Today's paper | eEdition | Subscribe
The Truth-O-Meter
Latest print edition
St. Petersburg Times
Special report
Video report
Multimedia report
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Your name Your email
Recipient email
You may enter up to 20 multiple email addresses, separated by commas.
Your message
Validation Code
Hear
validation
code
  Enter validation code

Young Rays have passed Yankees in standings and in talent

By Gary Shelton, Times Sports Columnist
In print: Sunday, May 18, 2008


Social Bookmarking
Digg Facebook Stumbleupon
Reddit Del.icio.us Newsvine
ADVERTISEMENT

Having spent a little time being both, I feel qualified to say this: Being young is better than being old.

Generally speaking, running is preferable to standing still, energy is better than entitlement and today is better than yesterday. Ripening is better than rotting, playing hard is better than punching a clock and, evidently, running over a catcher is better than running around him.

Also, it should be mentioned, the Rays are better than the Yankees.

We are not simply talking about the standings here. We are talking about the rosters. We are talking about reality. We are talking about Hank Steinbrenner having a rough, rough morning.

It was sometime during last week's games, when the Rays took three out of four from New York, that the notion arose. It began as a small idea, flitting around the eyes like a mosquito, then it grew into this question:

Brand names aside, would you trade the 25-man roster of the Rays for the 25-man roster of the Yankees?

Think of the audacity of the question. Throughout the entire history of history, such a question would have deserved only two answers: One: pointing. Two: laughing. That a person would even think seriously before answering says a great deal about the direction of both franchises.

At this point, the Rays are better.

Now, I don't mean they are a better bargain than the Yankees, although that is certainly true. I don't mean they happen to be ahead in the standings for the time being.

I mean they are better. Younger. Faster. Hungrier. They play the game so much harder that even Steinbrenner-the-sequel, the same guy who recently acted as if the Rays were kids who didn't appreciate their allowance, couldn't keep quiet about the embarrassment. You get the feeling Hanky the Yankee is ready to bowl over a Yankees catcher himself.

In other words, yeah, these Rays ought to finish ahead of these Yankees.

I know, I know. Any moment now, Yankee fans will hit you with their history books. And it is true: The Yankees have a glorious past. On the other hand, so did Constantinople.

At this point, however, watching the Yankees is kind of like watching the Rolling Stones. It's nice to see they can still strut around because everyone loves the oldies, but down deep, you find yourself hoping that no one breaks a hip.

Let's be honest: The emperor is wearing Perry Como's clothes. There were times last week you wondered if the Yankees wouldn't have shown more life if they strapped gloves on a few ATMs and placed them strategically about the field.

This is what you get for $207-million? Man, is this a rough economy or what? Never has yesterday's news come at such prices.

I don't know about you, but I can't wait for Steinbrenner to get loud. Eventually, he's going to have to wonder if this roster was assembled in a darkroom. Eventually, he's going to have to look at his payroll and ask for change. Also, his roster.

Eventually, he's going to have to walk into his front office and ask: So, how do these teams stack up?

This is what he is likely to hear.


PositionEdge
First base

Both Jason Giambi and Carlos Pena are off to dreadful starts. Giambi has more of a track record, but at 37, he's on the downhill slide. Put it this way: Which one would you wager will be employed by his team next year?

RAYS
Second base

The Rays' Aki Iwamura has made a seamless transition to second base, and he's starting to hit. Still, the edge has to go to Robinson Cano despite his slow start.

YANKEES
Shortstop

The Rays are delighted with Jason

Bartlett's range, but let's face it.

Bartlett has a lot of

proving to do before

he can be compared

with Derek Jeter.

YANKEES
Third base

Evan Longoria is

going to be a star.

Alex Rodriguez, who

should return this

week, already is one.

YANKEES
Catcher

Jorge Posada has caught only nine games all year, and by next year, he may be the Yankees' first baseman. Meanwhile, no one is grumbling about Dioner Navarro anymore.

RAYS
Leftfield

No question. Any general manager

in baseball would take Carl

Crawford over a 35-year-old

Johnny Damon.

RAYS
Centerfield

Not much question here,

either. Give me B.J. Upton

over Melky Cabrera.

RAYS
Rightfield

And isn't it nice to compare a Rays player other than Kevin Stocker to Bobby Abreu?

YANKEES
Designated hitter

Hideki Matsui's knees are healthier than Cliff Floyd's.

YANKEES
Starting pitching

Andy Pettitte is older than dirt. Mike Mussina is older than water. And the Rays are pretty darned good. Any questions?

RAYS
Setup and closer

Dan Wheeler and Troy Percival have been superb for the Rays. But the Yankees are pretty good, too, with Joba Chamberlain and Mariano Rivera.

YANKEES
Middle relief

The Yankees don't have a left-hander. They also don't have J.P. Howell.

RAYS
Intangibles

The Rays play better defense. They have more speed on the basepaths. They are more athletic. On the other hand, the Yankees can take heart. Next year, they should have a higher draft choice.

RAYS


[Last modified: May 19, 2008 04:16 PM]



Comments on this article
by Jimbo May 19, 2008 4:16 PM
Goes to show you that money can't buy championships, after all...at least not in the 21st Century. The Yanks, after all, haven't won this century, and unlike the Bosox, this team won't take 86 years to won a ring.
by Hank May 19, 2008 2:55 PM
Save this for September so you can write your follow-up where you apologize for being so dense.
by RayF May 19, 2008 1:43 PM
To the people that claim the Yanks and sox didn't have their big boys; the Rays had as many as 11 men on the DL at the beginning of the year. This team is better. to Ray-You forgot Bartlett, Garza, Floyd, Hinske, and Wheeler came late. go back to NY
by Wayne May 19, 2008 1:43 PM
And I'd take the Rays' manager, GM, president and principal owner over the Yankees' any day.
by kyle May 19, 2008 1:43 PM
to Ray: same lineup except Longoria? Guess you weren't watching. The Rays are better than the Yanks, and it will be that way for the next 8-10 years....get used to it!!!
by Carol May 19, 2008 1:31 PM
This is Carol, a big fan of the Rays, NOT snotty Carol from 5/18 at 1:46pm. The Rays have played solid baseball, with so much heart. I am proud of this team and impressed with their determination, guts, and skill. Jump in a lake snotty Carol-GO RAYS
by RayF May 19, 2008 1:31 PM
... and Percival, and Dukes is gone who was a big distraction. Typical Yanks fan- blind to the facts. Hey, I once threw 4 touchdowns in 1 game for Polk High. Stop liveing on past accolades Al Bundy.
by Tony May 19, 2008 10:33 AM
Let's see. I believe Matsui has made an error or two regarding how many outs in a game once. You want the past? How many Rays players have gotten into a fist fight with their manager in the dugout...aka, Reggie Jackson/Billy Martin!
by Bradley May 19, 2008 10:33 AM
Bravo Mr Shelton.I throughly enjoyed this assessment.
by sam May 19, 2008 10:33 AM
what mark said== """ the Rays' present, and possibly future, is better than the Yankees'."""
by Kathleen May 19, 2008 10:33 AM
Yes, the Rays. But no gloating. Just a big thank you that it's the season for the Rays. AT LAST!!!!!
by Ed May 19, 2008 10:33 AM
Get all the good young players locked up with long term contracts! That way the Yanks & Sox won't be able to raid the Rays roster. Force them to {GASP!} develop talent for the core of their future rosters instead of "checkbook" drafting.
by Andy May 19, 2008 10:33 AM
I live and die with the Yankees but I am afraid you are right. The Yankees will have to admit this before they can make the changes they need to get back on top.
by George Costanza May 19, 2008 10:32 AM
Come on Jerry, I mean Gary! The Yanks big sticks were out of the lineup last week. The Sox were missing their stars too when the Rays swept. Lets talk in Sept. Yes Yanks are old they reload every year with unlimited payroll.
by ben bolt fan May 19, 2008 10:32 AM
This is the same homer who writes about the bucs when it is good. Write this article in September and tell me the Rays are then.
by Ray May 19, 2008 10:32 AM
The Rays won 66 games last year with the same lineup minus Longoria and suddenly they have a better lineup than the Yankees. Ok let's check the back in late August
by Dennis May 19, 2008 9:41 AM
Carol, you are the reason why I hate the yankees and red sox, their fans are insufferably arrogant even when their team sucks.
by Dennis May 18, 2008 1:50 PM
Yankees fans always run home to the past whenever they have no argument left, so, right now, that is where they will start. I just wish I did not work with people from here who are Yankee fans, watch the Rays, you will like what you see.
by Brad May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
agreed agreed and agreed watch out for these rays
by Pete May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
Let's get serious. I hate the Yanks but A-Rod counts for a lot. I think it too early to give the rays the edge at catcher. The Yankees are better at middle relief as well. The rays have the advantage at starting pitcher and Upton and Crawford.
by BILL May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
AGREE WITH MARK. WHO HAS A GREATER HISTORY THAN NY? BUT THE YANKS ARE ON THE WAY DOWN, EVEN JETER IS SHOWING THE SIGNS. THERE'S NOT THAT MUCH OUT THERE NOW OR IN THE FUTURE FOR THE YANKS TO SIGN. THE RAYS ARE DEFINITELY ON THE WAY UP! SIGNS OF
by Ron Burgandy May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
Any Yankees fan who resorts to telling people how many rings they have is an idiot
by Carol May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
Oh yeah, a real dynasty brewing... What a laugh.
by Carol May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
The Rays will soon crumble. Yesterday, for the first time, I decided I was going to watch them - finally. I have tried in the past, but gave up. So what happens - their guy (Gross?) can't even remember how many outs there are!! Good grief - losers..
by steve May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
To those who believe that a team with a payroll as small as the Rays could never compete with the big boys like the Yankees and Red Sox, take a gander at the standings.
by stu May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
The youth on the Rays can and will make mistakes. Isn't it wonderful to watch them grow and start beating up on the "Old Guys"!Playing excited is for the young. Watching and getting excited is for us older guys. GO RAYS!!!!!!
by Travis May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
Shelton is the best sports writer in the nation. His unique character can put the most undeserving story a flare worth reading. The Rays are tremendous and they'er very much like our team here the Twins. Go Rays...Poor Yanks.
by Sam May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
The only disagreement I had was (1) I would've picked Aki over Cano and (2) I would not have even mentioned Bartlett with Jeter in the same text space.
by joaquin May 18, 2008 1:46 PM
the yankees, with its huge payroll, are fast becoming residents of jokesville. i watched the recent four-game series, the rays had a chance to score a shutout. next time around, it won't be surprised it will be a complete shutout. pathetic yankees...
by Mark May 18, 2008 1:19 AM
Exactly. The Yankees' history is better than the Rays'. However, the Rays' present, and possibly future, is better than the Yankees'.
Subscribe to the Times
Click here for daily delivery
of the St. Petersburg Times.

Email Newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

 
ADVERTISEMENT