Make us your home page
Instagram

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Baseball's PED era complicates Hall of Fame vote

The common cause and cry among voters for baseball's Hall of Fame is how convoluted the decision-making has become.

We've all done it, accepting that the grand privilege of voting comes with the mind-numbing, line-drawing, philosophy-challenging pain of making judgment calls on issues well beyond whether the player's actual onfield career made him Hall worthy.

And just wait 'til next year.

The stain of the steroids era that merely taints this year's ballot — in evaluations of Mark McGwire, Rafael Palmeiro and, as unfairly as it appears, Jeff Bagwell — will wash over the 2013 voting and potentially alter the foundation of the Hall going forward.

Three of the game's most prolific performers, and three of the players most entangled in the performance-enhancing drugs issue — Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens and Sammy Sosa — will all make their debuts on next year's ballot. And that's in addition to other lightning-rod candidates such as Mike Piazza.

Whatever precedents were established, justifications made, consciences rested, they will be challenged as voters consider whether the Hall should or shouldn't include the home-run king, one of the absolute best pitchers, the only player with three 60-homer seasons, and perhaps the game's best-hitting catcher.

Kinda makes this year's angst seem mundane. And with former Yankees centerfielder Bernie Williams the best of a weak class of newcomers, the internal debates were pretty much the same as last year for me, and many of the 550 or so voting members of the BBWAA.

I decided that while I had voted annually for McGwire — on the premises that use wasn't banned and was widespread, and that the impact on his performance couldn't be determined — I could not vote for Palmeiro, who knew there was testing and got caught anyway, then defiantly pointed his finger in front of Congress.

And neither the don't-look-at-the-stats push for Jack Morris nor the look-closer-at-the-stats bid for Tim Raines changed my mind on them.

Whatever a voter's philosophy — some won't vote for any player even associated with steroids, others don't consider it an issue at all, most are in between — it will be challenged significantly in the next year. About the only thing that is clear is that there is no clear right or wrong answer.

That said, here are my thoughts on other candidates on this year's ballot.

Agree/Disagree? Let us know what you think by email at topkin@tampabay.com. Jeff Bagwell

Complete player with seven 100-run/100-RBI seasons, a Gold Glove, an MVP award.

Vinny Castilla

Disqualified just on those Devil Rays years when he was called Vinny Cash-stealer.

Juan Gonzalez

Career numbers impressive (.295, 434 HRs, 1,404 RBIs), but there's that character thing.

Barry Larkin

Tremendous overall player, has best chance of any candidate on ballot to be elected.

Edgar Martinez

A great hitter but not a complete player: 72 percent of his plate appearances as a DH.

Fred McGriff

493 home runs the old-fashioned way should count for something.

Jack Morris

Always a tough call but always stopped by a 3.90 ERA that would be Hall's highest.

Dale Murphy

Actually would have had a better chance if he stopped playing a few years sooner.

Brad Radke

Tampa Jesuit product did well for himself winning 148 games, but he lost 139.

Tim Raines

A very good player for a long time who had a few great years, not a HOF player.

Lee Smith

Yes, he hung around, but 478 saves (No. 1 when he quit, third-most now) can't be ignored.

Alan Trammell

Like Raines, a very good player worthy of consideration but not election.

Larry Walker

Deserves more credit than he gets but hard to ignore Coors Field effect on stats.

Bernie Williams

Key piece of good teams and had great postseasons but overall numbers are not there.

.FAST FACTS

The vote

Hall of Fame results will be announced Monday at 3 p.m. on the MLB Network, mlb.com and baseballhall.org.

Baseball's PED era complicates Hall of Fame vote 01/07/12 [Last modified: Saturday, January 7, 2012 9:59pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. NFL commissioner, players' union angrily denounce Trump comments on national anthem

    Bucs

    SOMERSET, N.J. — The National Football League and its players' union on Saturday angrily denounced President Donald Trump for suggesting that owners fire players who kneel during the national …

    President Donald Trump walks off the stage after he speaks at campaign rally in support of Sen. Luther Strange, Friday, Sept. 22, 2017, in Huntsville, Ala. [Associated Press]
  2. Matt Peca making case for Lightning spot

    Blogs

    Center Matt Peca said he didn't read too much into the fact he was the only Lightning player to appear in each of the first three exhibition games.

    But Peca, 24, loved it.

    Matt Peca won nine of 10 faceoffs Friday, a skill the Lightning badly needs.
  3. Bucs players respond to Trump comments on anthem protests

    Blogs

    President Donald Trump shared his thoughts Friday night on NFL players protesting during the national anthem, suggesting that NFL owners should "fire" players who kneel during the anthem in protest. His remarks are alreading drawing responses from many NFL players, including some Bucs.

    Bucs players Mike Evans and Jameis Winston stand with coach Dirk Koetter during the national anthem in a game played in San Diego last season.
  4. Rays morning after: Wilson Ramos showing glimpses of what's possible in 2018

    Blogs

    The real payoff for the Rays signing C Wilson Ramos last off-season will come in 2018, when he can play a full season fully recovered from right knee surgery.

    Catcher Wilson Ramos connects for a two-run single in the fifth inning against the Cubs on Sept. 20, 2017.
  5. Buccaneers-Vikings Scouting Report: Watching Kyle Rudolph, Adam Thielen and Everson Griffen

    Bucs

    No matter how much film we study, no matter how much data we parse, we just don't know how an NFL season will unfold.

    Four of tight end Kyle Rudolph's seven catches this season have come on third down, including this 15-yard touchdown in the Vikings' opener against the Saints. [Getty Images]