Tuesday, September 18, 2018
Editorials

FCAT fiasco points up failures at the top

The Florida Board of Education was in crisis mode Tuesday, holding an emergency meeting by telephone to change on the fly the illogical scoring of this year's FCAT writing test. Public anger at the overuse of high-stakes standardized tests finally boiled over, as more than 800 people listened in to the conference call and queued up to question how this mess happened — and what it means for their children and their schools. What it means is that there is too much emphasis on standardized tests and that the state's manipulation of the rules render the test scores meaningless.

Faced with an uprising, the board had little choice but to control the damage and essentially grade on the curve to improve the results. It dropped the passing score to 3 (out of 6) instead of keeping it at a 4. That makes the results look more plausible and avoids the inaccurate perception that student performance dropped off a cliff overnight. But that answer is only a stopgap, and it raises significant issues about the meaning and the value of the FCAT, which affects everything from school grades to teacher bonuses. Those are issues that the board and Education Commission Gerard Robinson need to revisit if Florida's accountability system is to retain any of its quickly collapsing credibility. Robinson's failure to anticipate this mess also erodes confidence in his ability to chart a clear path for education in this state.

The FCAT writing exam itself didn't change. Administered to fourth-, eighth- and 10th-graders, it remains a 45-minute test that begins with a "prompt" that spurs a student to start writing. But two things about the grading changed. Punctuation, spelling and grammar, as well as supporting details, were graded harder, which meant that a passing grade of 4 was more difficult to earn. And each test was marked by two graders instead of one. That's actually an improvement, but it meant that when graders disagreed, they would split the difference and give half-point grades. That effectively lowered the number of passing tests as well.

Then came the fallout. For example, 81 percent of last year's fourth-graders scored 4 or higher. This year, under the tougher rules, only 27 percent did. As the education commissioner admitted, he knew there was a problem because "students didn't overnight become bad writers."

Indeed they didn't. The past two years, the vast majority of students scored right in the middle, in the 3- to 4-point range — 72 percent of fourth-graders last year versus 73 percent this year, for example. While there were more 3's and fewer 4's this year, as one would expect from tougher standards, that's not a sea change. But the scoring rules — which are subjective — made it seem like one. The subjectivity is obvious this year by the number of 3.5's awarded — every one of them represents a disagreement between the two graders. More than one in five fourth-graders got one.

This debacle should reinforce that a school's letter grade is made up of lots of elements that are far from objective measures and may ultimately say little that is meaningful about a school. It's a stew of calculations that results in a simplistic rating that doesn't begin to give parents and students enough information.

As the state moves to common nationally based assessments and appropriate end-of-course exams that test the material that should have been learned in the classroom, officials should be chastened by this fiasco. Schools should be held accountable for student performance, but the measurement needs to be scaled appropriately.

Comments
Editorial: FDA acts to keep e-cigarettes from kids

Editorial: FDA acts to keep e-cigarettes from kids

The federal Food and Drug Administration is bringing important scrutiny to the increasing use of e-cigarettes, requiring companies that make and sell them to show they are keeping their products away from minors. Vaping is the new front in the nation...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Tuesday’s letters: Honor Flight restored my faith in America

Dogs are the best | Letter, Sept. 15Honor Flight restored my faith in AmericaJust as I was about to give up on our country due to divisiveness and and the divisions among its people and politicians, my pride was restored. As a member of the recen...
Updated: 8 hours ago

Editorial cartoons for Sept. 18

From Times wires
Published: 09/17/18

Column: We’re measuring the economy all wrong

Ten years after the collapse of Lehman Bros., the official economic statistics — the ones that fill news stories, television shows and presidential tweets — say that the U.S. economy is fully recovered.The unemployment rate is lower tha...
Published: 09/17/18
Editorial: Senate should delay vote on Kavanaugh

Editorial: Senate should delay vote on Kavanaugh

The Senate and the nation needs to hear more about the sexual assault allegation against U.S. Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh. Setting aside Kavanaugh's judicial record, his political past and the hyper-partisan divide over his nomination, a no...
Published: 09/17/18
Editorial: Tampa council has another chance to show it takes Stovall House changes seriously

Editorial: Tampa council has another chance to show it takes Stovall House changes seriously

The Tampa City Council has yet to hear a compelling reason to allow a private social club in a residential neighborhood off Bayshore Boulevard, and a final meeting on the matter scheduled for Thursday offers the council a chance to show the diligence...
Published: 09/14/18
Editorial: Focus on Hurricane Florence, not defending poor response in Puerto Rico

Editorial: Focus on Hurricane Florence, not defending poor response in Puerto Rico

Hurricane Florence began lashing down on the Carolinas Thursday and was expected to make landfall early Friday, washing over dunes, downing trees and power lines and putting some 10 million people in the path of a potentially catastrophic storm. Flor...
Published: 09/13/18
Editorial: Scott sends positive signal on Supreme Court appointments

Editorial: Scott sends positive signal on Supreme Court appointments

Gov. Rick Scott has headed down a dangerous path by announcing he has started the process to fill three upcoming vacancies on the Florida Supreme Court as he heads out the door. But to his credit, the governor indicated his "expectation’’ is that he ...
Published: 09/12/18
Updated: 09/14/18
Editorial: Stalled U.S.-Cuba relations hurting Florida business

Editorial: Stalled U.S.-Cuba relations hurting Florida business

After an encouraging start, the breakdown in America’s reset with Cuba is a loss for both sides and for the state of democracy across the region. Havana and Washington are both to blame, but the Trump administration’s hard line with Cuba is out of sy...
Published: 09/12/18
Lessons from Moonves’ ouster

Lessons from Moonves’ ouster

If the swift departure of CBS Chairman Les Moonves has a bright side, it’s that a major television network took accusations of sexual harassment against its chief executive seriously enough to hold him accountable and obtain his resignation even at t...
Published: 09/11/18
Updated: 09/14/18