Monday, April 23, 2018
Pasco News

Pasco County judge refuses to stop west side school rezoning

In a late Thursday night ruling, after four hours of testimony, Pasco County judge Kimberly Sharpe Byrd declined to give some west-side parents the relief they'd been seeking for months.

Noting students return to classes in a week, Byrd decided that forcing the school district to undo its recently adopted attendance zones for Trinity-area middle and high schools would create undue disruption to the community. So she refused to order an injunction against the plan, which the parents had challenged as having been adopted in violation of Florida's open meetings law.

"Between the two competing interests, I am going to find it would not serve the public interest to issue an injunction," Byrd said after brief deliberations that followed the third day of her hearing, which ended after 8 p.m. Thursday.

She did not rule on the underlying complaint that members of the district's west-side rezoning advisory committee violated state Sunshine rules, which require that elected and appointed officials discuss in public all issues that are likely to come before their panel for a vote.

Related coverage: Parents' challenges to Pasco school rezoning decisions to be heard next week

Sharon Carlstedt Britton, the lawyer representing the complaining parents, contended in her summary statement that some advisory committee members had multiple conversations, including in social media, where they talked about rezoning topics such as which communities should be reassigned to different schools. Some of them privately communicated with district planning director Chris Williams about the specifics, she said, and none of the emails were shared even with others on the committee.

"We're talking about making law. And in this state, if you're going to make law, you have to do it in public. You can't do it in private emails," Britton argued.

She also spoke of how the advisory committee broke into separate groups during its sessions, having conversations that not everyone was privvy to hearing. 

"If that's the way we operate, then every single law we make can be done in secret. The problem is, we don't know what anybody was saying. We don't know what anybody's agenda is," she said. "There were people with agendas. That's one of the reasons we have the Sunshine Law. To know how people vote for things and why."

Representing the school district, attorney Dennis Alfonso contended the plaintiffs provided no proof that any advisory committee members talked about any voting issues in private. They might have discussed tangential matters, such as grandfathering of students or verifying family addresses, he said, but they did not cover the lines on the map, which was their sole charge.

"It's innuendo. It's a perception of a violation. And that does not a violation make," Alfonso said.

He further argued that the parents were trying to subvert the rezoning process by taking a "second bite at the apple." They already lost an administrative hearing that challenged the School Board's rule making process, he noted, and though under appeal, the rule has been in effect for nearly eight months. As the new status quo, that rule cannot simply be set aside, he argued.

Related coverage: Administrative judge sides with Pasco County school district in west-side rezoning challenge

Alfonso also contended that the plaintiffs did not meet the four legal prongs required to win an injunction, including preventing irreparable harm and serving the public interest. On that front, Judge Byrd agreed.

School district officials said they were relieved to have the decision go their way. In testimony, both Teaching and Learning supervisor Tammy Rabon and Mitchell High principal Jessica Schultz said they did not have plans to regroup if the judge did issue an injunction.

Schultz testified that such a result would force her to change teacher assignments and student schedules, revamp bus routes and add a fourth lunch period, among other things. Similar activities would have needed to take place at other affected schools.

With this outcome, those actions do not have to occur. 

The plaintiffs have not decided on what next steps to take, if any. 

Comments

Pasco Letters to the Editor for April 27

Stop Ridge Road extension, reader saysWhen I spoke at the Dade City meeting of the Pasco County Commissioners on my opposition to the Ridge Road Extension, three of them responded, but only when my three minutes of free speech expired, and I could sa...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Swimmer Michael Phelps to headline Crystal Lagoon grand opening Saturday

Swimmer Michael Phelps to headline Crystal Lagoon grand opening Saturday

WESLEY CHAPEL — Olympic gold medalist Michael Phelps will splash down Saturday at the Crystal Lagoon in Wesley Chapel’s Epperson development.Phelps, a global ambassador for Crystal Lagoons, will appear at the grand opening of the first Crystal Lagoon...
Updated: 2 hours ago

Pasco Briefs for April 27

COUNTYWIDEMPO launches transportation surveyThe Pasco County Metropolitan Planning Organization has launched the "It’s TIME Pasco Survey," available at itstimepasco.metroquest.com, on the MyPasco app and at pascocountyfl.net. The survey is open throu...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Black Maria Film Festival brings 10 short films to Richey Suncoast Theatre

Black Maria Film Festival brings 10 short films to Richey Suncoast Theatre

NEW PORT RICHEY — The world-renowned Black Maria Film Festival returns to the Richey Suncoast Theatre April 27, giving the usual nod to the creator of motion pictures, Thomas Edison, as well as the diversity of 10 award-winning short films.Now in it’...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Apartments planned for shuttered stores at Pasco’s Gulf View Square mall

Apartments planned for shuttered stores at Pasco’s Gulf View Square mall

PORT RICHEY — The new owner of two shuttered department stores at Gulf View Square mall wants to demolish the former retail outlets and replace them with nearly 400 apartments.The complex, called Gables at Gulf View, would be on the west side of the ...
Updated: 3 hours ago

School news for April 27

School Calendar• May 17-20: High school graduations• May 25: Last day of school for studentsBriefs• School Safety Town Hall Meetings will be held from 6 to 8 p.m. May 2 at River Ridge Middle/High, 11646 Town Center Road, New Port Richey and 6 to 8 p....
Published: 04/23/18

Pasco Business Digest for April 27

Business DigestEventsCHAMBER RIBBON-CUTTING: The Greater Zephyrhills Chamber of Commerce will have a ribbon-cutting ceremony for Culver’s of Zephyrhills, 6386 Gall Blvd., Zephyrhills at 10 a.m. April 30. For information, call (813) 389-8621.COMMON GR...
Published: 04/23/18

Pasco Events for April 27

27 FridayIQuit Smoking Cessation: Learn strategies for quitting all forms of tobacco. Learn about Nicotine Replacement Therapy and get free NRT patches, gum and lozenges while supplies last. Reservations required. 1 to 3 p.m. Free. Zephyrhills Librar...
Published: 04/23/18

Things to Do in Pasco and Hernando counties starting April 27

FestivalsOld Time Jamboree: The Florida Fiddlers Association hosts this three-day jamboree, kicking off with a potluck dinner at 6 p.m. April 27 and continuing through April 29 at the Sertoma Youth Ranch, 85 Myers Road, south of Spring Lake, on the H...
Published: 04/23/18
Hometown Pasco for April 27

Hometown Pasco for April 27

We want your news!Hometown Pasco is devoted to everyday life in our county, whether it’s snapshots from your family reunion, recreational sporting event, news from your last club meeting or just a few lines thanking someone for a job well done. You c...
Published: 04/19/18
Updated: 04/21/18