Make us your home page
A Times Editorial

Immigration not state’s top priority

As the Florida Legislature prepares for its 2012 session, illegal immigration is sure to make headlines again. But before Gov. Rick Scott and the Legislature proceed, they should take a hard look at the hard-line approaches by Alabama and Georgia and the devastating effect they have had on the states' agricultural interests. What may make for rousing political speeches can result in crops rotting in the fields because there are no workers to harvest them.

The idea that undocumented immigrants would be replaced in the fields by unemployed American citizens has proven to be out of touch with reality. As an Associated Press examination of the consequences of Alabama's strict new immigration law noted, although federal courts are reviewing elements of the stricter immigrations laws, many Hispanic farm workers have fled the state. Even Hispanics in this country legally fear being caught up in law enforcement sweeps of farms looking for illegal workers.

That should mean there are plenty of jobs available to pick tomatoes and other crops. But farmers note American workers aren't up to the grinding task of picking fruits and vegetables, noting many can barely last a day in the fields. That leaves crops unpicked and farmers scrambling to save their businesses. Depending on the crop and the farm, most experienced farm workers make less than $12,000 a year. But that is experience few Americans seem unable or unwilling to learn.

And yet, despite growing evidence illegal farm workers are not denying Americans jobs while underscoring their importance in sustaining a healthy agricultural economy, politically motivated efforts persist in pursuing illegal aliens even at the risk of hurting American farms dependent on their labor.

A Florida House bill that would have given law enforcement officials wide-ranging power to check someone's immigration status and required businesses to use the federal government's E-Verify system died last year when it could not be reconciled with a somewhat milder Senate version. As the 2012 session is set to begin in January, Scott and Senate President Mike Haridopolos have said immigration remains a priority, while House Speaker Dean Cannon correctly downplayed the issue. Cannon pragmatically noted the Legislature has more pressing matters such as budget concerns, redistricting and the economy to occupy its time.

Immigration remains a federal issue, and there is a pressing need to create more legal avenues for farm workers to be in this country legally to harvest crops. Without such workers, Florida agriculture would be at risk. Scott and Haridopolos should follow Cannon's common-sense lead and focus their energies on other issues of more vital interest to Florida's future, rather than attempting to deprive migrant workers — legal and otherwise — of a dirty but important job no one else seems to want.

Immigration not state’s top priority 11/27/11 [Last modified: Sunday, November 27, 2011 12:59pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours