Thursday, April 19, 2018
Tampa Bay Rays

Jones: If Curt Schilling was a liberal, he might be in Hall of Fame

Curt Schilling is a blowhard.

He's a fraud. He's self-centered. He is hateful. He's a bully.

Know what else he is? A Hall of Famer.

Know what he's never going to be? A Hall of Famer.

That's too bad.

When the Baseball Hall of Fame voting totals came out Wednesday, the retired pitcher picked up 45 percent of the votes from members of the Baseball Writers' Association of America, well short of the 75 percent needed to get into the Hall. More interesting, his total dropped from the 52 percent he received last year.

What happened over the past year? Nothing on the field, obviously.

Plenty off it.

Schilling called journalists an unflattering name we can't print. He retweeted a photo of a T-shirt that suggested journalists be lynched. He compared Muslims to Nazis.

He said Hillary Clinton should be "buried under a jail.'' He has lashed out against trans­gender people. He lost his job as an ESPN analyst because he couldn't keep his mouth shut when specifically told to keep his mouth shut.

That's just a portion of what he has said and done.

There's a phrase when it comes to the controversial former player: Curt Schilling pitched his way into the Hall of Fame, but now he is talking his way out of it.

To be clear, some believe he didn't even pitch his way into the Hall, that the right-hander's numbers aren't Hall worthy. His total wins (216) and ERA (3.46) don't compare favorably with those of pitchers in the Hall. He never won a Cy Young Award. He went to six All-Star Games, which really isn't that many for a Hall of Famer.

But if his regular-season numbers are borderline, his postseason numbers should be enough to lift him over the top. He won 11 postseason games and had a 2.23 ERA while winning three World Series. Pitching his guts out in a must-win playoff game with blood from painful ankle surgery seeping through his sock is the epitome of a big-game pitcher. His "Bloody Sock'' victory in the 2004 American League Championship Series for Boston is one of the gutsiest performances in baseball history.

Feels like a Hall of Famer to me.

However, fewer people think Schilling is a Hall of Famer today than thought so a year ago, and it seems as if Schilling's political views are a big reason why.

Boston Globe columnist Dan Shaughnessy, who covered Schilling with the Red Sox, voted for Schilling in the past but recently wrote, "Count me out on Curt Schilling. … I shall invoke the 'character' clause this year. Schill has transitioned from a mere nuisance to an actual menace to society. His tweet supporting the lynching of journalists was the last straw for this voter.''

There's a difference between one's politics and one's character. Some writers find that Schilling's character, and not his political slant, is a reason to keep him out of the Hall, or at the least, to let him sweat a little before getting their vote. That's fair.

But you also can't help but believe that Schilling's comments are more scrutinized because he is a conservative. If he supported Clinton instead of Donald Trump in last year's election, would he receive the same backlash? The guess is no.

When asked Thursday on the Dan Patrick Show why his vote total went down, Schilling said, "We all know why. Because I'm not quiet. If I didn't talk, I might have gotten in this time.''

His vote total wouldn't have dropped, that's for sure.

"I believe it's politics, in one sense,'' Schilling, 50, said, "but I think it's the retweeting of the T-shirt that gave them an out, so to speak.''

Schilling has repeatedly said he was kidding about lynching journalists, that he simply thought the shirt was funny and sarcastic, and should never have been taken seriously.

"You know how sick and tired I am of trying to explain to people what I was doing?'' Schilling said.

This is Schilling's problem: Every time he opens his mouth, he gives us five more reasons not to like him. If you have to constantly explain what you were trying to say, then maybe it's you and not everyone else.

Patrick asked Schilling if he could just cool it with the trolling tweets and outrageous comments.

"If that's sacrificing the Hall of Fame, I don't want to be in anyway,'' Schilling said. "If that ends up costing me votes, so what?''

Don't believe that for a second. Of course Schilling cares about the Hall of Fame, and that's what makes him a fraud.

Schilling admitted on Patrick's show that he likes "embarrassing'' people on Twitter, that he likes getting people riled up with his comments. If you're going to continue to do that and say you don't care if you get into the Hall, you can't then play the victim when you don't get in.

Schilling is a spoiled brat who enjoys all the attention he gets with his commentary, which can be hateful, divisive and ugly. But as much as his comments disgust me, I defend his right to say such things, and they shouldn't keep him out of the Hall.

As far as we know, he didn't do steroids. He didn't bet on baseball. He didn't fix games.

I don't want to have a beer with the guy. In fact, I wish he would just go away.

But I have no problem with putting him in a museum of the best baseball players. After all, he deserves it.

     
 
Comments
The Mallex Smith effect can take effect for Rays

The Mallex Smith effect can take effect for Rays

ST. PETERSBURG — Mallex Smith has style.Effervescent personality. Pop culture hipness. Sense of fashion with accoutrements.Now the Rays are going to find out if he has game.More specifically, enough game to be a front-line outfielder, even an i...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Rays journal: Whew. Alex Colome gets the job done

Rays journal: Whew. Alex Colome gets the job done

ST. PETERSBURG — In the end, Alex Colome got the three outs to save the game, the day and the stomach linings of his bosses from further deterioration, so in theory that should be what mattered most Wednesday.And the fact that he was smiling in...
Published: 04/18/18
Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Rays’ 4-2 Wednesday win

Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Rays’ 4-2 Wednesday win

Alex Colome's ninth-inning dramatics took the focus, but the work of newly corn-rowed RHP Chaz Roe in the seventh (three Ks) and LHP Jose Alvarado (one K, two infield outs) was textbook, and showed how the bullpen can work.RELATED: Whew. Alex Colome ...
Published: 04/18/18
Anonymous Rays rally to beat Rangers 4-2, win series

Anonymous Rays rally to beat Rangers 4-2, win series

ST. PETERSBURG — Even before they lost several of the hitters they were relying most on to injuries, the Rays did not exactly have a lineup built on intimidation.Their own owner said opening day that he expected them to rank among the least pro...
Published: 04/18/18
Rays Baldelli makes a key catch

Rays Baldelli makes a key catch

Rays coach Rocco Baldelli was all smiles Wednesday morning, happy to play a role through social media in reuniting a lost dog and its owner."I feel really good about how this worked out," Baldelli said.REUNITED! Thank you everyone for spreading the w...
Published: 04/18/18
For starters: Rays vs. Rangers, with Faria on the hill

For starters: Rays vs. Rangers, with Faria on the hill

UPDATE, 12:01: Cash said Brad Miller (groin) got through his rehab game with the Stone Crabs well last night playing first and will play second tonight, with the likely plan to be off Thursday and rejoin the Rays Friday. … With 3B Matt Duffy on...
Published: 04/18/18
Rays, Chirinos fall to Rangers, 7-2

Rays, Chirinos fall to Rangers, 7-2

ST. PETERSBURG — For three outings, rookie Yonny Chirinos had been stellar in making a case to join the Rays' starting rotation, not allowing a single run in the first 141/3 innings of his major-league career.That perfection came to an inevitab...
Published: 04/17/18
Updated: 04/18/18
Rays journal: Rays play it safe, put Matt Duffy on DL with hamstring injury

Rays journal: Rays play it safe, put Matt Duffy on DL with hamstring injury

ST. PETERSBURG — Matt Duffy is back on the disabled list.The Rays third baseman, who missed all of last season with an Achilles tendon injury, was placed on the 10-day disabled list Tuesday after leaving Monday's game in the first inning with t...
Published: 04/17/18
Rays takeaways: Just one bad outing, a rangey outfield, a sharp ex-Ray

Rays takeaways: Just one bad outing, a rangey outfield, a sharp ex-Ray

Yonny Chirinos may still be an answer as the Rays look to fill out their rotation. He probably stayed in a little too long Tuesday, trailing 2-1 entering the fifth but giving up four runs the rest of the way. Bad starts caught up to him in the first,...
Published: 04/17/18
Rays-Rangers lineup: Matt Duffy to DL, Brandon Snyder up

Rays-Rangers lineup: Matt Duffy to DL, Brandon Snyder up

Greetings from Tropicana Field, where another day brings another round of injury-related transactions for the Rays.Third baseman Matt Duffy, who left Monday's game with tightness in his right hamstring, has been placed on the 10-day disabled list, ta...
Published: 04/17/18