Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

We'll have to wait to judge Tampa Bay Rays draft

Mikie Mahtook might make Andrew Friedman look like a genius for drafting him. Check back in about five years on the LSU centerfielder and other picks.

Getty Images

Mikie Mahtook might make Andrew Friedman look like a genius for drafting him. Check back in about five years on the LSU centerfielder and other picks.


In baseball, you have to be quick. You have to be sharp. You have to think on your feet.

And those are just the requirements of the general manager.

Ah, poor Andrew Friedman. It was Monday night, the night of Friedman's annual IQ test (the major-league draft), and suddenly, Friedman was surrounded by decisions. He would make a pick, and here would come another one, and another after that, and another after that. It was late in the evening, and just like that, Friedman was playing in the lightning round from Password.

A pitcher from South Carolina. An outfielder from Louisiana. A shortstop. Another shortstop. A third baseman. A second pitcher. A third pitcher. Another outfielder. A fourth pitcher. Another outfielder.


On and on it went, quicker than hiccups, as repetitive as popcorn, as rapid as drumbeats. Through the first round and sandwich picks, it was as if Friedman were picking in a three-man Rotisserie League. Once the 24th pick of the first round arrived, it seemed as if it was always Friedman's turn at bat.

"Controlled chaos," Friedman called it. All things considered, he seemed to enjoy the whirling, frenetic ride. After all, he will probably never have another draft night with 10 out of 60 picks.

"It was a lot of fun," Friedman said. "Our scouts did such a good job, they allowed it to be fun."

Also, it was as breathless, and it was relentless, and for a while, it seemed endless. Ah, but was it good?

Who knows?

At this point, not even Friedman and his scouting staff can be sure. That's the thing about the MLB draft. It's like throwing darts through a tornado. A lot of darts improve the odds, but that still doesn't guarantee a thing.

So was Friedman a genius? Or just very, very busy?

Did the Rays restock their minors? Or did the Rays just make a lot of noise?

Are the Rays better off today? And how many tomorrows will it be until we know?

I don't know about you, but I say we all get together in five years to decide.

That's how long it will be until anyone can tell how the Rays did Monday night, you know. For all of their picks, for all the potential, for all of the signing bonuses ahead, it will be sometime about 2016 before anyone knows how good this draft was for them. Oh, a player or two will trickle through before that, but to judge the haul, you'll have to wait.

Think about that: By 2016, we will know if the Rays are going to get a new stadium, and where, and whether Evan Longoria will play in it. By 2016, David Price will be in his 30s, and Joe Maddon will be in his 60s, and Don Zimmer will be in his 80s (still). The world will spin around quite a bit before we know about Taylor Guerrieri, Mikie Mahtook and the rest of the orchestra who became Rays players on Monday night.

Was Guerrieri really one of the top two high school pitchers in the draft? Were those who graded Mahtook as a top 15 pick accurate? Was Jake Hager a reach or a slice of insight?

It bears repeating just how important a night such as this was for the Rays. They needed to do better than the odds suggest. They had to be smarter than most. Given their budget, the Rays are always going to have to survive by their wits, by drafting and developing their talent.

If this were the NFL, or the NBA or the NHL, you would begin to feel the impact of the draft in the next season or two. This is the downside of the baseball draft. (The upside? No Mel Kiper.)

How smooth will the ride be for the Rays' new employees? Some will rise, and some will fall, and some will get hurt, and some will develop and some will not. If the Rays are fortunate, a precious few of them will make an impact in the big leagues someday.

All of which leads us back to the image of Friedman, spinning around in his chair, trying to come up with 10 correct answers. Let's face it: Friedman has had a lot of smart moments in his years with the Rays.

How smart was he Monday?

Check back in 2016. Maybe 2017. If Friedman had a keeper of a night, eventually it will show on the scoreboard.

We'll have to wait to judge Tampa Bay Rays draft 06/06/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, June 7, 2011 12:39am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Family a driving force for University of Tampa pitcher David Lebron


    TAMPA — For University of Tampa junior pitcher David Lebron, baseball reminds him of family. He uses it to help honor the memory of his father, who taught him the game. One day, he hopes his career can help support his mother and allow her to rest.

    University of Tampa junior pitcher David Lebron (Courtesy of University of Tampa)
  2. L.A. delay could re-open Super Bowl chance for Tampa in 2021


    Construction delays on the NFL's new stadium in Los Angeles mean the Rams and Chargers won't be playing there until 2020, a year later than expected, and the ripple effect could give Tampa another chance at landing a Super Bowl in February 2021.

    Tampa and Raymond James Stadium last hosted a Super Bowl in 2009, when the Pittsburgh Steelers edged the Arizona Cardinals.
  3. Bucs' Gerald McCoy, Jameis Winston honored in NFL top 100


    Helping fans pass time through the offseason each summer, NFL Network has been unveiling its top 100 players for 2017 as chosen by the players, and the Bucs' Gerald McCoy and Jameis Winston are the first Tampa Bay players revealed, coming in at No. 52 and 57, respectively.

    Bucs quarterback Jameis WInston and defensive tackle Gerald McCoy, shown in the 2016 season finale against the Panthers, have both been named to the NFL Network's top 100 players for 2017.
  4. The play occurred in the third inning when Angels rookie Nolan Fontana, making his major league debut, tried to slide past the tag of Rays second baseman Michael Martinez.
  5. Former Gator Caleb Brantley paying a steep price for nothing


    It turns out Caleb Brantley isn't quite the dirtbag that millions of people presumed. It's too bad the damage to his reputation and bank account is already done.

    Caleb Brantley, who dropped to the sixth round of the draft, works out during Browns rookie minicamp. [Associated Press]