Monday, January 22, 2018
Sports

A fan base does not grow in Brooklyn

We've watched Jackie Robinson steal home a hundred times on those old reels, and breathed all the loving poetry about the Bums of Brooklyn. It is an idyllic vision, the rainbow merger of community and sports team, an interracial Eden.

Maybe, when the Brooklyn Nets and then the New York Islanders arrived in Brooklyn, there was a sense that this could all happen again; that the borough would once more fill the stands, unite behind inspiring teams in a newfangled, asymmetric arena. Maybe Barclays Center wasn't Ebbets Field, but it surely had its charms and convenient subway access.

The trouble, though, is that the Nets and the Isles aren't the Dodgers, and that Brooklyn isn't the same Brooklyn anymore. And maybe Brooklyn was never the rabid, hand-holding Brooklyn of our literate Dodger elegists.

This is heresy, but it is also statistical fact: From 1950 to 1957, while the Dodgers earned four National League pennants, they never averaged even 17,000 fans. In 1955, their championship season, the Dodgers averaged crowds of 13,423. By comparison, the New York Yankees drew 19,352. The second-place Braves, in their third year in Milwaukee, averaged 26,050.

So there was always a great deal of mythology about the borough's sports obsession from the start, and then these new teams showed up with warts and little hope for championship banners. They also were competing for the devotion already pledged by long-term residents to the New York Rangers and particularly the New York Knicks. Spike Lee, the ultimate Brooklynite, refused to switch.

Currently, the Islanders are slumping, 16 points behind the first-place Washington Capitals. Their star, John Tavares, has lost his strut in the new place and says that home games feel like road games to players who still live on Long Island. He is on a pace to finish the season with 60 points. Last season, lifted in part by the familiarity and acoustics of Nassau Coliseum, he amassed 86 to lead the Islanders to the playoffs.

The Nets are far worse off, falling apart at the seams. Mikhail Prokhorov dumped his general manager and coach on Sunday, and that will mean very little for quite some time. The Nets don't have a point guard and they don't have draft picks. Those are important things.

What has followed from all of this is inevitable: Islanders fans, most of them strangers in a strange place, are not filling enough seats. They commute from Long Island and grump about obstructed views. Closer to the arena, the hipsters in Red Hook and the Russian immigrants in Brighton Beach are largely disconnected from all the action, basketball and hockey.

The Nets are 28th out of 30 NBA teams in attendance, averaging 14,789 fans per game with an arena at 81.7 percent capacity. When they first came to Brooklyn, escaping moribund venues in New Jersey (nobody thinks the Nets should have stayed there), the Nets averaged crowds of 17,187. The novelty has worn off, however, and the losing has taken its toll.

Meanwhile, the Isles are ranked 29th out of 30 NHL teams in attendance with a 13,035 average, but because they play in one of the league's smallest arenas, they are at 82.4 percent capacity. They averaged 15,334 fans per game last season in the rickety Coliseum, though they struggled at the gate in recent years and NHL officials desperately wanted them out of the old arena.

The troubles are not for a lack of trying on management's part. Brett Yormark, chief executive of the Nets and Barclays Center, has targeted disparate communities in the borough. He has launched promotions and community outreach programs. Pat Singer, founder and executive director of the Brighton Neighborhood Association, recently received a batch of discount tickets to distribute for the Islanders games.

"I think it's going to build," Singer said. "There's something about a hometown team."

But the Islanders have only one Russian player, Nikolay Kulemin. When the first-place Capitals, with their batch of Russian stars, came to town last week, Kebeer, a sports bar on Brighton Beach Avenue, was deserted. Nobody was there to watch Alex Ovechkin score yet another goal on the big screen. Why? That day happened to be Russian Orthodox Christmas, another reminder of just how many factors come into play when loyalties and habits are forged.

Barclays Center has had its cool moments, even with its flawed sight lines and overpriced seats. The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge came to Atlantic Avenue for a Nets game, and exchanged greetings with Jay Z and Beyoncé. That wouldn't have happened in East Rutherford, N.J. The NBA deigned to allow its dunk contest to take place in Brooklyn, even though the real All-Star Game was staged in Manhattan at Madison Square Garden.

So there is hope. If nothing else, Brooklyn is resilient, resourceful, ever-changing. As one neighborhood is gentrified, another welcomes a fresh batch of struggling settlers.

Does Brooklyn have the passion, the population and the demographics to marry a professional franchise? Did it ever? We may not know that answer until the Nets find a point guard, or Tavares beats the Rangers in the Eastern Conference finals.

Then, those mythical Brooklyn fans better show up and create a fresh narrative. Otherwise, Walter O'Malley's decision to move west may be proved right.

 
Comments

Vikes’ Shurmur to lead Giants

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. — Vikings offensive coordinator Pat Shurmur was hired as the Giants head coach Monday afternoon. The Giants announced the hiring less than 24 hours after Shurmur and the Vikings were beaten by the Eagles in the NFC title game. S...
Updated: 20 minutes ago

Updated: 1 hour ago
HomeTeam Hot Shot winners: Misha O’Neal and Tyrick Brascom

HomeTeam Hot Shot winners: Misha O’Neal and Tyrick Brascom

Misha O’Neal, Countryside The Cougars’ 69-63 overtime win against Clearwater last week had a little extra meaning to O’Neal. The guard transferred from Clearwater after last season. O’Neal led all scorers with 23 points and added nine steals. "We al...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Oh Gahd, the Patriots are back in the Super Bowl! Don’t worry, lots of new story lines for LII vs. E-A-G-L-E-S

Oh Gahd, the Patriots are back in the Super Bowl! Don’t worry, lots of new story lines for LII vs. E-A-G-L-E-S

TAMPA – Unless you are a Chowd who drives the cah wicked fah and pahks in the yahd, you probably aren't all that jacked up about the Patriots returning to Super Bowl LII against the Philadelphia Eagles in Minneapolis. Anybody but Bill Belichick...
Updated: 3 hours ago
A top-heavy lineup for district girls soccer

A top-heavy lineup for district girls soccer

Girls soccer super seven1. Newsome (18-0): The Wolves have been completely dominant this season. They have outscored opponents 114-3. Let that sink in. They are ranked 44th nationally by MaxPreps and fifth in the state in Class 5A. Sophie Shrader has...
Updated: 3 hours ago
USF sets 2-game football series with N.C. State

USF sets 2-game football series with N.C. State

USF announced Monday it has reached a home-and-home football deal with North Carolina State, the second ACC team to be added to the Bulls' future football slate in less than a week.The Bulls announced Thursday they'll play a two-for-one deal with Lou...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Lightning’s Ondrej Palat to be out six to eight weeks

Lightning’s Ondrej Palat to be out six to eight weeks

The Lightning will be without Ondrej Palat six to eight weeks. And  Tampa Bay is still ticked by how Palat got hurt.The Wild's Jared Spurgeon slashed/speared the back of the Lightning wing's right ankle on a power play Saturday."It's a huge loss...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Jordan Miner, Isaiah Bolden shine in International Bowl

Jordan Miner, Isaiah Bolden shine in International Bowl

Four months ago, Wiregrass Ranch's Jordan Miner and Wesley Chapel's Isaiah Bolden squared off against each other in a highly anticipated matchup between two of the area's most heavily recruited players in the class of 2018.This past weekend, the two ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Matt Peca, Michael Bournival hope to spark Lightning

Matt Peca, Michael Bournival hope to spark Lightning

When Matt Peca had his best training camp with the Lightning back in September, coach Jon Cooper said he learned the 5-foot-9 forward was someone the Lightning would be able to count on at some point this season.Turns out, that time is now.Peca, 27, ...
Updated: 6 hours ago
HomeTeam 25: Girls basketball rankings for Tampa Bay

HomeTeam 25: Girls basketball rankings for Tampa Bay

1. Alonso (16-1)This week: Wednesday at Jefferson, Thursday at FreedomThe buzz: Another undefeated week for the Ravens, who picked up an impressive win over Tampa Bay Tech on Tuesday. Senior Ariel Scott had 17 points and sophomore Carly Price added 1...
Updated: 7 hours ago