Tuesday, October 23, 2018
Colleges

CFP rankings: Unbeaten mid major's snub cries out for expanded playoff

Before the Jan. 9 national championship game kicks off, 128 banners will enter Raymond James Stadium, one for each Division I-A team.

The four semifinalists' banners will advance, then the final two will meet near midfield. The fans will go crazy. It's a cool sight.

But it's also misleading. Some of those 128 teams don't really belong among the contenders. How else can you explain Western Michigan?

The Broncos can finish 13-0 with a win over Ohio in Friday's MAC championship. Yet they have no realistic shot at making the semifinals; the College Football Playoff selection committee put Western Michigan No. 17 in Tuesday's latest set of rankings, with no hope of cracking the top four.

No, the Broncos don't have a resume as impressive as Washington or Wisconsin. But if an undefeated conference champion doesn't have a shot at winning the national title, why bother? Why put their banner on the field at all?

The solution is simple, and one that would work well this year: Expand the playoff to eight teams.

The best teams in each Power Five league are clear, no matter what happens this weekend: Alabama, Ohio State, Clemson, Washington and whoever wins the Oklahoma-Oklahoma State game (which would have been played last weekend under an eight-team playoff). Replace the conference title games with quarterfinal matchups and give all five league champs an automatic playoff berth.

The top Group of Five team would get one, too, so Western Michigan can row the boat to the quarterfinals. The best at-large teams get the last two spots. Give the top four seeds homefield advantage for the first round to keep the meaning in the final regular-season games.

Remember this idea Saturday when you're watching 'Bama blow out Florida in the SEC Championship Game or seeing the Big Ten's third- and fourth-best teams compete for the league title.

Instead, this year's drama will take place in a hotel conference room in Grapevine, Texas, where the committee will watch the conference championships and select the four semifinalists.

But there might not be much drama after all. If No. 1 'Bama, No. 3 Clemson and No. 4 Washington all win their leagues, they're likely in, along with No. 2 Ohio State. With an upset or two, the Big Ten champ — either No. 6 Wisconsin or No. 7 Penn State — could join the Buckeyes in the semifinals. No. 8 Colorado (up one spot from last week) needs a win and some help.

Tuesday's rankings gave a better glimpse of teams that could be left out. Michigan fell to No. 5 and will have a very hard time climbing back. The Big 12 champ (either No. 9 Oklahoma or No. 10 Oklahoma State) seems unlikely to vault into the final four — but would be guaranteed a spot in an eight-team field.

NEW YEAR'S SIX: Florida State seems headed for a fifth consecutive New Year's Six/BCS bowl appearance. The Seminoles jumped to No. 12 and leapfrogged No. 13 Louisville as the ACC's second-best team, despite the Cardinals' 63-20 rout in September. If Clemson beats No. 23 Virginia Tech in Orlando for the ACC title and the rankings hold firm, FSU would get the ACC's spot in the Orange Bowl and a potential matchup with Michigan.

Florida might be in the mix for the Sugar Bowl, even with a loss Saturday. The Gators stayed at No. 15, one spot below Auburn. If UF looks better than the Tigers did in their 30-12 Iron Bowl loss to 'Bama, the committee might rank the Gators as the SEC's second-best team. That would send UF to New Orleans against the winner of this week's Sooners-Cowboys game.

Contact Matt Baker at [email protected]. Follow @MBakerTBTimes.

Comments
Cam Akers, Florida State run game trying to break through against Clemson

Cam Akers, Florida State run game trying to break through against Clemson

TALLAHASSEE — When Florida State running back Cam Akers saw the hole open up on the second play of Saturday's third quarter against Wake Forest, his first thought was obvious.Touchdown.Sometime after that 58-yard touchdown in the Seminoles' 38-...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Florida Gators reflect on the weirdness of Jim McElwain’s exit, one year later

Florida Gators reflect on the weirdness of Jim McElwain’s exit, one year later

GAINESVILLE — As No. 9 Florida prepares for its first top-10 meeting with Georgia in a decade, it's important to remember the innocuous moment that started the Gators' path back to the national stage.It was a year ago, on the Monday of Georgia ...
Published: 10/22/18
Florida Gators preparing for top-10 showdown with Georgia

Florida Gators preparing for top-10 showdown with Georgia

GAINESVILLE — As No. 9 Florida prepares for to play No. 7 Georgia on Saturday, the Gators aren't putting any extra attention on a top-10 matchup, the appearance of ESPN's College GameDay or any of the other hoopla surrounding the rivalry's...
Published: 10/22/18
AP Top 25: Florida Gators in top 10, USF remains steady

AP Top 25: Florida Gators in top 10, USF remains steady

The Florida Gators moved up two spots to No. 9 in the latest AP Top 25 poll released Sunday. That's their highest ranking since 2015 and sets up a top-10 showdown Saturday against No. 7 Georgia. It'll be the first top-10 matchup between the two rival...
Published: 10/21/18
Matt Baker’s AP Top 25 ballot: Florida Gators over Ohio State

Matt Baker’s AP Top 25 ballot: Florida Gators over Ohio State

Coming up with my weekly AP Top 25 ballot, I'm always faced with new questions I never considered.Like this one, from 247Sports' excellent Gators writer, Thomas Goldkamp:Does Florida move past Ohio State in this week’s rankings? Legit question....
Published: 10/21/18
ESPN’s College GameDay headed to Florida-Georgia

ESPN’s College GameDay headed to Florida-Georgia

The biggest Florida-Georgia game in years will have the pregame hype to match the high stakes.ESPN's College GameDay will be in Jacksonville for the annual rivalry game, the network announced Saturday evening. The SEC Network's pregame show, SEC Nati...
Published: 10/20/18
Without Milton, No. 10 UCF beats ECU 37-10 for 20th straight

Without Milton, No. 10 UCF beats ECU 37-10 for 20th straight

GREENVILLE, N.C. — Darriel Mack Jr. stepped in for Heisman Trophy hopeful McKenzie Milton and rushed for 120 yards and a touchdown, and No. 10 UCF forced five turnovers in beating East Carolina 37-10 for its 20th straight victory. Nate Evans returned...
Published: 10/20/18
Florida State climbing under Willie Taggart, but ‘Noles still have a long way to go

Florida State climbing under Willie Taggart, but ‘Noles still have a long way to go

TALLAHASSEE — Florida State's 38-17 comeback win over Wake Forest on Saturday was a nice way to start the second half of coach Willie Taggart's inaugural season.It was certainly better than how the first half went — with a 21-point home d...
Published: 10/20/18
FSU journal: Tackle for loss becomes moment to reflect

FSU journal: Tackle for loss becomes moment to reflect

TALLAHASSEE — Less than two weeks after Hurricane Michael destroyed his Panama City home, Florida State LB Janarius Robinson was just happy to be back on the field and able to contribute.He did more than that Saturday.Robinson recorded a career...
Published: 10/20/18
McKenzie Milton out of starting lineup for No. 10 UCF at ECU

McKenzie Milton out of starting lineup for No. 10 UCF at ECU

GREENVILLE, N.C. — Heisman Trophy hopeful McKenzie Milton did not start at quarterback on Saturday night for No. 10 UCF at East Carolina. Team spokesman Andy Seeley said only that it was a game-time decision by coach Josh Heupel. Darriel Mack Jr. mad...
Published: 10/20/18