Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

College football slowdown proposal prompts controversy

The college football rules proposal raging through the Twitter-verse, one far more dissed than deliberated, begs a rhetorical question:

Just when did Alabama coach Nick Saban and Arkansas coach Bret Bielema determine high-octane offenses needed to ease up on the throttle for the sake of defensive player safety?

Could Saban's epiphany have occurred while Auburn's no-huddle, no-blink attack amassed 296 rushing yards on the Crimson Tide in November? Could the bulb suddenly have illuminated for Bielema as Texas A&M collected 523 yards on 74 plays against the Razorbacks in September?

Legions of coaches and commentators have suggested exactly that. When you're trying to call an audible on a basic tenet of the game, expect a little sarcasm. And a lot of pushback.

"It makes no sense," new USF offensive coordinator (and former Washington State coach) Paul Wulff said.

By now, you're likely aware of the proposal, which is scheduled to be heard by the NCAA's Playing Rules Oversight Panel on Thursday. It prohibits offenses from snapping the ball until at least 10 seconds elapse from the 40-second play clock.

The rule would not be in effect for the last two minutes of each half or if the play clock began at 25 seconds. If the ball is snapped while 30 or more seconds remain on the clock, the offense will be whistled for — how's this for paradoxical poetry? — delay of game.

Saban and Bielema, both of who run traditional offenses, are the proposal's most prominent advocates. Saban even addressed the NCAA Football Rules Committee — which approved it — on its behalf. (Though Friday, Saban said, "I had nothing to do with the idea" and had no opinion on it.) Bielema participated in the discussion as chairman of the American Football Coaches Association rules committee.

Neither had a vote. As for the opponents, well, New Coke didn't have this many naysayers.

Steve Spurrier dubbed it the "Saban Rule" with his trademark jeer. A recent ESPN poll of 128 Division I-A coaches found only 25 (19.5 percent) favor it.

"I'm definitely against it," former Plant High and Georgia quarterback Aaron Murray said. "I'm a little bit biased because I am an offensive player, but it's part of the game now.

"At the end of the day, the goal is to run as many plays as you can. You won't always be successful at them. But the more plays you run, the more snaps everyone gets as a team, the more chances for you to make bigger plays down the field."

As division opponents of Auburn, Saban's and Bielema's advocacy appears self-serving. Slow the offense, and your defense can substitute and adjust. Thing is, they've hitched their support to the s-word, at least momentarily altering the conversation's tone.

If safety is a smokescreen for an ulterior agenda, it's a shrewd one. In the current climate, no one's going to scoff at player welfare. That includes Troy Calhoun.

The rules committee chairman and Air Force coach, Calhoun was a Broncos assistant in 2005 when 49ers 310-pound guard Thomas Herrion collapsed and died moments after a Broncos-49ers preseason game. A form of heart disease was determined as the cause of death.

"Bottom line," Calhoun told, "if there is something that stands through that is medically legitimate, there is a concern. If there is nothing overwhelmingly conclusive, that's a different deal."

Essentially, that's all most skeptics are requesting: proof connecting a faster-paced game to increased injuries or an adverse effect on player health. So far, none exists.

"There's zero proof that has anything to do with it," Wulff said.

"You can't really say just by them going super ridiculously fast that somebody's going to get hurt," said former Florida State (and Alonso High) defensive tackle Demonte McAllister, who had a tackle against Auburn in the BCS title game. "You can go the regular speed of the game and somebody can get hurt, too."

Might be moot anyway. In the national title game, Auburn ran two plays with 30 or more seconds remaining on the clock.

"In research that I did a few years ago, there are only 4-6 plays in a game where a team is snapping the ball before 30 seconds," Florida coach Will Muschamp said. "So we're not talking about a whole lot of plays being affected anyway. My biggest concern is the administration of the game by the officials. It is very difficult when the ball is snapped quickly.

"Is the chain gang lined up? Are the officials ready? Are they in position to make the right call? That is not good for the game if the officials can't administer the game correctly."

Ultimately, Muschamp says, he'll be fine with whatever is decided. Same with USF coach Willie Taggart who, coincidentally, is employing a more brisk tempo this spring.

The most plausible scenario: The proposal is tabled for a year so more data can be collected. If it does pass, coaches will do what they've done since chalkboards doubled as scoreboards: adapt and adjust.

"Everything's evolving," Murray said. "You're not used to 35-31, 42-35 games in the SEC. It used to be 17-14, 17-10 and stuff like that.

"But I'm sure the defenses and these defensive masterminds like Nick Saban and everyone else are going to figure out ways to counteract the speed of the game and figure out ways to slow it down or find ways to get their defenses set up faster to get ready to go."

What they're saying

Nick Saban, Alabama coach at last summer's SEC media days:

"Should we allow football to be a continuous game?"

Former Florida State coach Bobby Bowden, who began running the hurry-up in 1993, quarterback Charlie Ward's senior season:

"We kind of stumbled into what they're doing now, although they do it faster. People like offense. Unless they can show me evidence that boys are injured by doing that, I say leave it alone."

Chuck Bresnahan, USF defensive coordinator and former NFL coordinator:

"The game is designed to be competitive, and there are going to be edges. Right now, it's become an offensive game. We understand that as defensive coaches."

Mark Richt, Georgia coach:

" I feel like if you can train offensive players to play five or six plays in a row, you train defensive players to play that many plays in a row as well."

Demonte McAllister, former Florida State (and Alonso High) defensive tackle:

"It's not really that hard after somebody makes a play for everybody to hustle back to the ball and get the call from the sideline. It can get a little tricky, but the offense can't go that much faster. Auburn was pretty fast (in the BCS title game), but we practiced for it."

College football slowdown proposal prompts controversy 03/02/14 [Last modified: Sunday, March 2, 2014 10:09pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Lightning takes defenseman Cal Foote with top pick in draft

    Lightning Strikes

    CHICAGO — Former Avalanche defenseman Adam Foote said his son Cal lived in the locker room.

    Cal Foote, second from left, is welcomed to the Lightning by GM Steve Yzerman, far left.
  2. It's Rays' turn to pound Orioles pitching (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG - Ah, the fantastic four.

    The Rays smashed the reeling Orioles 15-5 on Friday, scoring a season-high in runs, to climb four games above .500 for the first time since July 1, 2015.

    Rays third baseman Evan Longoria scores on a triple by Logan Morrison during the first inning against the Orioles.
  3. Lightning journal: Plans set for 25th anniversary season

    Lightning Strikes

    CHICAGO — The Lightning revealed some of its plans for its 25th anniversary season Friday, including a ceremony to honor the 2004 Stanley Cup team.

    fit test: Top draft pick Cal Foote puts on his Lightning jersey.
  4. Rays designate catcher Derek Norris for assignment

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — C Derek Norris tied a career-high with three hits in Friday's 15-5 win against the Orioles then was designated for assignment after the game to make room on the 25-man roster for C Wilson Ramos.

    Matt Duffy is expected to resume his baseball activities once the stitches heal.
  5. Lightning picks defenseman Cal Foote


    Cal Foote is the son of former Avs defenseman Adam Foote.