Friday, December 15, 2017
Opinion

Guns an absolute right? Not at all.

The "Second Amendment," more than a right, has become a rhetorical device. It's a counterargument in two words, a rallying cry designed to end debate. Want to restrict firearms, or regulate their sale, or limit which kinds Americans can buy?

Meet the Second Amendment, the simplest rebuttal goes. It creates the unfettered right to own guns in America. Full stop.

This claim — prominent among gun-rights advocates — implies that the Second Amendment establishes not just a right to own guns, but a right that the government cannot legally limit. The problem with this argument: None of our rights work this way.

"The Supreme Court has said repeatedly that no right under the Constitution is absolute," says Adam Winkler, a law professor at UCLA and the author of Gunfight: The Battle over the Right to Bear Arms in America. "In general, where the government has very strong reasons to restrict a right, it can."

Take the First Amendment right to free speech, which sounds pretty ironclad ("Congress shall make no law... abridging the freedom of speech"). In the most famous example of what Winkler is talking about, the Supreme Court has said the First Amendment doesn't protect your right to shout "Fire!" in a crowded theater that is not, in fact, on fire. You can't say whatever you want, wherever you want, in other words, if what you want to say might cause a riot endangering public safety.

Also, about those air-tight free-speech rights: You can't just libel people willy-nilly, or incite murder, or leak government secrets, or distribute child pornography, or say certain words on TV, or pass out political pamphlets wherever you want.

And that's just one right contained in the First Amendment.

The Fourth Amendment says you have a right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. But you still have to go through security at airports. You can still be stopped at a drunk-driving checkpoint.

Your right to private property? The government can still take it from you under eminent domain. Your right to freedom of religion? That doesn't mean a government clerk can deny same-sex couples marriage licenses, or that a baker can refuse to sell those couples wedding cakes.

You have a right to be free from racial discrimination. But, for example, if a race riot breaks out in a state prison, the government can separate inmates by race to end the violence.

"Same thing with gun rights," Winkler says. "We already restrict access to firearms in many ways. We prohibit people from owning machine guns. We prohibit people from owning shoulder-launched missiles and hand grenades. We prohibit felons and the mentally ill from possessing firearms."

The Second Amendment in effect is no more absolute than any of our other rights, and yet a vocal camp in our public debates often describes it that way. "We see a lot more absolutist rhetoric today than we did in the past," Winkler says, "partly because we have over the last 40 years seen the rise of a rather extreme pro-gun movement, led by the NRA."

We can still argue about semiautomatic weapons bans and universal background checks and whether such policies would curb gun violence. But citing "the Second Amendment!" by itself in those debates isn't a valid argument for shutting them down.

— Washington Post

Comments

Column: Tax reform is the right path forward for Florida

In Washington, the tax reform process continues to move steadily forward, increasing the likelihood that Floridians will be able to keep more of their own money next year. While it has been the subject of a great deal of criticism (and outright misle...
Published: 12/14/17
Editorial: Rubio should make good his threat to oppose tax cuts without changes

Editorial: Rubio should make good his threat to oppose tax cuts without changes

For once, it would be nice to see Sen. Marco Rubio stand up as the independent leader he aspires to become. For once, the Florida Republican should hold his position rather than bow to pragmatic politics. Rubio can stick with his threat Thursday to v...
Published: 12/14/17

Column: An important thing you probably knew nothing about — tax-exempt Private Activity Bonds

Only tax attorneys and God fully comprehend the federal tax code that has governed private activity bonds since 1968.But most of us can understand results.Such tax-exempt bonds over the years have literally saved millions of dollars in borrowing cost...
Published: 12/14/17
Column: How the 2018 midterms could end the nightmare of Trump

Column: How the 2018 midterms could end the nightmare of Trump

It is slowly dawning on Republicans and the right-wing media echo chamber that President Donald Trump’s assault on democratic norms and the rule of law, his betrayal of his own populist campaign themes (with tax cuts for the rich and Medicaid spendin...
Published: 12/14/17
Column: How Doug Jones lost in nearly every congressional district but still won the state

Column: How Doug Jones lost in nearly every congressional district but still won the state

Preliminary numbers for Alabama’s U.S. Senate election crunched by J. Miles Coleman of Decision Desk HQ reveal something astonishing: Democrat Doug Jones lost in six of Alabama’s seven congressional districts, but he still managed to beat Roy Moore b...
Published: 12/14/17
Joe Henderson: Recent cold snap brings to mind the Big Chill of Christmas ‘89

Joe Henderson: Recent cold snap brings to mind the Big Chill of Christmas ‘89

You know that little snap of frigid — OK, chilly — weather we just had? In Florida, we call that winter, a season we typically measure in hours.If it’s really savage, the thermometer might not rise above 50 degrees for two or sometimes three whole da...
Published: 12/14/17

Another voice: A shameful anniversary

Josephine "Joey" Gay should have celebrated her 12th birthday this week. She should have been surrounded by friends and family in a place festooned with purple, her favorite color.Chase Kowalski should have been working toward a Boy Scout merit badge...
Published: 12/13/17
Updated: 12/14/17
Editorial cartoons for Dec. 15

Editorial cartoons for Dec. 15

These cartoons are from various Times wire services.
Published: 12/13/17
Updated: 12/14/17
Editorial: Congress should block efforts to expand offshore drilling

Editorial: Congress should block efforts to expand offshore drilling

Timing is everything, and Sen. Bill Nelson seized the right moment this week to call on his colleagues to pass legislation he filed earlier this year that would block the Trump administration from opening additional areas to offshore drilling. With t...
Published: 12/13/17
Goodman: The night Alabama woke up America

Goodman: The night Alabama woke up America

After weeks during which the people of Alabama were prejudged as incapable or unwilling to decipher right from wrong, they proved themselves by blazing a new path to virtue.They defied tradition. They defied political party. They defied the elites wh...
Published: 12/13/17