Monday, August 13, 2018
Opinion

Should you trust the news you're reading?

One of the hottest questions in the aftermath of the 2016 election has been how to fight the plague of fake news. Facebook has alternately evaded and grappled with its role in the crisis. Fake-news writers have explained their motivations. And my Washington Post colleague David Ignatius has looked at the international implications of a wave of falsehoods.

As much as it's important to push back on what's not true, it's also important to focus on what is trustworthy and to explain why outlets and reporters who continually do a good job amidst this onslaught are worth trusting. After this disorienting election, I reached out to a wide range of friends from all points on the political spectrum to ask what outlets and which writers they had confidence in and to explain the reasons for that confidence.

Many of the people who responded suggested that they trusted individual writers — or the judgment of individual people passing along stories — more than the trusted specific institutions.

"This will be unsatisfying, but I (increasingly) don't trust organizations or outlets; I trust individual journalists and opinion leaders. This is partly because I think it's harder (nowadays) for outlets to impose quality control, editing, fact checking, etc., and partly because Twitter is a primary means of consuming information," wrote the Daily Caller's Matt Lewis. "This is not to say that some outlets aren't dramatically more trustworthy than others, but the brand name that I tend to trust is the one on the byline, not the masthead."

"I've found myself gravitating to specific, individual trusted voices, not just as sources but as curators of other sources — e.g., trusted filters: (The Washington Post)'s own Dave Fahrenthold, Greg Sargent and Dave Weigel come to mind, as do MSNBC's Joy Reid, CBS' (and now the New York Times') Sopan Deb, Slate's Jamelle Bouie and Time's James Poniewozik," agreed Jeff Yang, vice president of cultural strategy for the research and branding firm Sparks and Honey, and a prominent advocate for inclusion and diversity in the entertainment industry. "Note that each of the publications these individuals work for also have sources I considered to be unreliable and in fact, truly problematic, as far as promoting trivia or spreading falsehood."

"Does 'My own personal Twitter feed' count?" as a trusted source of news, Washington Free Beacon executive editor and Washington Post contributor Sonny Bunch wrote. "I mean, honestly, I trust people more than I trust institutions. And I've curated a feed that delivers quality news from discerning people."

Other correspondents passed along more specific outlets or rules of thumb.

Dara Lind, a staff writer for Vox who covers immigration and criminal-justice issues and co-writes the Vox Sentences newsletter, wrote that she has been finding the Wall Street Journal useful because the way its coverage is framed can help her see big stories from a new perspective.

"Because its coverage of the business world and its foreign desks, for example, aren't usually refracted through the lens of U.S. politics, I feel that the information I get from reading the (Wall Street Journal) is more useful in helping me understand a news story on its own terms - it might not help me win an argument, but it keeps me informed," she explained.

"I tend to trust the outlets that run headlines at odds with their editorial point of view," offered Ben Shapiro, who left Breitbart this year and now serves as editor in chief of the conservative site Daily Wire. "So, for example, National Review will run headlines that praise Trump even though the publication opposed Trump. (The Washington Post) will run anti-Hillary headlines. Breitbart will rarely run an anti-Trump headline."

Nick Baumann, senior enterprise editor at the Huffington Post, wrote back with a lengthy list of basic tests for readers, among them checking how long the outlet has been around and what its leanings are, trying to figure out what else the author has written and seeing whether any other outlet has confirmed the story's findings.

"Does the writer show her work by saying how and where she got her information? Or does she simply assert things?" he wrote. "Do the names in this story sound made up? Are experts cited? If you Google their names, are they real? ... Does this story being true require there having been a secret conspiracy to hide it? How many people would have to be involved in that conspiracy? The more people who would have had to be involved, the less likely the story is to be true. The main question is the classic one: Is this too good to be true?"

These ideas are only helpful, of course, if people want to verify that what they're reading is real. For the rest of us, the fake-news epidemic demands of us that we do more than share good stories. We have to explain why we're passing along the news, what we trust about it and why.

— Washington Post

Comments
Stand your ground now means we must read the mind of an accused killer

Stand your ground now means we must read the mind of an accused killer

Today, the liberals are doing a victory dance.And the conservatives are resting easier.Pinellas-Pasco State Attorney Bernie McCabe has done them all a huge favor by bringing a manslaughter charge against convenience store shooter Michael Drejka.You s...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Editorial: Why stand your ground has to go

Editorial: Why stand your ground has to go

Pinellas-Pasco State Attorney Bernie McCabe made a reasonable decision to charge Michael Drejka with manslaughter in last month’s deadly Clearwater convenience store parking lot confrontation. The shooting, which erupted over use of a handicap parkin...
Updated: 9 hours ago
PolitiFact Florida: Gwen Graham lacks proof that Florida Gov. Rick Scott covered up Mosaic sinkhole

PolitiFact Florida: Gwen Graham lacks proof that Florida Gov. Rick Scott covered up Mosaic sinkhole

Gwen Graham says Florida needs a governor who will fight to protect clean water, unlike, she said, Gov. Rick Scott."When a sinkhole began dumping toxic water in Florida’s aquifer, Rick Scott tried to cover it up. I worked with the press to expose the...
Published: 08/13/18
Romano: Two years later, politicians still ignoring Florida voters on medical marijuana

Romano: Two years later, politicians still ignoring Florida voters on medical marijuana

The war is over, except no one in Tallahassee has bothered to read the news.And so Florida continues its daft fight against medical marijuana. All of which means patients are being left behind, voters are getting ignored, and lawyers are buying fanci...
Published: 08/11/18
The US military’s no-good, very bad tweets

The US military’s no-good, very bad tweets

The U.S. military is extremely online.Most of the Twitter accounts for the armed forces’ branches boast followings in the millions, but that’s no surprise in a country whose military capabilities are national legend. What is surprising is the way the...
Published: 08/11/18
Satire: What really happened at that Trump Tower meeting

Satire: What really happened at that Trump Tower meeting

Everybody wants to know what was said in that Trump Tower meeting with the Russians in June 2016. Well, other than the people in the room, I, Steven Yablonsky, alone know exactly what was said because I worked as a janitor in the building and was hid...
Updated: 11 hours ago
Uber and Lyft are making traffic jams worse, not better

Uber and Lyft are making traffic jams worse, not better

Have you heard that Uber and Lyft are helping alleviate traffic congestion by getting us to give up our personal cars?That reassuring notion, nurtured by the ride-hailing services, gets repeated often. I’ve heard various forms of the bromide three ti...
Published: 08/10/18
Jesuit High opens new Chapel of the Holy Cross, a ‘sermon in brick and stone’

Jesuit High opens new Chapel of the Holy Cross, a ‘sermon in brick and stone’

TAMPAFor more than two years, students, faculty and staff have watched workers turn bricks and columns into a soaring architectural work at the center of Jesuit High School’s 40-acre Tampa campus.On Tuesday, more than 500 people turned out for the cu...
Published: 08/09/18
Updated: 08/11/18
Living ‘unfiltered’ puts Sarah Jeong in tight spot

Living ‘unfiltered’ puts Sarah Jeong in tight spot

In March, a liberal furor erupted when the Atlantic magazine briefly hired Kevin Williamson, a conservative writer with National Review. Several years earlier, Williamson had written a short tweet in which he seemed to suggest that women who obtain a...
Published: 08/09/18
Updated: 08/10/18
Editorial: Politics aside, arguments are clear for moving appellate court to Tampa

Editorial: Politics aside, arguments are clear for moving appellate court to Tampa

It’s time to re-establish a permanent home for the state appeals court that serves the Tampa Bay region.It makes sense to put it in Tampa, the same as it made sense 30 years ago when the court’s operations began moving piece by piece up Interstate 4 ...
Published: 08/09/18
Updated: 08/10/18