Monday, May 28, 2018
Letters To The Editor

Vote for May Letter of the Month

Editor's note: Letters to the editor offer a significant contribution to the discussion of public policy and life in Tampa Bay. To recognize some of that work by our most engaged readers, the Times will select a letter of the month and the writers will be recognized at the end of the year. We will choose the finalists each month based on relevance on topical issues, persuasiveness and writing style. The writer's opinion does not need to match the editorial board's opinion on the issue to be nominated. But clarity of thinking, brevity and a sense of humor certainly helps.

Help us choose the letter of the month for May 2014 by reading through the three nominated letters and voting on the ballot at the bottom of the web page.

_______________________

Retirement realities | April 28, commentary

It's income, not assets

Robert Samuelson claims that most baby boomers are prepared for retirement because the median home equity balance for this group is $120,000 and the median retirement plan balance is $100,000. He makes the common mistake of making this about assets rather than income.

In reality, retirement planning is all about how much income one can generate each year. Few financial planners would ever recommend that a retiree withdraw more than 4 percent of their total asset base annually. Therefore, even if we include the home equity (which many would be reluctant to do) as an available asset, these median asset numbers would generate only $8,800 in annual income. Throw in the average Social Security benefit of $1,300 per month and Samuelson is expecting retirees to live off $24,400 per year. And keep in mind that the balances he gives are the median numbers. That means half of the baby boomers would have less than $220,000 in available assets.

He is correct that one possible solution is to work longer. In fact, for many that will be the only solution. Unfortunately, the last I checked there weren't many organizations looking to hire 70-year-olds.

The fact is that we are facing a very real and unfortunately inevitable retirement crisis over the next 30 years. That is the true retirement reality.

Scott Stolz, Tarpon Springs (May 4)

_______________________

Lost chance for cleaner springs

May 6, editorial

Environment imperiled

Thank you to the Tampa Bay Times for the important articles and editorials about the Florida Legislature and lack of money allocated to springs cleanup. The pictures of lawmakers hugging and congratulating themselves after finishing work on the budget was infuriating. There are a lot of issues clamoring for attention, but springs cleanup should have been a priority. How can lawmakers not know or not care that environmental health is essential to human health and the health of the economy?

I grew up in Pinellas County before electronic distractions and we were always outside, enjoying and appreciating the beauty of our salt and freshwater resources. Swimming with the mermaids at Weeki Wachee in the '60s, tubing down the Ichetucknee River in the '70s, and canoeing down the Rainbow River with my children in the '90s was as close to paradise as one could get. I still think Florida is beautiful, but we must repair and actively care for this fragile beauty.

How can our lawmakers, Republican and Democrat, many with children and grandchildren, fail to take immediate action or, worse, make deals with big business at the expense of Florida's environment and our future?

Amy C. Kelly, Palm Harbor (May 10)

_______________________

Democracy's failure to reverse inequality | May 15, commentary

To remedy inequality, change law

I was dismayed by this column's conclusion that there might be little that democracies can do to stop the rise of inequality. This is a false conclusion drawn from a false framing that only taxation policy can be applied to the problem.

Economies are the sum total of the laws and regulations that make them up. Laws that we write through our elected government have a huge impact on outcomes. For example, there is nothing "natural" about the fact that corporations are chartered at the state level instead of the federal. There is nothing natural about the limited liability joint stock corporation, the company design most of us work for. It is a creature of law.

A proposal that would go a long way toward solving inequality would be a National Companies Act that charters corporations for a national economy at a national level. Under the new definition, in return for limited liability, every corporation employee (and only employees) would be equal voting shareholders. Depending on company size, the employee-shareholders would regularly elect management or the board of directors. These corporations could raise money from banks, crowd-sourcing and selling nonvoting shares. That's it.

This is not some pie-in-the-sky proposal. This institutional design has existed in the United States as long as the corporation. In Minnesota and Wisconsin, every type of business has been organized this way for 100 years. It is called the cooperative.

Cooperative-corporations will compete and operate in a free market economy just like existing corporations they would replace, with no additional regulation or government intervention needed.

But can you imagine employees electing CEOs who pay themselves 1,000 times the average worker's salary? Broad, much more equal wealth distribution would happen "naturally" by design.

Robert Clark, Tampa

Comments

Monday’s letters: NFL finally listens to its fans

NFL moves to endanthem protests | May 24NFL’s action comes too lateThe NFL owners are, after two years, finally growing some courage.Before these kneel-downs became the elephant in the room, team owners could have taken action to minimize the imp...
Published: 05/24/18
Updated: 05/25/18

Sunday’s letters: As Jews, we should not be afraid to criticize Israel

Published: 05/24/18
Updated: 05/25/18

Saturday’s letters: Bayshore fatalities didn’t have to happen

After two fatalities, speed limits cut | May 25Cameras needed on BayshoreOnce again, two pedestrians have died as the result of careless drivers who were speeding. Once again, the Times and other media outlets are filled with opinions about the c...
Published: 05/23/18
Updated: 05/25/18

Friday's letters: Thanks to jurors for fulfilling civic duty

May is Juror Appreciation Month Thanks, jurors, for your service Trial by a jury of one’s peers is among the bedrock guarantees that make our representative democracy exceptional. Without it, the courtroom fates of defendants and civil litiga...
Published: 05/23/18
Updated: 05/25/18

Thursday’s letters: Heated chemotherapy won’t treat most ovarian cancers

Heated chemotherapy has promising results | May 16Cancer treatment not a cure-all While we were pleased to see the story about ovarian cancer treatment, we are concerned that the article could mislead many patients. The treatment described has be...
Published: 05/22/18
Updated: 05/24/18

Wednesday’s letters: A princess gives us a lesson to live by

Royal treatment | May 21Princess offers advice for us allThe radiant and joyful Princess Anna Noela Lokolo of the Democratic Republic of Congo, recent Eckerd College graduate, has given us a huge gift in her parting words. "If people have a negat...
Published: 05/21/18
Updated: 05/23/18

Hernando Letters to the Editor for May 25

Re: Central High School bomb threat suspect to be tried as adult | May 4Angry mob rhetoric not helpfulWe have observed the public discourse surrounding the case of Mizella Robinson with increasing unease. A sampling of the more common sentiment...
Published: 05/21/18
Updated: 05/22/18

Pasco Letters to the Editor for May 25

Re: Proposed TECO Solar Plant Opposed to the TECO solar plantAs a 21-year resident and property owner, I am writing in opposition to the proposed Tampa Electric Company solar plant in rural northeast Pasco County.The solar plant will be .2 miles from...
Published: 05/21/18
Updated: 05/22/18

Tuesday’s letters: If you don’t like the Electoral College, then amend the Constitution

The popular vote | May 20, letterIf you don’t like it, amend ConstitutionA recent letter supports the idea that a state should be able to change its Electoral College vote to match that of the national popular vote winner as opposed to the result...
Published: 05/21/18
Updated: 05/22/18

Monday’s letters: Focusing on the mental state of shooters misses the point

Texas high school shooting | May 18Criminals, angry people kill peopleSchool shootings are a distinctly American phenomenon. But shootings by people with serious mental illness represent less than 1 percent of all yearly gun-related homicides in ...
Published: 05/19/18
Updated: 05/21/18