Wednesday, May 23, 2018
Tampa Bay Rays

A Rays deal with Matt Wieters makes sense — at the right price

PORT CHARLOTTE — There are several things we know about the Rays' interest in Matt Wieters, the former Orioles star catcher who surprisingly — check mlbtraderumors.com — yep, remains unsigned as camps open:

First, and most important, is the Rays are serious enough to have made an offer, likely for one year and certainly for millions of dollars less than what Wieters and agent Scott Boras are seeking.

Another is they believe they provide a great fit for Wieters. With the Rays, Wieters, 30, would have the chance to be the primary catcher but wouldn't be overused and have designated-hitter at-bats available; to stay in the familiar American League East (with 19 dates for potential revenge versus the O's); to sign a one-year deal for the opportunity to build value for a 2018 run at free agency in which he would have the benefit of/credit for catching a really good staff; and to play close to his Atlanta-area home, with the usual Florida tax benefits.

Also, the Rays could use him.

Wieters has his flaws, including poor pitch-framing. But his experience handling pitchers, his reputation for strong defensive skills and his ability to hit homers from both sides of the plate make him a considerable upgrade from the trio of Curt Casali, Luke Maile and Jesus Sucre the Rays will be using until/if Wilson Ramos recovers enough from offseason knee surgery to get behind the plate come July or later.

But here's the big thing neither we nor the Rays know:

How willing is Wieters to take their offer — even if creativity and incentives could push it past $10 million — and get into camp versus waiting to see if Boras can still find the tens of millions they were expecting going into free agency?

Boras is quite good at his job, and he has done this before, taking players late into the spring and then cashing in on multiyear deals that seemed unlikely, if not shocking.

He also has done a considerable amount of business, sometimes going straight to ownership, with several teams that might also be interested in Wieters, such as the Angels, Brewers and Nationals. (The O's say they're not, though some wonder.)

Wieters made $15.8 million with the Orioles last season, when he hit .243 with 17 homers and 66 RBIs, and a .711 OPS, improving after a slow start in his first full season following 2014 Tommy John elbow surgery.

Boras shared with Fox Sports' Ken Rosenthal some of the data points he is using to sell teams on Wieters, including a to-date comparison to Hall of Famer Carlton Fisk.

More skeptical types have pointed out Wieters' statistics are better compared to the much more pedestrian Jason Castro, though Castro's $27.5 million, three-year deal with the Twins must look pretty good to Wieters right now.

The Rays are not going to offer Wieters the most money, certainly not more than the team-record $14 million they paid David Price in 2014, or the $13 million Evan Longoria will make this season, or likely not even the $10 million Carl Crawford got in 2010. Wieters isn't that, and he won't make that much difference.

The Rays hope that Wieters is getting antsy sitting at home, that he's willing to bet on himself to have a good year and cash in (think Ian Desmond in 2016), that he will see the value in what they have to offer rather than the money they are willing to pay him.

If so, they'll get Wieters' relatively big bat to boost a lineup missing Logan Forsythe, plus the benefit of his experience behind the plate, and his leadership and motivation. If they're in the playoff race, they can keep Wieters for the full year and eventually have him share time at catcher and DH with Ramos. If they're not, they can trade Wieters and recoup some of their investment.

For the Rays, there are lots of reasons a deal with Wieters makes sense. Just as long as it doesn't cost too many dollars.

Marc Topkin can be reached at [email protected] Follow @ TBTimes_Rays.

Comments
Rays put Jake Faria on DL, call up Vidal Nuno

Rays put Jake Faria on DL, call up Vidal Nuno

The Rays, as expected, are placing RHP Jake Faria on the 10-day DL with a left oblique strain that he sustained during Tuesday's game.Somewhat unexpectedly, they are calling up LHP Vidal Nuno to take his place.Nuno, 30, has pitched parts of five seas...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays morning after: Faria frustrated after latest letdown

Rays morning after: Faria frustrated after latest letdown

Whatever pain RHP Jake Faria was feeling as a result of the oblique muscle on the left side he strained throwing a fourth-inning slider to Boston's Hanley Ramirez couldn't compare to the hurt in his heart.Forced to leave Tuesday's game and likely hea...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Willy Adames homers, but Rays fall to Red Sox and suffer injuries

Willy Adames homers, but Rays fall to Red Sox and suffer injuries

ST. PETERSBURG — Top prospect Willy Adames is only going to get to stay with the Rays for a few days, so good for him for making the most of it with a home run in his first big-league game, and off Red Sox ace Chris Sale no less.But the good fe...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Rays loss to Red Sox

Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Rays loss to Red Sox

Marc Topkin's takeaways from Rays 4-2 loss to Red Sox on Tuesday:* The Rays record against a Red Sox team they consider a measuring stick doesn't look very good at 3-8. But, as manager Kevin Cash and several players pointed out, there is some consola...
Published: 05/22/18
Rays journal: Critics don’t faze Sergio Romo or team

Rays journal: Critics don’t faze Sergio Romo or team

ST. PETERSBURG — Criticisms of the Rays' latest innovative pitching strategy have piled up since Angels INF Zack Cosart said after Sunday's game that starting RHP Sergio Romo to get the first three-six outs was "bad for baseball.''One of the lo...
Published: 05/22/18
For starters: Rays vs. Red Sox, with Faria on the mound

For starters: Rays vs. Red Sox, with Faria on the mound

UPDATE, 6:04: Cash said the Rays don't know yet if Wendle will be  back Thursday or Friday, though with the Sox starting RHP Rick Porcello on Thursday that would make sense. …  Cash said OF Carlos Gomez (groin strain) will run the bas...
Published: 05/22/18
Rays call up top prospect Willy Adames – but only for a couple days

Rays call up top prospect Willy Adames – but only for a couple days

The Rays have called up top prospect INF Willy Adames – though likely for a short stay.INF Joey Wendle was placed on the paternity list Tuesday, which allows him to miss up to three days.Manager Kevin Cash said Adames is headed back to Triple-A...
Published: 05/22/18
Rays journal: Christian Arroyo set to play first game at Tropicana Field

Rays journal: Christian Arroyo set to play first game at Tropicana Field

ST. PETERSBURG  — Christian Arroyo has watched more than 50 Rays games at Tropicana Field from the stands. Has been on the turf for his younger sister's gymnastics competitions and once, while it was in football configuration, to take grou...
Published: 05/21/18
There’s a swing by Rays CF Kevin Kiermaier …. and a gender reveal for November baby

There’s a swing by Rays CF Kevin Kiermaier …. and a gender reveal for November baby

Tampa Bay Rays OF Kevin Kiermaier and his wife Marisa are having a boy.Kiermaier shared the news on Twitter over the weekend in a most appropriate themed gender reveal event — taking a swing at ball that exploded with blue powder.Looks like im ...
Published: 05/21/18
What’s next for the Rays’ new pitching strategy

What’s next for the Rays’ new pitching strategy

ST. PETERSBURG — When Kevin Cash called team president Matt Silverman Sunday morning to wish him happy birthday, he expected to get back some form of an "attaboy" for implementing the Rays' latest unorthodox pitching strategy in using reliever ...
Published: 05/21/18