Monday, March 19, 2018

Editorial: Florida Senate values guns over kids

By a single vote, the Florida Senate on Monday approved a sweeping response to the Marjory Stoneman Douglas massacre that includes too little gun control and too much emphasis on transforming schools into armed fortresses. Republicans altered an unpopular plan to arm teachers to allow personnel such as principals, counselors and librarians — but not most teachers — to secretly carry guns. That is window dressing for what remains a dangerous plan to put more guns on campuses. Only law enforcement officers should carry guns in schools. The legislation has positive provisions such as raising the age to buy all guns to 21, more spending for mental health and added school security. Yet Douglas High survivors and families of the 17 victims — and most voters — do not want to arm teachers. They want to ban the sale of semiautomatic assault rifles and large magazines. The Senate placed guns above kids Saturday, rejecting a ban by a 20-17 vote (see roll call, below). The bill goes today to the House, which has refused to even debate a ban. Tell legislators they aren’t listening to Floridians.

As Sen. Gary Farmer, D-Fort Lauderdale, noted Monday, Democrats tried compromise after compromise and Republicans rejected every significant attempt to improve the legislation. The Republicans’ arguments for arming school personnel and blocking bans on the sale of semiautomatic assault rifles would be comical if the stakes weren’t so high:

• Asked Saturday whether the legislation would allow local sheriffs to arm school personnel with AR-15 assault rifles, Sen. Bill Galvano, R-Bradenton, said that would be up to individual sheriffs. Really?

• Sen. David Simmons, R-Altamonte Springs, opposed a ban on the sale of assault rifles by invoking Adolf Hitler, Fidel Castro and North Korea. So AR-15 assault rifles will be a deterrent to a nuclear attack?

• Sen. Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland, claimed banning the sale of assault rifles would be similar to banning fertilizer because it was used in the Oklahoma City bombing or banning pressure cookers because they were used in the Boston Marathon bombing. Never mind that fertilizer and pressure cookers have legitimate, legal uses while the purpose of assault rifles is to kill people.

The Senate voted Saturday 20-17 to defeat a proposed ban on the sale of assault rifles, then immediately held a moment of silence to honor the Douglas High students and personnel who were killed by a shooter firing an AR-15 assault rifle. That says it all.

Tampa Bay senators


Jeff Brandes, R-St. Petersburg

(850) 487-5024 • [email protected]

Tom Lee, R-Thonotosassa

(850) 487-5020 • [email protected]

Wilton Simpson, R-Trilby

(850) 487-5010 • [email protected]


Darryl Rouson, D-St. Petersburg

(850) 487-5019 • [email protected]


Dana Young, R-Tampa

(850) 487-5018 • [email protected]

Young was present during Saturday’s session but skipped the roll call vote and later entered a "no" vote in the record.

The rest of Florida


Dennis Baxley, R-Ocala

(850) 487-5012 • [email protected]

Aaron Bean, R-Fernandina Beach

(850) 487-5004 • [email protected]

Lizbeth Benacquisto, R-Fort Myers

(850) 487-5027 • [email protected]

Rob Bradley, R-Fleming Island

(850) 487-5005 • [email protected]

Doug Broxson, R-Gulf Breeze

(850) 487-5001 • [email protected]

George Gainer, R-Panama City

(850) 487-5002 • [email protected]

Bill Galvano, R-Bradenton

(850) 487-5021 • [email protected]

Denise Grimsley, R-Sebring

(850) 487-5026 • [email protected]

Dorothy Hukill, R-Port Orange

(850) 487-5014 • [email protected]

Travis Hutson, R-Palm Coast

(850) 487-5007 • [email protected]

Debbie Mayfield, R-Vero Beach

(850) 487-5017 • [email protected]

Joe Negron, R-Stuart

(850) 487-5025 • [email protected]

Kathleen Passidomo, R-Naples

(850) 487-5028 • [email protected]

Keith Perry, R-Gainesville

(850) 487-5008 • [email protected]

David Simmons, R-Longwood

(850) 487-5009 • [email protected]

Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland

(850) 487-5022 • [email protected]

Greg Steube, R-Sarasota

(850) 487-5023 • [email protected]


Lauren Book, D-Plantation

(850) 487-5032 • [email protected]

Randolph Bracy, D-Ocoee

(850) 487-5011 • [email protected]

Oscar Braynon, D-Miami Gardens

(850) 487-5035 • [email protected]

Daphne Campbell, D-North Miami Beach

(850) 487-5038 • [email protected]

Gary Farmer, D-Fort Lauderdale

(850) 487-5034 • [email protected]

Anitere Flores, R-Miami

(850) 487-5039 • [email protected]

Rene Garcia, R-Hialeah

(850) 487-5036 • [email protected]

Audrey Gibson, D-Jacksonville

(850) 487-5006 • [email protected]

Bill Montford, D-Tallahassee

(850) 487-5003 • [email protected]

Bobby Powell, D-West Palm Beach

(850) 487-5030 • [email protected]

Kevin Rader, D-Delray Beach

(850) 487-5029 • [email protected]

Jose Javier Rodriguez, D-Miami

(850) 487-5037 • [email protected]

Linda Stewart, D-Orlando

(850) 487-5013 • [email protected]

Annette Taddeo, D-Miami

(850) 487-5040 • [email protected]

Perry Thurston, D-Fort Lauderdale

(850) 487-5033 • [email protected]

Victor Torres, D-Orlando

(850) 487-5015 • [email protected]

Editorial: Hits, errors and misses by the Florida Legislature

Editorial: Hits, errors and misses by the Florida Legislature

They named roads, replaced a state statue in the U.S. Capitol and demanded every school display "In God We Trust.’’ They embraced daylight saving time year-round and considered creating license plates for schools in Georgia and Alabama. They crafted ...
Published: 03/16/18
Editorial: Pinellas should affirm commitment to add affordable housing

Editorial: Pinellas should affirm commitment to add affordable housing

With the Penny for Pinellas local sales tax on the books for another 10 years, a stream of funding will be available for developing affordable housing, and there is a dire shortage. Rising rents are forcing low-income residents to spend a growing sha...
Published: 03/15/18
Updated: 03/16/18
Editorial: Florida Legislature fails public schools

Editorial: Florida Legislature fails public schools

Tampa Bay school district superintendents who are asking Gov. Rick Scott to call the Florida Legislature into special session and demand more money for public schools can sum up their powerful argument in two numbers. The governor asked lawmakers to ...
Published: 03/15/18

Editorial: Tech Data climbs to the top

Tech Data recently seized the throne as Florida’s largest company, a result of its steady climb and adaptability in the fast-changing technology industry. The company’s growth likewise elevates the Tampa Bay area’s importance, both in Florida and aro...
Published: 03/14/18
Updated: 03/16/18

Editorial: Pasco’s proposed solar farm is no dump

As NIMBY issues go, this is a new one.Residents of rural northeast Pasco County are up in arms over a solar farm proposed for 350 acres of pasture land across from Pasco-Hernando State College. Tampa Electric wants to install approximately 470,000 so...
Published: 03/14/18
Updated: 03/16/18

Another voice: Big tent, big result

The result of a Tuesday special election in a usually solid Republican congressional district is just the latest sign that the GOP’s toxic embrace of President Donald Trump is hurting not only the country but also their party. With all precincts repo...
Published: 03/14/18
Updated: 03/15/18
Editorial: 2 smart transportation investments for Tampa Bay

Editorial: 2 smart transportation investments for Tampa Bay

They received virtually no public attention, but buried in the tax cuts and the state budget that the Florida Legislature sent to Gov. Rick Scott are two significant provisions that would help Tampa Bay create a more robust mass transit system. Allow...
Published: 03/14/18
Editorial: Trump’s firing of Tillerson messy but necessary

Editorial: Trump’s firing of Tillerson messy but necessary

President Donald Trump’s abrupt firing by tweet of Secretary of State Rex Tillerson on Tuesday triggered another round of chaos in an administration that appears more unstable than ever. Tillerson was a moderating voice and more in line with mainstre...
Published: 03/13/18
Editorial: Trump caves to the NRA on school safety

Editorial: Trump caves to the NRA on school safety

That was quick. Not two weeks after stunning the nation with what seemed an open embrace of sensible new gun restrictions, President Donald Trump did an about-face last week, abandoning his call for modest gun control in favor of an agenda long suppo...
Updated: 11 hours ago

Another voice: Defend Florida’s gun restrictions

Florida, one of the most gun-friendly states in the nation, which took 30 years to enact any gun control measures, whose governor consistently gets the National Rifle Association’s equivalent of a gold star and that seriously considered letting colle...
Published: 03/12/18
Updated: 03/13/18