Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Weighing the merits of FSU vs. Oregon

In September, college football is all about the sights. It is all about football teams racing onto the field and toward the season, and it is about mascots roaming the sideline, and it is about scheduling easy wins to get a team kick-started.

In October, college football is all about the feel. Conference schedules begin, and fans remind each other of traditions, and as the disappointments fade away, the season starts to take shape.

In November, however, college football is about the sound of it all. The noise increases in volume, and the cheers get louder, and the arguments get testier. It is as if fans believe they can debate their team into the national title game.

All of that said, here's a question:

Why, exactly, is Oregon ahead of FSU in the human polls?

Hey, it's just a question. The truth is that we don't really know that Alabama is better than Oregon, or that Oregon is better than FSU, or that Ohio State is better than all of them. At this point, college is an art show. You pick the team that looks prettiest to you.

What we do know is that the voters of the Associated Press poll like Oregon better, as do the voters of the USA Today poll, as do the voters of the Harris poll, as do the voters of the Legends poll. Yes, FSU is second in the BCS ranking, but if Oregon handles Stanford on the road Thursday night, that will probably change, too.

In other words, FSU could be on its way to finishing this season undefeated and uninvited. The Seminoles could easily finish third — someone has to — which would leave them in front of the TV and watching the national title game.

Again, why?

Aren't the polls supposed to judge teams by their accomplishments? If that's true, FSU has simply done more than Oregon has. It went on the road and trampled the No. 3 team in the country in Clemson. It has beaten three ranked teams, including two in the top 10.

There seems to be an impression out there that Oregon is playing a much tougher schedule than FSU. But is that true? Think about this: In eight games, FSU has beaten only two teams that have losing records. In its eight games, Oregon has beaten only two teams with winning records. Oregon's best wins have been over UCLA when it was ranked 12th and Washington when it was 16th. So why does everyone assume that a close race will go to Oregon?

It is true that there are too many soft touches on the FSU schedule. Playing Nevada and Bethune-Cookman and Idaho is just too many gimme putts along the way. But Oregon played Nicholls State and Virginia and Tennessee along the way, teams they didn't exactly pull off of the victory stand to schedule.

You want statistics? For what it's worth, Oregon has the second-best offense in college football, and FSU is only fourth. But FSU has the seventh-best defense, and Oregon is 27th. In other words, both are impressive teams led by impressive quarterbacks on their way to an impressive season. It's like comparing diamonds.

So why is Oregon ranked higher than FSU?

Why, it's easy. That's what the polls said was true in August.

For years, this has been one of the most absurd parts of the national polls. If you start high, it's easier to stay there. Oregon was third in the preseason polls, which means it had to pass only Ohio State along the way. FSU was 11th in one poll and 12th in the other. It was still eighth five polls later, and it was still fifth only three weeks ago.

Oh. So what you're telling me is that Oregon is ranked higher than FSU because it had a better July?


If you judge by what you read, maybe some of this, too, is because a lot of people seem to prefer to see an Alabama-Oregon title game. And, yes, the contrast of styles there is terrific to consider, a new school vs. old school, cavemen vs. spacemen kind of matchup. Remember, those teams finished last year 1-2, too.

And who knows? Maybe when the season plays itself out, that will be the best game possible. Lately, college football has been lucky that way.

On the other hand, there was Miami in 2000, and Oregon in 2001, and USC in 2003, and Auburn in 2004, and Georgia in 2007. Hey, it's the last year of the BCS. Why not go out with bruised feelings?

So is that the legacy of this FSU team? Is it doomed to be the latest team left out? Unless Oregon loses to Stanford, or unless Alabama loses to LSU, it might turn out that way.

No, that won't feel fair.

On the other hand, this is the BCS. When did fair have anything to do with anything?

Who's the 2?

Florida State and Oregon both have cases to be ranked No. 2:

FSU Category Oregon
4th (549.1 ypg) Total offense 2nd (632.1 ypg)
3rd (51.1 ppg) Scoring offense 2nd (55.6 ppg)
7th (287.6 ypg) Total defense 27rd (359.3 ypg)
4th (13.1 ppg) Scoring defense 7th (16.9 ppg)
8-0 Record 8-0

Weighing the merits of FSU vs. Oregon 11/05/13 [Last modified: Thursday, November 7, 2013 12:11pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Red state: Yes, Bill O'Reilly is a Bucs fan


    TAMPA -- The question was simple enough for Bucs fans: Why is former Fox News personality Bill O'Reilly wearing a red Bucs polo?

    O'Reilly was wearing the polo during a few video clips from his "No Spin News" podcast posted on his website Monday, which was exciting news for some Bucs fans and not-so-exciting …

    Former Fox News personality Bill O'Reilly was sporting a red Bucs polo during his "No Spin News" video podcast Monday. An assistant said the shirt was given to him by former Bucs tight end Dave Moore.
  2. For starters: Slumping LoMo, Dickerson not in Rays lineup tonight vs LHP


    1B Logan Morrison and LF Corey Dickerson, two of the main slumpers in the Rays lineup, are not in tonight's lineup with the Orioles throwing LHP Wade Miley.

    Logan Morrison is 0-for-12 on this homestand.
  3. Ex-Buc Booger McFarland becomes ABC college football analyst


    Former Bucs defensive lineman Booger McFarland is continuing his broadcasting rise by joining ABC's studio coverage for the upcoming college football season, ESPN announced Tuesday.

    Former Bucs lineman Booger McFarland (No. 92) will become an ABC studio analyst this college football season.
  4. Rank the top 10 Bucs players? Here's what fans said


    We mentioned this morning that is was a fun challenge, in response to Sports Illustrated's ranking of the NFL's top 400 players, to ask fans to rank their top 10 Bucs players.

    Bucs receiver Mike Evans celebrates with quarterback Jameis Winston during last year's Bucs win against the Seahawks. Evans and Winston finished 1-2 in an informal Twitter poll of fans ranking their top Bucs players.
  5. Brain study examined 111 former NFL players. Only one didn't have CTE.


    Researchers studying the link between football and chronic traumatic encephalopathy found that 99 percent of the brains donated by families of former NFL players showed signs of the neurodegenerative disease, according to a new study published Tuesday.

    This combination of photos provided by Boston University shows sections from a normal brain, top, and from the brain of former University of Texas football player Greg Ploetz, bottom, in stage IV of chronic traumatic encephalopathy. According to a report released on Tuesday by the Journal of the American Medical Association, research on the brains of 202 former football players has confirmed what many feared in life -- evidence of chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE, a devastating disease in nearly all the samples, from athletes in the NFL, college and even high school. [Dr. Ann McKee | BU via AP]