Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida State Seminoles' appeal to NCAA: School cooperation should factor in Bobby Bowden keeping victories

Florida State football coach Bobby Bowden should not be forced to vacate wins because the school's cooperation in the NCAA's academic misconduct investigation wasn't given sufficient consideration, the school said in its written appeal.

Tallahassee attorney Bill Williams said that even if the Division I Infractions Appeals Committee were to uphold the lone sanction FSU chose to fight in the case, it should not force a "reconfiguring" of innocent coaches' records.

"(That) would be excessive and arbitrary since it is undisputed that none of the head coaches was at all responsible for the misconduct that occurred," Williams wrote in the 28-page appeal that was released publicly Thursday afternoon.

While vacating wins would affect 10 sports in which the implicated 61 student-athletes competed in during 2006 and 2007, the biggest loser stands to be Bowden. (That despite the 2007 NCAA men's outdoor track and field title possibly being in jeopardy as well as NCAA postseason appearances in numerous other sports.)

Bowden ended last season with 382 career wins to trail Penn State's Joe Paterno by one for the all-time lead among Division I-A coaches. But given the sanctions, Bowden, 79, would lose all seven wins from the 2007 season and possibly more from the seven-win 2006 season, likely putting Paterno, 82, beyond reach.

The FSU appeal refers extensively to a recent case involving Oklahoma football players who were paid thousands of dollars for work they didn't do at a car dealership. Among the penalties was a vacating of wins from the 2005 season.

"In this case, the institution's cooperation was a significant factor in the ultimate detection of the violations … (and) the Committee on Infractions report did not acknowledge or discuss the nature or extent of the institution's cooperation, nor specify what weight, if any, it was given," the appeals committee wrote in February 2008.

That flew counter to a precedent it established in 1995 in a case involving Mississippi, saying that a school's cooperation had to be given "substantial weight in determining and imposing penalties" or it would be a "disincentive to the fullest possible institutional cooperation." Oklahoma's wins that season were safe.

In the FSU case, the Committee on Infractions simply said in its report that the school "met its obligation" under NCAA rules to cooperate.

Williams called that "opaquely" and with "pointed brevity" and proceeded to cite specific dates when FSU and the NCAA enforcement staff discussed the case and how much the two had actually partnered.

He urged the appeals committee "should not retreat from its consistent position that cooperation and corrective action are mitigations which the Committee on Infractions, in the imposition of penalties, must discuss and weigh."

The Committee on Infractions now has until May 26 to respond to FSU's appeal. FSU then has 14 days to offer a rebuttal. The NCAA enforcement staff might also submit a response to which FSU would have 10 days to answer. FSU has requested a hearing before the five-member appeal committee, which will be scheduled later.

Florida State Seminoles' appeal to NCAA: School cooperation should factor in Bobby Bowden keeping victories 04/23/09 [Last modified: Friday, April 24, 2009 8:01am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Bucs-Jaguars: Five things to watch Thursday in Jacksonville


    JACKSONVILLE — The Bucs have their second preseason game here Thursday against the Jaguars, and here are five things to keep an eye on as Tampa Bay moves closer to paring its roster from 90 players to 53 by Sept. 3.


    Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Jameis Winston (3) participates in training camp at One Buccaneer Place in Tampa, Fla., on Wednesday, Aug. 2, 2017. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times
  2. We knew Aguayo was a goner, and 'Hard Knocks' still delivers


    Tuesday night's second installment of Hard Knocks, the HBO show that is going behind the scenes at training camp with the Bucs, had plenty of interesting tidbits, revelations and insights.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers kicker Roberto Aguayo (19) kicks during training camp at One Buccaneer Place in Tampa, Fla., on Wednesday, Aug. 2, 2017. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times
  3. For starters: Rays at Jays, looking for some carryover


    The six runs and 13 hits the Rays posted on Tuesday were a positive, but the true test if they are out of their historically bad hitting slump will come tonight and in the coming days as they try to build on their success.

    "Hopefully,'' manager Kevin Cash said after Tuesday's 6-4 win, "there is a …

    Daniel Robertson is expected to make a third straight start tonight, likely at shortstop.
  4. What you might have missed in the second episode of the Bucs on 'Hard Knocks'


    We're back for another episode of The Annotated Hard Knocks, trying to find behind-the-scenes insights and things you might have missed in Tuesday's second episode of "Hard Knocks," following the Bucs in …

    As the crowd recognized him and got loud, Jameis Winston jumped up and down in celebration. [GREG AUMAN | Times]
  5. Why Noah Spence could be the Bucs' X-factor


    JACKSONVILLE — Noah Spence crouched in a four-point stance, bending low like a sprinter in starting blocks. At the snap, he took one step to his right, startling Jaguars left tackle Josh Wells with his explosiveness. Wells went for the move and Spence countered with an inside swim move, flying past Wells' right …

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers defensive end Noah Spence (57) participates in training camp at One Buccaneer Place in Tampa, Fla., on Wednesday, Aug. 2, 2017. LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times