Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

There's no excuse for leaving Rays manager Joe Maddon off All-Star staff

From left, coaches Jim Hickey and Dave Martinez and manager Joe Maddon watch the Rays’ victory Sunday.


From left, coaches Jim Hickey and Dave Martinez and manager Joe Maddon watch the Rays’ victory Sunday.

[This column was revised on July 8, 2008]

ST. PETERSBURG — Josh Hamilton is having a phenomenal season, and was a deserving choice as a starting outfielder in the All-Star Game.

Francisco Rodriguez is on a record pace for saves and, appropriately, is an All-Star closer.

Cliff Lee was nearly unhittable for the first six weeks of the season, and so he earned his spot as one of the American League's starting pitchers.

For the most part, all of the best performers at their positions have a place in the All-Star Game.

Except for this one:

Rays manager Joe Maddon should be there.

Sure, a Rays fan could argue the cases of J.P. Howell and Dan Wheeler, but all the relievers on the All-Star roster have better numbers. And you could quibble with Joe Crede making it ahead of Evan Longoria at third base, but Crede was elected by players, and Longoria still has a chance in the final fan balloting.

In a lot of ways, Boston manager Terry Francona's hands were tied when it came to filling out the final six spots on the roster. He had to name four players to ensure every team had a representative, and he had to name an extra pitcher to make sure he had the required 12. That means catcher Dioner Navarro was his final selection, which was appropriate.

But when it comes to the coaching staff, MLB rules are horribly flawed. Francona extended invitations to New York's Joe Girardi and Detroit's Jim Leyland before the season began. Working under that kind of time frame, that means every spot in the dugout is performance-related except for the coaching staff.

And there's something wrong with that.

Seriously, which manager has had a better first half? Which manager has pushed more of the right buttons? No matter how it's measured, I defy anyone to find a more deserving candidate than Maddon.

Do you want to judge it in terms of success? Because the Rays have the best record in the majors.

Do you want to consider it in terms of improvement? Because the Rays are on pace for the greatest turnaround in major-league history.

Do you want to get inside the numbers and base it on who got the most out of their roster? Because the Rays came into Sunday's game without a single player in the top 10 in the AL in batting average, home runs or RBIs. And none of their pitchers was in the top 10 in ERA or strikeouts.

Here's another way of looking at it: You have to go back to the 1980s to find a team that had the best record in baseball at the break but was limited to two representatives at the All-Star Game.

Which means the Rays are a rare breed in this game. A highly successful team that does not need to be carried by a handful of superstars or players having career years. And I have to believe the manager has a lot to do with that.

"He understands our strengths, and he knows our weaknesses, and he puts us all in a position to succeed," outfielder Jonny Gomes said. "It's not like we have 25 robots going out there.

"Our stats stick with us, but the won-loss record sticks with him.''

From that standpoint, you could make an argument that Maddon has done his job better than anyone else in the Rays clubhouse. Statistically speaking, the thing that jumps out at you most about the Rays is their record. It's might overstating the situation to say Maddon has been the most valuable asset on the team, but it's hard to argue that he hasn't made a major impact.

Absolutely, Joe deserves it," closer Troy Percival said. "The job he has done started two years ago. He showed patience with all the kids they have here. As anyone in here would attest, they were all waiting for him to blow up, but he never did. He put in time trying to teach people how to play the game, and it's all benefitting the team now."

A few years ago, I suggested Maddon might be too soft to be a big-league skipper. That he was too concerned about building trust and a rapport with his players. I wrote that it would be nice if he would occasionally acknowledge publicly when a player wasn't performing to expectations.

Turns out, I was wrong.

Sure, it's a thankless job when it comes to managing an All-Star Game. Odds are, you're going to tick off somebody when filling out the roster, but it comes with the territory when you win a pennant.

"Maybe that's the answer," Percival said. "Maybe we'll get Joe there next year as the manager."

John Romano can be reached at

>>Fast facts

All-Star rarity

Not since the Angels in 1989 has a team sported the best record in baseball at the All-Star break and not had at least three representatives on the All-Star team.



2007Red Sox6


2005White Sox4





2000White Sox3








Blue Jays3




* The Rays could have three All-Stars if Evan Longoria is voted to the final roster spot.

There's no excuse for leaving Rays manager Joe Maddon off All-Star staff 07/06/08 [Last modified: Saturday, July 12, 2008 11:35pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pro Bowl returning to Orlando in 2018


    ORLANDO — The Pro Bowl will return to Orlando in 2018 for the second straight year.

    Bucs  wide receiver Mike Evans runs a route as Denver Broncos cornerback Chris Harris Jr. defends during the first quarter of the AFC-NFC Pro Bowl in January at Camping World Stadium in Orlando. [LOREN ELLIOTT | Times]
  2. Erasmo Ramirez makes his third start of the season.
  3. If Tony Dungy sticks around, he'll broadcast the 2021 Tampa Super Bowl for NBC


    Lost in the Super Tuesday news of the Super Bowl coming back to Tampa was this nugget:

    Pictured, from left, Dan Patrick, co-Host, Tony Dungy, studio analyst, Aaron Rodgers. [Ben Cohen/NBC]
  4. Tragedy, tenacity helped shape Ridgewood valedictorian Johannah Cummines

    Volleyball Preps

    NEW PORT RICHEY — Even if her daily routine didn't permit calories to melt off, Johannah Cummines would deserve to pick anything on the menu.

    Ridgewood High senior Johannah Cummines and mom Chenell. Cummines is headed to Florida Atlantic, where she will play beach volleyball. (Photo courtesy of Johannah Cummines)
  5. Bucs Roberto Aguayo kicks off 2017 on the wrong foot


    The goal posts still seem to be moving for Roberto Aguayo.

    The Bucs woebegone place-kicker, who is in a battle with veteran Nick Folk, went 1-for-4 in field goal tries from 35-40 yards Tuesday on a set of narrow uprights, the first day of full squad Organized Team Activities.

    If that weren’t …

    Roberto Aguayo went 1-for-4 in field goal tries from 35-40 yards Tuesday on a set of narrow uprights.