Saturday, March 17, 2018
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Buccaneers vs. Cowboys Scouting Report, Week 15: The difference between Ezekiel Elliott and Doug Martin

Want to know why it looks as if Ezekiel Elliott is a step from the Pro Football Hall of Fame and Doug Martin is a step from the retirement home?

It might have to do with when they're getting hit.

Elliott could tie his shoes in the backfield. Martin? He's about as safe as a chunk of red meat in a lion's cage. Of Elliott's 1,392 yards, 58 percent have come after contact. Of Martin's 379 yards, 87 percent have come after contact.

Look at it this way: The Bucs' leading rusher, Jacquizz Rodgers, has had to break tackles and move piles to gain 422 yards. Elliott has gained 580 — before getting close enough to smell a would-be tackler's breath.

Tampa Bay's five-game winning streak has masked a critical flaw: Its ground attack looks much different from last season's. When the Bucs ran the ball, they were, on average, halfway to a first down. This season, they're only a third of the way there.

It might not get any easier for Martin and company Sunday night when the Bucs play the Cowboys. Dallas features a run defense that Football Outsiders rates as fourth best.

Part of the reason the Bucs' yards per carry are down is they're executing fewer "explosive" runs, which they define as runs of 12 or more yards. They're on pace to have about half as many as they had last season. The Cowboys lead the NFL with 48. That's a lot of first downs.

Center Joe Hawley said Martin and the Bucs are close to breaking through.

"I think he's ready for a big game, and we're ready to give him a big game," he said. "We just need to clean up little things and get him to the second level because he has the ability to make those big plays, so we just got to give him a little bit more room to run."

When he says Martin is running hard and needs help from the line, you wonder whether he's just talking up his teammate. But he has a point.

Bucs running backs have been tackled at or behind the line of scrimmage on 23 percent of their runs, the third-highest rate. That's up from 20 percent last season, which was around league-average.

The lack of running room has contributed to a low success rate in short-yardage situations (third and fourth downs with 2 or fewer yards to go, for example), a strength for the Bucs last season, when they converted seven out of 10 such runs. They're converting three out of 10 this season.

"It's a concern," coach Dirk Koetter said. "You should have a very high percentage converting on those third-down runs."

The Cowboys do. It's no coincidence three of their linemen were invited to the Pro Bowl last season. They're dominant. Dallas is achieving a first down or touchdown on 65 percent of its short-yardage runs, the second-best rate.

It's no fluke, either. The Cowboys have converted at that rate in each of the past four seasons.

"We pride ourselves on being a physical football team," coach Jason Garrett said. "That's how we built our team. It starts with those guys up front, and they do a great job controlling the line of scrimmage."

Koetter said there's no one reason for the Bucs' inconsistency in such situations.

"It might be the running back's track off, or it might be we didn't crowd the line of scrimmage," he said. "It might be that we just flat got beat on a point of attack block, or they might have made a good play."

Here's an example from the Bucs' win over the Chargers two weeks ago. On this third-and-2 run, San Diego stops Doug Martin for no gain.

After the snap, right guard Ali Marpet (74) and right tackle Demar Dotson (69) double-team defensive tackle Corey Liuget (94). Marpet has another assignment: block linebacker Korey Toomer (56).

The play breaks down when Liuget sheds the double team and tackles Martin before he can get to the line of scrimmage.

I asked Marpet this week about the play, and he critiqued his technique. Instead of trying to drive his arm into Liuget, he wishes he had driven into him with the top of his shoulder pad, he said.

The third-down stop isn't representative of Marpet's play. He's a confident, dependable run blocker. It does illustrate, however, the narrow difference between success and failure for an offense. When fighting for a yard or two, all 11 players need to execute. The guys on the other side are getting paid, too, and are going to make plays.

Here's a power run that worked, a Martin touchdown on third and goal from the 1 against the Bears.

Marpet pulls from the right side of the line to the left and acts as a lead blocker for Martin, who runs patiently as Marpet helps clear an alley.

Left guard Caleb Benenoch (77) isn't perfectly squared up against nose tackle Eddie Goldman (91), but he got a strong initial push and Goldman lost his balance. It's 11 guys doing their job, Marpet said. "Everyone's where they need to be."

Marpet believes success in short-yardage situations will come. The effort and toughness are there, he said.

"If we've done it before, we can do it this year."

Statistics in this report are from Football Outsiders, Pro Football Focus and Pro Football Reference. Contact Thomas Bassinger at [email protected] Follow @tometrics.

Offensive line success rate on power runs

Football Outsiders defines power runs as runs on third or fourth down with 2 yards or less to go, as well as runs on first and goal or second and goal from the 2-yard line or closer.

RankTeam2016 success rate2015 success rate (rank)
1New York Jets67 percent59 percent (26)
2Dallas65 percent66 percent (15)
3San Francisco63 percent67 percent (14)
4New Orleans59 percent74 percent (5)
5Arizona59 percent51 percent (29)
6Chicago59 percent74 percent (4)
7Tennessee59 percent37 percent (32)
8Houston57 percent65 percent (16)
9Carolina57 percent76 percent (2)
10Atlanta57 percent61 percent (21)
31Tampa Bay31 percent71 percent (8)
Source: Football Outsiders

How the Bucs and Cowboys built their offensive lines

Dallas has drafted three linemen in the first round since 2011 — left tackle Tyron Smith, left guard Ronald Leary and right guard Zack Martin. Between them, they've earned seven Pro Bowl nods.


PositionPlayerYear acquiredHow acquired (round-overall pick)ExperiencePro Bowls
Left tackleDonovan Smith2015draft, 2-3420
Left guardKevin Pamphile2014draft, 5-14930
CenterJoe Hawley2015free agency70
Right guardAli Marpet2015draft, 2-6120
Right tackleDemar Dotson2009undrafted70


PositionPlayerYear acquiredHow acquired (round-overall pick)ExperiencePro Bowls
Left tackleTyron Smith2011draft, 1-963
Left guardRonald Leary2012undrafted50
CenterTravis Frederick2013draft, 1-3142
Right guardZack Martin2014draft, 1-1632
Right tackleDoug Free2007draft, 4-12290

New Buc Chandler Catanzaro knows his place … on kickoffs, that is

New Buc Chandler Catanzaro knows his place … on kickoffs, that is

TAMPA — More than any free agent who signed with the Bucs, place-kicker Chandler Catanzaro could have the biggest impact on the new season.Finding a kicker who won't choke in the clutch has been the hardest piece of the puzzle. Considering that...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Bucs reach agreement with Ravens free agent Ryan Jensen to make him one of the NFL’s top paid centers

Bucs reach agreement with Ravens free agent Ryan Jensen to make him one of the NFL’s top paid centers

To understand why the Bucs went so hard after Ravens free agent center Ryan Jensen, you just have to see to what extent he went to protect his quarterback last season.After Joe Flacco took a late hit from the Dolphins' Kiko Alonso in a game last year...
Published: 03/16/18
Chandler Catanzaro hopes to bring continuity to Bucs’ kicking game

Chandler Catanzaro hopes to bring continuity to Bucs’ kicking game

Chandler Catanzaro understands the pressure he faces to end a long, frustrating run of disappointing kickers changed out every year by the Bucs.This fall will be the sixth straight season Tampa Bay has a different kicker than the season before, but t...
Published: 03/16/18
Beau knows: Allen will be a perfect fit for the Bucs defense and in the locker room

Beau knows: Allen will be a perfect fit for the Bucs defense and in the locker room

TAMPA – Beau Allen had not met a single teammate when he walked into One Buc Place to survey his new surroundings Thursday and hold an introductory news conference. But it was immediately clear, unlike recent free agents, the Eagles defensive t...
Published: 03/15/18
Report: Doug Martin signs with Raiders, Gruden

Report: Doug Martin signs with Raiders, Gruden

Former Bucs running back Doug Martin, cut loose by Tampa Bay after two straight disappointing seasons, has landed with Jon Gruden and the Oakland Raiders, NFL Network reported Thursday.Martin, 29, averaged just 2.9 yards per carry this past season, a...
Published: 03/15/18
New Bucs DT Beau Allen once wore an elephant costume on Bumble

New Bucs DT Beau Allen once wore an elephant costume on Bumble

TAMPA — Free agent defensive tackle Beau Allen is not a guy who will have a negative impact in the Bucs locker room. On the contrary, the Philadelphia Eagles credited their closeness as a team for helping them win Super Bowl LII over the Patrio...
Published: 03/15/18
How Day 1 of free agency affects Bucs

How Day 1 of free agency affects Bucs

TAMPA — The rest of the NFC South, much like the Bucs, had a quiet, low-key start to free agency.But a few seemingly easier games on the Bucs' 2018 schedule got tougher, with opponents that have been among the most active in upgrading their ros...
Published: 03/14/18
Bucs have low-key start to free agency

Bucs have low-key start to free agency

TAMPA — A run-stuffing, rotational defensive tackle from the Super Bowl champion Eagles. Another one from the Bears. A Jets place-kicker. A starting center/guard from the Ravens is visiting.Those were the Bucs' headliners when the NFL's free ag...
Published: 03/14/18
Bucs agree to terms with Bears defensive lineman Mitch Unrein

Bucs agree to terms with Bears defensive lineman Mitch Unrein

The Bucs continued to load up on run-stuffing defensive linemen Wednesday, agreeing to terms on a three-year contract with Bears free agent Mitch Unrein.The 3o-year-old Unrein played defensive end in the Bears 3-4 defense but will play defensive tack...
Published: 03/14/18
Bucs to sign ex-Cards, Jets kicker Chandler Catanzaro

Bucs to sign ex-Cards, Jets kicker Chandler Catanzaro

For the sixth year in a row, the Bucs now look to have a different kicker than they did the year before.Tampa Bay is signing former Cardinals and Jets kicker Chandler Catanzaro, whose strong leg should help the Bucs on kickoffs — and hopefully ...
Published: 03/14/18