Tuesday, January 16, 2018
Editorials

Editorial: Fairness in malpractice awards restored

A small measure of justice was restored this week when the Florida Supreme Court found unconstitutional the centerpiece of a decade-old state law, saying it discriminates against the surviving relatives of medical malpractice victims based solely on how many there are. The ruling comes too late for families who already have been shortchanged. But it sends a clear message to the Florida Legislature that it cannot allow powerful political forces to trump fundamental fairness for individuals.

In a 5-2 opinion, the justices ruled Thursday that Florida's controversial 2003 medical malpractice reform violated survivors' equal protection rights because hard caps on noneconomic damages were limited to no more than $1 million in the event of a death or permanent vegetative state — regardless of the number of practitioners or survivors.

The practical effect of the law: Individual family members' share of damages was limited not by the actual pain and suffering they endured, but by how many other relatives were also entitled to part of the $1 million in noneconomic damages. What's more, when multiple parties were found at fault, their burden was lessened regardless of the severity of their malpractice simply because there were more parties to contribute toward the $1 million in damages. "We hold that to reduce damages in this fashion is not only arbitrary, but irrational, and we conclude that it 'offends the fundamental notion of equal justice under the law,' " Justice R. Fred Lewis wrote in the majority opinion.

The ruling is expected to also impact a $500,000 cap on noneconomic damages for lesser injuries. The Florida Justice Association estimates there are more than 700 medical malpractice suits pending statewide.

The bigger outrage for survivors whose noneconomic damages were capped in the last decade is that lawmakers and then-Gov. Jeb Bush were repeatedly warned this could happen. In several 2003 bill analyses written over multiple legislative sessions, the legislative staff warned that the bill "may implicate equal protection concerns under the Florida Constitution."

But constitutional concerns rarely get in the way when special interest legislation is at stake. Hospitals were seeking to limit their liability and doctors wanted lower insurance premiums. On the other side was the Trial Bar, long a nemesis of the Republican-controlled Legislature, which argued that caps would not hold doctors or their insurance companies to account. In the end, Lewis wrote, it's not even clear doctors got rate relief due to the law's caveats that allowed insurance companies to keep raising rates.

At least now survivors of the victims of medical malpractice have a fairer chance of receiving the pain and suffering damages they are reasonably due, not just an amount artificially set by the number of survivors.

Comments
Editorial: Balancing the playing field for workers’ compensation

Editorial: Balancing the playing field for workers’ compensation

For the longest time, injured workers in Florida were basically at the mercy of the whims of employers to treat them fairly. A 2003 law aimed at reducing the cost of workers’ compensation coverage for businesses had the desired impact, but it also di...
Published: 01/16/18

Another voice: Why just Florida?

Cynicism has always been a part of politics, but rarely are politicians so brazen and self-serving as President Donald Trump and his interior secretary, Ryan Zinke, have been over the past week. First they announced a new offshore drilling plan that ...
Published: 01/16/18
Editorial: King’s legacy still relevant in digital age

Editorial: King’s legacy still relevant in digital age

Today’s holiday honoring the legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. couldn’t be more timely. At a moment when the nation’s civic dialogue is choking on personal and political division, it is hard to remember an earlier time when role models were role m...
Published: 01/15/18
Editorial: Florida’s chance to make it easier to restore civil rights

Editorial: Florida’s chance to make it easier to restore civil rights

As it has for decades, Florida stubbornly clings to an inhumane, inefficient and indefensible system of justice that permanently sentences more than 1.5 million residents to second-class citizenship. This state automatically revokes the right to vote...
Published: 01/13/18
Editorial: Speak out against Trump’s vulgar remarks

Editorial: Speak out against Trump’s vulgar remarks

President Donald Trump’s vulgar outbursts during a White House meeting on immigration are racist and indefensible no matter how he parses them. They are not presidential, they undermine U.S. foreign relations and they do not reflect America’s values....
Published: 01/12/18

Editorial: Pinellas commission stands up for accountability

The Pinellas County Commission has gotten the message that it should not be a rubber stamp. Commissioners sent a clear signal this week they will demand more accountability of local agencies by refusing to approve nominees for the board for CareerSou...
Published: 01/11/18
Updated: 01/12/18

Editorial: Progress on Tampa Bay graduation rates

Tampa Bay’s four school districts all reached a significant milestone last school year: achieving graduation rates over 80 percent. It’s believed to be the first time Pinellas, Hillsborough, Pasco and Hernando counties all surpassed that threshold, a...
Published: 01/11/18
Updated: 01/12/18

Take deal; build wall

President Donald Trump says he is optimistic a deal can be struck to shield "Dreamers," the young undocumented immigrants whose lives he put in jeopardy by stripping them of work permits and deportation protection, beginning March 5. His price, and t...
Published: 01/10/18
Updated: 01/11/18
Editorial: Trump’s reversal on drilling a victory for Florida

Editorial: Trump’s reversal on drilling a victory for Florida

The Trump administration’s abrupt reversal on its foolhardy plan to allow more oil drilling off Florida’s coastlines is a win for the Sunshine State, regardless of whether it is based more on politics than environmental concerns. Drilling poses a uni...
Published: 01/10/18
Editorial: Welcome steps toward cracking down on dangerous teen parties

Editorial: Welcome steps toward cracking down on dangerous teen parties

Getting to the bottom of the shootings that left two people dead after a New Year’s Day teen party, one a 15-year-old girl, is the job of the Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office. Investigators so far have said that the two security guards who fired ...
Published: 01/09/18
Updated: 01/12/18