Thursday, August 16, 2018
Tampa Bay Rays

Rays trade Matt Moore, Brandon Guyer, Steve Pearce

ST. PETERSBURG

More than any of the names that were pitched, proposed or potentially pawned off, more than other deals featuring a passel of prospects or a catcher with promise, Matt Duffy was what made Monday's big deal worth doing for the Rays.

On what was an unusually busy deadline day by their standards, the Rays shipped Steve Pearce, who was of little value this season once they plummeted out of contention, to the Orioles; and they sent Brandon Guyer, who looked to be of little value (and about $2.5 million in salary) next season, to the Indians.

But the headline and, potentially, head-scratching move was trading Matt Moore, their one-time future ace, to the Giants for Duffy and two Class A prospects.

The premise is Duffy, 25, will become the Rays' frontline shortstop, bringing a better glove and broader range than they've gotten from Brad Miller, who will take his potent bat and now get time at first base and in the outfield.

One catch is that for the 2½ seasons he has been in the majors, Duffy has played primarily third base, albeit rather well. Now he will be asked to shift back to his original position, the Rays confident he has the requisite fast feet and soft hands and can "relearn" — as Duffy said — the position, giving them a solid answer to a major 2017 question.

Another is that he is currently on the disabled list, about a week from returning from a left Achilles strain sustained during a June series at the Trop, which makes him all kinds of a perfect fit for this battered bunch.

"We think he can be a very good shortstop for us," Rays baseball operations president Matt Silverman said, his voice hoarse from a long night and day on the phone. "He's a good young player to add to the mix and be part of our core going forward. And he was a big part of the motivation in the trade for Matt Moore."

Though Silverman would never share details, the Rays had other options Monday, given what he acknowledged was "overwhelming" and "incredible" interest in their pitchers overall.

They could have traded Moore for a different package. They could have dealt a different starter, Chris Archer or Jake Odorizzi or even Drew Smyly. Or they could have done nothing and waited until the winter, when the free agent market will be fallow and the trading options broader as they could engage with all teams and not just contenders.

But at some point, the Rays were going to do something. That's how they operate.

They had more than enough starting pitchers for next season, especially with the expected return of Alex Cobb. Silverman acknowledged as much, that "it's been our business plan in a way to trade from depth to address other areas of need." (And they still may well trade Archer or another starter in the offseason.)

Moore, 27, seemed all along like the most likely to go now. Sure, he had been their best pitcher for the past six weeks and was looking more like the front-end starter from before his April 2014 Tommy John elbow surgery. But there would always be that injury risk, plus an escalating salary, as he was due either a $7 million salary or $2.5 million buyout for 2017, with options of $9 million and $10 million after that.

Moore had made it clear he wanted to stay with the only organization he knew, and he admitted Monday when the 4 p.m. deadline passed that he thought he was clear, only to get the word minutes later. "Right now," he said outside the Rays clubhouse, "there's a lot of different feelings floating around." Ex-mates felt the same, Archer saying it was a tough, emotional goodbye.

Duffy told the San Francisco Chronicle he had similarly mixed emotions, that it was "going to hurt for a while" leaving the Giants, but he was "really excited" to join the Rays, with the added benefit to play alongside Evan Longoria, whom he met at a Long Beach State baseball camp and has followed ever since. (Also, for what it's worth, he has a 35-pound cat named Skeeter.)

Pearce was hardly surprised at being traded given that he was on a one-year, $4.75 million deal and appealed to several contenders, dealt for defense-oriented Class A catching prospect Jonah Heim after no bigger deal arose.

As much as Pearce wanted to stay, he said rejoining the Orioles, for whom he played from 2012-15, "is going to make the transition a lot easier. Couldn't be happier where I'm going."

Guyer, conversely, was totally shocked at being dealt — "No idea at all," he said. "It's bittersweet" — as he headed to join an Indians team that had long eyed him based on his success vs. lefties and ability to get on base, including his record hit by pitch numbers. With Mikie Mahtook in line to take Guyer's spot next season, the Rays got an early start on a winter move by dealing him now, for two minor-leaguers.

Overall, the trades saved the Rays around $4.5 million this year and at least as much next year based on Guyer's salary and Moore's buyout. Seeing Moore pitch in the playoffs (against Joe Maddon's Cubs?) while the Rays are sitting home could sting, but it shouldn't. And obviously there is the potential for one or two of the acquired prospects — such as the intriguing Lucius Fox from the Giants — to develop into something special.

But this deal, on this day, will be judged on Silverman and Co., whose initial trades haven't worked out that well yet, being right on Duffy.

"If you look at the club today going forward, projecting into next year, we should be a more talented club," Silverman said. "We expect to compete again. Recharge, get refocused and go back after it next year."

Marc Topkin can be reached at [email protected].

     
     
Comments
Rays lefty Adam Kolarek picked a good time for his first career save

Rays lefty Adam Kolarek picked a good time for his first career save

NEW YORK — There was a lot that went into the Rays hanging on to their 3-1, series-clinching win over the Yankees Thursday.Including the conversation  reliever Adam Kolarek had with himself jogging in from the bullpen with the bases loaded...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Rays-Yankees: Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Tampa Bay’s 3-1 victory

Rays-Yankees: Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Tampa Bay’s 3-1 victory

NEW YORK — Here's Marc Topkin's takeaways from the Rays' 3-1 victory over the Yankees Thursday:* Give mild-mannered 29-year-old rookie Adam Kolarek credit for handling the pressure of a bases loaded no-outs in the ninth situation and closing ou...
Updated: 1 hour ago
The Rays finally won a series in Yankee Stadium. Now for some perspective.

The Rays finally won a series in Yankee Stadium. Now for some perspective.

NEW YORK — After the Rays exhaled following Thursday's tense-as-they come 3-1 win, they were able to appreciate the significance of what they'd done.For now.And, more importantly, for the future.Really, it shouldn't be that hard. They make thre...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Rays hang on for 3-1 victory, win first series at Yankee Stadium since 2014

Rays hang on for 3-1 victory, win first series at Yankee Stadium since 2014

NEW YORK – Once they got done exhaling, the Rays had reason to celebrate Thursday.In hanging on for a 3-1 win and taking two of the three games, they won their first series at Yankee Stadium since the middle of the 2014 season.Twelve times sinc...
Updated: 4 hours ago
For starters: Rays at Yankees, looking for a rare series win

For starters: Rays at Yankees, looking for a rare series win

UPDATE. 12:01: Cash said they are confident Pham's foot is fine and there is no risk activating him after just one rehab game. Also, that Pham was adamant about wanting to play in Yankee Stadium (for the first time in his career) and in playing leftf...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Rays ballpark engineers computer-modeled fly balls to design a roof that would stay out of play

Rays ballpark engineers computer-modeled fly balls to design a roof that would stay out of play

TAMPA — The roof at the Tampa Bay Rays’ proposed ballpark in Ybor City is about the same height at its peak — 230 feet, give or take — as at Tropicana Field, but the similarities end there.One big difference: No catwalks. Nothing to get in the way of...
Published: 08/16/18
Rays journal: Offense finally shows up in 6-1 win over Yankees

Rays journal: Offense finally shows up in 6-1 win over Yankees

NEW YORK —  The Rays were looking for something to spark their once-again stagnant offense, and it came in somewhat unexpected ways in a 6-1 win over the Yankees on Wednesday.Rookie INF/OF Brandon Lowe, who didn't have a hit in his first 1...
Published: 08/15/18
As the Rays turn: Tommy Pham activated, Jake Faria demoted

As the Rays turn: Tommy Pham activated, Jake Faria demoted

OF Tommy Pham only needed seven innings in leftfield and four at-bats for short-season Class A Hudson Valley on Wednesday to determine his fractured right foot was healed and he will rejoin the Rays for Thursday's matinee at Yankee Stadium.Pham was i...
Published: 08/15/18
Rays core that finishes season will be one that starts 2019, Stuart Sternberg says

Rays core that finishes season will be one that starts 2019, Stuart Sternberg says

NEW YORK — No, the Rays won't sit tight the whole off­season without changing their roster. That's not their style. There's going to be a trade or two. They'll dump somebody whose salary exceeds his value. With only maybe $30 million or so...
Published: 08/15/18
Marc Topkin’s takeaways from the Rays’ win over the Yankees

Marc Topkin’s takeaways from the Rays’ win over the Yankees

1. Welcome back, Kevin Kiermaier. For one night, anyway, the slumping centerfielder looked like the kind of game-changer the Rays expect, rapping a few hits, racing around the bases and roaming the outfield, making leaping catches and laser-like thro...
Published: 08/15/18