Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

In Miami scandal, NCAA investigators need to get it right

Imagine a team out of control, arrogant and defiant.

For so long, it has gone where it wished and done what it wanted, and to heck with anyone who had a problem with it. Its decisions are so confounding, and its actions are so baffling, that you cannot help but wonder if anyone has ever read a rule book.

Yes, you can suggest all of that about the football program at the University of Miami.

If you prefer, you can also say it about the NCAA investigators on the edge of campus.

This time, the NCAA needs to get it right. This time, it needs to be thorough, it needs to be accurate, it needs to be wise. This time, it needs to bring Sheriff Andy and leave all of the Barney Fifes at home.

It can be a confusing organization, the NCAA. It moved too slowly with USC, and it rushed too quickly with Ohio State, and who knows what it was thinking with Auburn? It was too tough on Florida State, and too easy on UConn and completely out of whack with Georgia Tech. In recent seasons, there have been times the NCAA seemed to have determined its punishments through The Spinning Dartboard of Justice.

And now the NCAA is at Miami's door.

Why shouldn't as many eyes be on the investigators as vice versa?

This is not a call for heads at Miami, nor is it a plea for mercy. As I wrote last week: If these charges are true, it won't be pretty. But until the facts have been uncovered, none of us knows what the right punishment should be.

What I would like to see here is a patient, methodical investigation by the NCAA. More than a hundred players should be interviewed. Dozens of coaches. Nevin Shapiro. Documents should be reviewed. Phone records should be checked. Tough questions should be asked. Basically, the NCAA should care as much about Miami as did.

That doesn't seem like a lot to ask, does it? But when has anyone been satisfied when the NCAA left town? No, no, I'm not talking about the angered fans whose team has had its chances of winning lessened. Every time a school is punished, you hear from them. They're never happy with punishment, and the media is always to blame, and besides, they will tell you, everyone does it. And so on.

For an organization that is in charge of answers, however, there are a lot of questions about the NCAA.

Honestly, why did it take the NCAA so long to get to the Reggie Bush scandal? Once it did, was the punishment excessive? USC got a two-year bowl ban, the loss of 30 scholarships over three years and had a national title and a Heisman taken away. It was harsh enough to make Ohio State, North Carolina, Oregon and Miami a little nervous.

Then there is Ohio State. If you remember, the NCAA announced that five players would be punished in 2011, but yeah, it was okay for them to play in the Sugar Bowl. That's silly. As soon as a player is dirty, shouldn't he be removed from the roster immediately? Of course he should. And could someone please explain, one more time, why it isn't a lack of institutional control when the head coach (the recently deposed Jim Tressel, in this case) knows his players are outside the rules and keeps it a secret?

Then there was Auburn. Granted, this was a tough one for the NCAA, because there hasn't been any evidence to suggest that Cecil Newton (the father of quarterback Cam Newton) asked Auburn for money (he did ask Mississippi State) or that his son knew about it. Still, why did Auburn rule Cam ineligible and have the NCAA immediately reinstate him the week of the SEC title game? If the NCAA didn't know anything, why should it do anything?

Compare the Newton case to that of Baylor basketball player Perry Jones, who was suspended the day the Big 12 Conference tournament started. His violation? His mother Terri had borrowed $1,000 to help pay her mortgage. Not from Baylor, but from Jones' AAU coach, an old friend of the family. She said her son didn't know about it.

It goes on. Georgia Tech was hit with four years probation and vacated the 2009 ACC title because wide receiver Demaryius Thomas reportedly was given $312 worth of clothes (and because Tech wasn't cooperative enough in the investigation), most of which he returned. Former FSU coach Bobby Bowden was stripped of victories because of cheating in a music course, a course he didn't know about in a building he couldn't find. I still find that silly. (Although not as silly as when the NCAA threatened to punish Clemson because its players were wearing illegal underwear before changing its mind.)

I know, I know. The NCAA is overwhelmed these days with the scandals at Miami and Ohio State and North Carolina and Oregon and Boise State and Tennessee and, it seems, everywhere else. It is an ugly, rotten time for college athletics, and it's hard to clean the sleaze off of so many goal posts.

It is because of that, however, that the NCAA investigators are counted on to be the justice department of college. Instead, they seem confused, reactionary, arbitrary. Think of it like this: punishment without logic isn't justice. It's just bullying.

Ask yourself this: Do you trust the NCAA? It's a telling question, isn't it?

This time, the charges against Miami are so reckless, so plentiful, so scandalous that a nation will pay as much attention to this investigation as to any in the history of college football.

Along the way, perhaps we should pay attention to the investigators, too.

In Miami scandal, NCAA investigators need to get it right 08/23/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, August 23, 2011 10:42pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. For starters: Rays at Twins, looking for another with Odorizzi starting


    The Rays are looking to keep rolling when they make a quick turnaround after Friday's win over the Twins and are back on the field for a matinee today, 2:10 first pitch Tampa Bay time.

    RHP Jake Odorizzi will be on the mound for the Rays, coming off a good but not great start against the Angels, though buoyed …

  2. Why the Lightning would consider trading Jonathan Drouin

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — This summer, the Lightning could trade one of its most dynamic young players ever.

    Tampa Bay Lightning left wing Jonathan Drouin (27) celebrates with his team on the bench after beating Chicago Blackhawks goalie Scott Darling (33) to score his second goal of the period and to tie the score at 4 to 4 during second period action at the Amalie Arena in Tampa Monday evening (03/27/17).
  3. Why the Lightning should keep Jonathan Drouin

    Lightning Strikes

    Keep him.

    Jonathan Drouin is live bait. The Lightning is ready to run the hook through him and cast him out there again. Drouin has enough talent for the Lightning to meet some defensive needs in a deal.

    Keep him.

    Lightning wing Jonathan Drouin celebrates after beating Los Angeles Kings goalie Peter Budaj during the first period of Tuesday's win in Tampa. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD   |   Times]
  4. This Tampa Bay Lightning wing rides the newest wave of fan interaction

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — There are photos of Lightning fan Shaun Egger as a toddler at center ice at the then-Thunderome, aka Tropicana Field. He's played in the Lightning's high school hockey league for Palm Harbor University. But his closest personal encounter with players had been waving through a crowd after a training camp …

    Tampa Bay Lightning player J.T. Brown wears his anti UV glasses as he talks over the headset with a hockey fan while they play against each other on line in an XBOX NHL video game in Brown's game room at his home in south Tampa. The fan chose to be the Washington Capitals and Brown, of course, was the Tampa Bay Lightning. Brown interacts with fans through video game systems as he streams the games live on Twitch with plans for the proceeds to go to charity.
  5. ‘Biggest fight' behind her, Petra Kvitova returns ahead of schedule


    PARIS — Five months after a home invader's knife sliced into her left hand, Petra Kvitova will return to competitive tennis at the French Open, a last-minute decision to make her comeback earlier than expected.

    Petra Kvitova adjusts her hair during a news conference at Roland Garros Stadium, where she will make her tennis return at the French Open. Kvitova's left hand was badly injured by a knife-wielding intruder in December; she has recovered ahead of schedule. [Associated Press]