Saturday, April 21, 2018
Opinion

My simple rule for sex tape cases

What's newsworthy? That's the legal question at the heart of the Bollea vs. Gawker Media trial in St. Petersburg, which revolves around a videotape showing the wrestler Hulk Hogan (real name Terry Bollea), having sex with the wife of a friend. Apparently, the friend, radio host Bubba the Love Sponge Clem, took the video without Bollea's knowledge.

After the online news and gossip site Gawker posted an edited version of the sex tape, Bollea sued Gawker for invasion of privacy. He's seeking $100 million in damages. Gawker has raised the First Amendment as a defense and says that its action is constitutionally protected speech because Bollea is a public figure who has frequently discussed his sex life in books, interviews and his reality TV show.

So here we have high-minded constitutional principles running up against low fare.

The law allows recovery for publicly disclosing private information if the revelation would be offensive to a reasonable person and if the information is not "newsworthy." Put another way, the facts disclosed must not be a matter of legitimate public concern.

But courts have failed to offer a definition or way of determining what is newsworthy. Should juries assess newsworthiness according to the public's actual interest in the material? Isn't anything then newsworthy if enough people want to look at it? By this standard, the Hogan videotape is newsworthy simply because many people watched it and — logically — there is virtually no such thing as an invasion of privacy in a prurient society.

Alternatively, should juries determine newsworthiness according to what the public should be interested in? But then who gets to decide what's valid and what's not? Who's to say that much of what fills the periodicals at supermarket cash registers isn't newsworthy, given that so many people are interested in gossip about celebrities?

This is not a new issue, but it arises far more often now than in the past because of the Internet, which makes it possible to disseminate information to a mass audience quickly. Sex and the First Amendment are thus in constant contact.

Indeed, this case reflects how the changing notions of privacy in society make it much harder to decide what would be offensive to the reasonable person and what isn't of public concern. But juries, it's said, make decisions based on emotion, on the gut. Accordingly, the St. Petersburg jurors may ultimately find it hard to accept that Gawker's speech rights reach into Bollea's bedroom, notwithstanding the plaintiff's lewd persona. There is a difference, after all, between talking about sex and watching it.

If the jury sides with Bollea, First Amendment absolutists will worry about the "chilling effect" the verdict may have on speech, and will claim it's impossible to draw a line between permissible and impermissible expression. Speech is speech.

But I can imagine a clear rule: No videos of people having sex should be made public unless all of the participants consent. I think the media will survive the restriction.

Erwin Chemerinsky is dean and Raymond Pryke Professor of First Amendment Law at the University of California at Irvine School of Law. He wrote this for the Los Angeles Times.

Comments
Romano: Okay, now who sounds like a hysterical teen talking about guns?

Romano: Okay, now who sounds like a hysterical teen talking about guns?

The writer of the letter sounds hysterical. Perhaps a little desperate. And maybe that’s just who Marion Hammer is these days.Most of the world knows her as the take-no-prisoners maven of the National Rifle Association who directs Florida politicians...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Goodman: In America, truth is missing in action

Goodman: In America, truth is missing in action

It’s "Mueller Time," as the nation grows ever closer to a confrontation with the truth.Was collusion with the Russians an illusion? If not, who was involved, what was done, and when? Did it impact the 2016 campaign, the fate of Hillary Clinton and no...
Published: 04/20/18
Editorial: New Cuba president is chance for new start

Editorial: New Cuba president is chance for new start

For all the symbolism, Raul Castro’s handoff of the Cuban presidency this week amounts to less than meets the eye even if his handpicked successor, the Communist Party functionary Miguel Diaz-Canel Bermudez, is the first person not named Castro to le...
Published: 04/20/18

Editorial: A missed chance for open primary elections

The Florida Constitution Revision Commission did a lot of things wrong this week by combining unrelated or unpalatable provisions into single amendments that will appear on the November ballot. It also wasted an opportunity to do one thing right. The...
Published: 04/20/18
Editorial: When they visit Nature’s Classroom, kids are right where they belong

Editorial: When they visit Nature’s Classroom, kids are right where they belong

The Hillsborough school district planted a fruitful seed with the opening of Nature’s Classroom five decades ago on the cypress-lined banks of the Hillsborough River northeast of Tampa. • The lessons taught there to some 17,000 sixth graders each yea...
Published: 04/20/18
Howard Altman: Tampa company analyzed strike on Syrian facilities

Howard Altman: Tampa company analyzed strike on Syrian facilities

After President Donald Trump announced the U.S., France and England had carried out attacks on three Syrian chemical weapons centers, a Tampa company began its own analysis of the bomb damage.The analysis, by geospatial intelligence firm Radiant Solu...
Published: 04/20/18

Editorial: Equality pays off on Southwest Flight 1380

The passengers of Southwest Flight 1380 can be thankful that, 33 years ago, the U.S. Navy took the lead on equal opportunity.Capt. Tammie Jo Shults was piloting the flight from New York to Dallas on Tuesday when an engine exploded, blowing out a wind...
Published: 04/19/18
Updated: 04/20/18
Editorial cartoons for April 21-23

Editorial cartoons for April 21-23

These cartoons are from various Times wire services.
Published: 04/19/18
Updated: 04/20/18
Book review: James Comey wants to explain himself

Book review: James Comey wants to explain himself

In 2016, as the director of the FBI, James Comey publicly dissected Hillary Clinton’s email server controversy. Later, we learned that Comey was keeping to himself the beginnings of an investigation into Russia’s active interference in the U.S. elect...
Published: 04/19/18
Updated: 04/20/18
Nickens: Democratic candidates for governor are not ready for prime time

Nickens: Democratic candidates for governor are not ready for prime time

Here’s a sentence that will surprise some folks: I agree with Blaise Ingoglia.Ingoglia is the chairman of the Republican Party of Florida and a state representative from Spring Hill. That’s an inherent conflict that he doesn’t recognize, and we don’t...
Published: 04/19/18
Updated: 04/20/18