Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Derek Jeter's dramatics in faking being hit by pitch were over the line

Shortstop Derek Jeter, left, being examined by the team trainer and manager Joe Girardi, was awarded first base though a Chad Qualls pitch clearly hit just the knob of his bat.

Getty Images

Shortstop Derek Jeter, left, being examined by the team trainer and manager Joe Girardi, was awarded first base though a Chad Qualls pitch clearly hit just the knob of his bat.

With a lesser player, perhaps this would seem like a lesser transgression.

If Derek Jeter was just another guy playing just another game, just another guy in a dirty uniform scrapping away, perhaps this would seem like nothing at all. It would be a case of boys being boys. It would be someone trying to find a edge. It would be, well, baseball.

Ah, but this is Jeter the elegant, Jeter the dignified, Jeter the regal. Jeter has spent his entire career above the mess and beyond reproach. He has been the most admired man in his sport, carrying himself with a uncommon class that even the fans of his rivals could not help but admire. It is permissible to detest the Yankees, but who has ever had a bad word to say about Jeter?

Until now.

Until you keep seeing replays of Jeter performing scenes from Death of a Salesman in the seventh inning of Wednesday night's game against the Rays.

By now, you have seen the video of Chad Qualls' pitch hitting the knob of Jeter's bat as he spun around. It was like hitting the bottom of a pool cue. And suddenly, Jeter was in absolute agony. It was like he was one of those Western outlaws who had just had the gun shot from his hand by Wyatt Earp. There hasn't been this much torment to a guy's hand since Darth Vader sliced off Luke Skywalker's in the Empire Strikes Back.

And the umpires bought it. All of it. Why, this is Jeter. It would be beneath a guy of Jeter's golden reputation to fake such a play, wouldn't it? Never mind the crack of the bat. Never mind the ball shooting toward the infield as it never would have if it had hit skin.

Alex Rodriguez? Why, sure, A-Rod might fake it. Heck, he has faked a lot of his career, hasn't he? You don't have to squint to picture him trying to fool the umpires.

He once yelled at an infielder trying to catch a popup. He once pawed at the glove of a player trying to tag him.

Dustin Pedroia? Yeah, you could believe this of Pedroia, who I admire greatly for his grit and his spunk. If someone was going to do anything to win, you could believe it of Pedroia. For that matter, you could believe it of most players.

But Jeter?


Just to make things clear, I have no problem with Jeter taking first base. If he had dropped his bat and jogged to first, well, that's his job. He's not there to help the umpire avoid looking foolish. I don't expect infielders to admit if they miss a tag, and I don't expect baserunners to say they were really out, and I don't expect batters to say, "Yeah, I went too far on that check swing.'' In that world, you don't need umpires. Or, for that matter, Oscars. So, no, I wouldn't expect Jeter to admit the ball didn't hit him.

What bothers me are the dramatics that Jeter went to, the over-the-top, ham-it-up, play-pretend con job that helped convince the umpires the good captain had been plunked. On the border of gamesmanship and sportsmanship, that was the part that crossed the line.

Yes, there is such a line. For all you might say about "winning at all costs,'' most baseball players know there is such a thing as going too far. Remember when A-Rod pawed at the glove of a player who was trying to tag him out? Remember when he yelled at another who was trying to catch a pop fly? Remember when he dared to run across the pitcher's mound during a game?

In each of those incidents, most fans simply rolled their eyes at another of A-Rod's transgressions. And if it had been A-Rod who had done a Nancy Kerrigan imitation Wednesday night instead of Jeter, ESPN would have blown up from trying to wedge 65 minutes worth of replays into an hour.

So doesn't Jeter deserve the same scorn? Or, given the moral high ground of his career, a little more?

Mostly, this was disappointing because most of us think so much of Jeter. If there was one player in the game you might have thought was above role-play, it was Jeter. If there was one player who you suspected stood for something more, it is this generation's Joe DiMaggio.

Today, Jeter has lost something, and baseball has lost something, and the rest of us have lost something, too.

Here's another question: Do you think that perhaps, just perhaps, Jeter's reputation is one reason the umpires were so willing to believe him? Do you think that if it were another player, say the Rays' B.J. Upton, that the umps wouldn't have looked at Jeter's hand the way other umps once looked at Cleon Jones' shoes?

If you are looking for goats, of course, you can add the umpires to this one. Think of it like this: None of the four umpires saw the ball hit Jeter — we know this because the ball never hit Jeter — and still, Jeter was awarded first base (later, he would score the tying run) and, possibly, a Purple Heart.

Here we go again, a big call in a big game leading us one step closer to instant replay. Remember all the blown calls from last postseason? Remember the case of the disappearing perfect game?

At this point, baseball needs to take replay seriously. Let's face it: Everyone at home has replay. They know when a call is butchered. So why withhold it from the people (the umpires) who need it most? For crying out loud, this is baseball. Most of the close plays happen at four distinct pieces of geography.

Do that, and maybe the umpires wouldn't need Jeter's help.

At its very nature, baseball is a game of deception, of phantom tags and stolen signs, of hidden ball tricks and trapped fly balls, of scuffed balls and corked bats. It isn't golf. It isn't tennis. It's a shame, but sometimes can be too costly. On the other hand, bad acting can never be forgiven. Ask Keanu Reeves.

So how bad was this? Oh, it wasn't as bad as taking steroids. It wasn't as bad as fixing the World Series. On the other hand, it was worse than a phantom tag or blocking a bag without the ball. If I had to guess, I'd rate it somewhere even with the World Series game where Minnesota's Kent Hrbek pulled the Braves' Ron Gant off the bag.

Frankly, it was beneath Derek Jeter, who seems somewhat less pristine today than he was before.

Shame, Derek. You're better than that.

Derek Jeter's dramatics in faking being hit by pitch were over the line 09/16/10 [Last modified: Friday, September 17, 2010 6:58am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Rays' Blake Snell erasing memories of his poor start

    The Heater

    NEW YORK — As Blake Snell strides up the mound at Yankee Stadium Tuesday night with an 10-game unbeaten streak, doesn't the miserable start to his sophomore season, when he was winless in eight starts and got demoted to Triple-A, seem like a long time ago?

    To him, too.

    Tampa Bay Rays starting pitcher Blake Snell (4) in the dugout during the fourth inning of the game between the Chicago Cubs and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2017. WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times

  2. Jake Dotchin on rule violation: 'It's hurting me'


    While defenseman Jake Dotchin continues to practice with the Lightning, it's uncertain when - or if - he'll get any preseason action.

    Jake Dotchin violated an unspecified team rule, which is why he hasn't played in the first four games.
  3. PolitiFact: Trump's Mostly False claim that NFL ratings are 'way down'


    The statement

    "NFL attendance and ratings are WAY DOWN. Boring games yes, but many stay away because they love our country."

    Quarterback Jameis Winston is sacked during the first half of the Bucs' 34-17 loss to the Vikings on Sunday. (LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times)
  4. Bucs couldn't connect on or stop deep passes in loss to Vikings


    If two things were established as storylines entering Sunday's Bucs-Vikings game, it was that Tampa Bay was still struggling to establish the deep passes that were missing from its offense last year, and that …

    Minnesota Vikings wide receiver Stefon Diggs (14) gets into the end zone for a long touchdown reception as Bucs free safety Chris Conte (23) cannot stop him during the second half. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  5. Nine Gators, including Antonio Callaway and Jordan Scarlett, face felony fraud accusations


    Nine Florida Gators face at least 62 potential felony charges on accusations of credit card fraud. 

    Star receiver Antonio Callaway is among at least four Florida Gators who face potential felony charges on accusations of fraud.