Monday, December 11, 2017
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Commentary: Letting New York Giants score was a Super flop

Wait a minute. Let's rewind the Giants' last possession for the sake of debate. Let's suck Ahmad Bradshaw out of the end zone and return him to the backfield, put 1:04 on the clock, stick the ball on the 6 and correct the score so the Patriots still lead 17-15 with a single timeout dangling.

Let's suit you with a hoodie and headphones and send you to the Patriots' sideline.

Let's say you know about Win Probability (a simple estimate of who's going to win based on score and other variables), and that some geeks in the booth have been running numbers for you all game. You know that in this position, with barely a minute left, every second the Giants bleed off the clock before attempting a sure-thing field goal to go up by one point decreases your probability of winning.

But if you tell your defense to lie down, tell it even to help the Giants score, you suddenly have a better shot, percentages say, of getting your offense on the field, scoring and kissing the cheerleaders.

What do you do?

Take a dive, let the Giants score and hope your offense can go 80 in less than a minute?

Or tell your defense that it all comes down to the next few plays and you'd better not let them score, not by run or by kick, because the world is watching?

We know what Bill Belichick did. He confirmed it after his Patriots lost.

"Right," he said when asked if his team had let Bradshaw score.

Some loved the move. Headlines on Deadspin and Slate: The Ballsiest Call In Super Bowl History. But that's exactly backward.

Being ordered to let the other team score — even if the numbers suggest it's the right thing to do — goes against a player's every instinct, especially when it means letting the other team take the lead.

The riskier call would be to forget the percentages. The riskier call would be to let your defense do what it does: try to keep the Giants out of the end zone and pray you get a hand on the ball when they attempt a field goal.

Others felt like the call was a monumental shift in American football, a game that in its purest form has two chief pursuits: to score, and to stop the other team from scoring. Football has rarely been a game where it's better to go backward.

It wasn't the first time a defense has taken a dive. Who remembers The Gator Flop from 1971? That's when Florida's defensive players dove to their bellies on the field to let Miami score so Florida's John Reaves could set a passing record. In 1998, Green Bay allowed Denver to score from a yard out to get the ball back earlier, but Brett Favre couldn't score on the final chance.

But Sunday's call was an obvious relinquishing of those time-honored principles of unadulterated, belief-based football. And it was on the sport's main stage. If that's okay, to let the other team score, where does it end? If you buy into Win Probability, the smartest play would've been for the Patriots to have given up a touchdown earlier, even as early as the two-minute warning.

What worth is a defense if it lacks the faith that it can force a turnover, or block a kick? What were the chances Ravens kicker Billy Cundiff would miss a tying 32-yard kick, sending the Patriots to Super Bowl XLVI?

Belichick's call changes football. Expect to see more, for better or for worse.

Ben Montgomery played defensive back for Division II Arkansas Tech University, which was Gulf South Conference champion in 1999.

Comments
Explosives? On 40-yard plays, Bucs among NFL’s worst

Explosives? On 40-yard plays, Bucs among NFL’s worst

Bucs coach Dirk Koetter has key statistics that he puts great value in, finding a close correlation between success in those areas and success on the scoreboard. Winning the takeaway battle is always first among those priorities, but he and his staff...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Bucs Cannon Fodder podcast: Another close game that got away

Bucs Cannon Fodder podcast: Another close game that got away

In his latest Cannon Fodder podcast, Greg Auman looks back on the Bucs’ 24-21 loss to the Lions, Gerald McCoy’s injury, reports of Jameis Winston-Dirk Koetter friction and another close game that got away from Tampa Bay on the way to a 4-9 record. Li...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Rick and Tom podcast: Do Jameis Winston and Dirk Koetter get along?

Rick and Tom podcast: Do Jameis Winston and Dirk Koetter get along?

The Bucs guarantee another losing season after turning the ball over five times in a 24-21 loss to the Lions. In their latest podcast, Rick Stroud and Tom Jones talk about how the Bucs stayed in the game until the end despite a non-existent pass rush...
Updated: 4 hours ago
The Jameis Winston-Dirk Koetter relationship: It’s complicated

The Jameis Winston-Dirk Koetter relationship: It’s complicated

  TAMPA — There are lies, damn lies and statistics, none of which are working in favor of Jameis Winston and Dirk Koetter avoiding a split in the near future. Even before the Bucs turned the football over five times and lost to the Detroit Li...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Report: Jameis Winston-Dirk Koetter relationship ‘is not in a good place’

Report: Jameis Winston-Dirk Koetter relationship ‘is not in a good place’

Jameis Winston is displeased with how coach Dirk Koetter has handled Winston's shoulder injury and the Bucs offense, according to an NFL Network report Sunday. “The relationship between quarterback Jameis Winston and Koetter is not in a good p...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Jones: Why Bucs coach Dirk Koetter won’t survive this

Jones: Why Bucs coach Dirk Koetter won’t survive this

  TAMPA — Dirk Koetter isn’t going to return as coach of the Bucs next season. That’s not official. No announcement has been made. No press conference is scheduled. It’s not an absolute fact. Not yet. And this isn’t a...
Updated: 8 hours ago
NFL Week 14: What we learned

NFL Week 14: What we learned

Aaron Rodgers is ready to return, but is he needed in Green Bay? Backup QB Brett Hundley is 2-0 in OT; Rodgers is 1-7. The Pack has its Mr. Clutch, right? Yeah, right. Its 27-21 OT win at Cleveland keeps it alive for a wild-card spot. Mr. Rodgers, yo...
Published: 12/10/17
Bucs-Lions journal: Backup lineman was most unlikely of targets

Bucs-Lions journal: Backup lineman was most unlikely of targets

TAMPA — The Bucs’ unlikely comeback to erase a 14-point deficit in the fourth quarter was capped by the most unlikely of targets. Tampa Bay tied the game when Jameis Winston threw a 2-yard pass to 305-pound Leonard Wester, a backup lineman who lined ...
Published: 12/10/17
Gerald McCoy leaves game with shoulder/bicep injury

Gerald McCoy leaves game with shoulder/bicep injury

Bucs defensive tackle Gerald McCoy left Sunday's  game against the Lions in the second quarter with an injury to his shoulder/biceps muscle. The team says his return is doubtful.The Bucs were tied 7-7 with the Lions when McCoy was sidelined. He'...
Published: 12/10/17
Fennelly: Gerald McCoy’s lost season may be over

Fennelly: Gerald McCoy’s lost season may be over

TAMPA — It was the face of a losing season.Gerald McCoy’s tearful, contorted face.Up there on the video boards at Raymond James Stadium. On your TV screen. Everywhere."I’m not a quitter," McCoy said. "I don’t play to lose."The Bucs lost their ninth g...
Published: 12/10/17