from vendors and whose agency throws business to their family. But that wasnít enough to move the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to find that the ex-di...
Published: 02/21/18
Updated: 02/23/18
Editorial: They value guns, not kids

Editorial: They value guns, not kids

They value guns over kidsSix days after 17 were killed at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High by a teen-ager firing an AR-15 semi-automatic rifle, the Florida House refused to even debate a bill banning the sale of assault weapons. The vote, 71 to 36, wasn...
Published: 02/21/18

Editorial: Nursing home rule should be stronger

It shouldnít take months or another tragedy for Florida ó which is hot and full of seniors ó to protect its elderly population from heat stroke in the event of an emergency. Thatís why Gov. Rick Scott had the right idea last year in calling for nursi...
Published: 02/20/18
Updated: 02/23/18
Editorial: Listen to Marjory Stoneman Douglas students demanding change

Editorial: Listen to Marjory Stoneman Douglas students demanding change

Students from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School are traveling to the state capital today and declaring "never again.íí A prominent Florida Republican fundraiser vows he wonít raise another nickel until his party approves new gun controls. Across F...
Published: 02/19/18

Editorial: No more doubt about Russian meddling in election

The latest indictment by the Justice Department special counsel, Robert Mueller, refutes President Donald Trumpís claims that Russian interference in the 2016 election was a Democratic hoax. The indictment details the lengths Russian conspirators too...
Published: 02/19/18

Another voice: Tips should belong to workers, not their bosses

The Trump administration is under fire for proposing a Labor Department regulation that could result in hotel and restaurant employers dipping into the tips customers leave for their employees, depriving the nationís 14 million hard-working restauran...
Published: 02/18/18
Updated: 02/20/18
Editorial: Trumpís rising deficits and misplaced priorities

Editorial: Trumpís rising deficits and misplaced priorities

Itís not popular in Washington or virtually anywhere else these days to express concern about the rising federal deficit. Congressional Republicans who used to be deficit hawks first voted to cut taxes by $1.5 trillion over the next decade, then rais...
Published: 02/17/18